|Dec 21, 2012, 09:01 AM||#1|
Blizzard FPS issues
I have been playing WoW for a long time. I have seen many mac issues get pushed aside but this is unacceptable.
Since the release of MoP I have not been able to play because my FPS flucuate and drop even on the lowest setting.
I tried getting help in the blizzard forum. Only to be told it was my hardware and to contact apple. This was suggested after the various fixes they threw at me did not work.
I do not believe this to be a problem with hardware but something seriously wrong with the game and it is not being addressed.
My posts have since been removed from the blizzard forums and there is nothing more I can say there.
I know to some it might seem silly but I left behind a lot of people. I was an officer, I had many duties, spent many hours leveling and gearing many toons, helping others out and this is how blizzard treats me.
At this point I dont know what else to do. I am just trying to get the word out that there that something is wrong. I have even contacted wow.joystiq.com but have not heard back.
Any input, knowledge, who to contact regarding this would be greatly appreciated.
|Dec 21, 2012, 09:20 AM||#2|
same here - wrote a lot - nothing happened!
here is my story in short form:
had an imac with core 2 duo and a ati radeon x1600 with 256 mb memory
played the SC2 beta not full but in a native resolution with med low details!
2010 i bought a mid 2010 imac with 2,93 ghz ati 5740 1Gb 27" 16 GB Ram.
when i first played SC2 when it came out it ran maxed out in native resolution. after the 10.6 open GL patch from apple it ran even better.
wow in there days ran maxed out with about 40-60fps without any troubles.
after a few moths sc2 was patched. it never ever ran as smooth as it was before.
april 2012 a bought a mid 2011 27" imac maxed out 2b Ati 6970m and so on.
Wow with Cata ran maxed out with about 60-80fps in SW and a little slow down in raids ...
SC2 ran even worst.
i bought Diablo 3 ... what shall i say ... from the beta on this game never ever ran on a mac under OSX
today: D3 stutters like hell
SC2 stutters like hell
wow i unplayable with the settings from cata
conclusio: every of theses games look worst than they did when they ran. now Sc2 looks like on my old 2006 Core 2 Duo, wow looks like BC times on a G4 mini and Diablo ist just a cheap joke!!!
i will never ever buy oder play any blizz game - never EVER !!!!
ps. forget their tech forum - even a monkey is able to repeat SMC RESET - PRAM RESET and WTF Folder delete ...
|Dec 21, 2012, 09:49 AM||#5|
the issue is not a hardware or a software issue
The issue is your still playing WoW,
Its LONG past its best before date, has been since the expansions started ruining the main game by making it possible to get from level 1 to max in a day of grinding..
Death to XP curve changes, dungeon, raid and battlefield teleporting queues...
bring back the days when you had to get a group for scarlett monastery and ride forth , none of this pokemon crap.
on a more serious note, i have a friend whos better half is still addicted to WoW and she complains all the time about the performance, turns out its the 97.3 billion addons shes running.. try disabling all the addons and see what happens.
iWatch in action http://media.joe.ie/wp-content/uploa...ael-Knight.jpg
MacBook Pro/iPad Mini/TV1/iMac/iPhone5
|Jan 4, 2013, 12:27 PM||#6|
iPhone 6 64GB | 27" iMac 3.2GHz, 16GB RAM, 1TB FD, 680MX | iPad 2 32GB
|Dec 21, 2012, 11:30 AM||#7|
tried everything ... clean install and so on ... to the mbp ... do you play it in native resoltion of the 27" inch iMac? if you have retina try it an tell me that theses games run smooth...
the problem is these games except D3 ran awesome under osx. the look the same but the fps is much less of what it was...
that is the shame. if you play all these games in win 7 they run (except D3) with good FPS...
open GL of 10.8 is worst than 10.7 is worst than 10.6 ...
is just my opinion ...
|Dec 21, 2012, 06:29 PM||#8|
I hear graphic card drivers that came with Mountain Lion made many games unplayable to some extent. Developers have a hard time figuring out a workaround to make these games running well again and simply blame for this, hence their "Call-APPLE" response.
Since is pushing sales of the top of the line models, it's possible that releasing new graphic card drivers for any Mac older than 2012 is pretty down on their list.
Anyway, I own the 17" 2010 Macbook Pro and must say that all Blizzard games run really well.
WoW runs a bit worse in some MoP areas, but the performance there can be improved by some minor tweaking.
I can get a decent framerate in both D3 and SC2, running with almost everything on high.
Last edited by SingularityG; Jan 19, 2013 at 12:53 PM.
|Dec 21, 2012, 09:19 PM||#9|
Im not sure it has anything to do with pushing mac sales because there are plenty of people with newer models that are experiencing the same thing.
to be honest I am not sure what the problem really is but from what I have dealt with in the blizzard forums I just feel like it could have been handled better.
I followed all of their possible fixes. some even multiple times and it made no change in the issue.
I was averaging around 90fps just regular dungeons and around 60-70 in 25man but something happened and it wasnt just on the release of MoP.
I played MoP for 2 days without any issues but by the 3rd night I logged in and thats when the FPS issue started.
Anyway I do appreciate the comments and I am happy for those of you that are able to play.
|Dec 21, 2012, 10:00 PM||#10|
I'm sorry, but thit is a bad example of a thread asking for help. It contains absolutely no information for people to work with. No tech specs, no details on when, where and under what conditions do fps drop, no listing of what fixes did you try, etc, etc. Its all just bashing Blizz.
My WoW videos
13" Retina MacBook Pro 2.4 GHz | 8 GB | 256 GB | Intel Iris
|Dec 22, 2012, 05:13 AM||#12|
Anyway, if the performance drop occurred just like that from one day to the next and there was no MoP update at the time, then it really might not be anything wrong with the game itself.
If other similarly demanding games run fine, it's probably not the hardware, but it could be Apps in the background, Energy Saver, something with the WoW's cache or plug-ins, new OS X update and basically anything else that was changed during that time (which is not helping, at all).
Also note that only the new MoP areas are more demanding on the hardware. When you go to older areas, the performance is the same as before.
Have you tried bootcamping WoW?
|Dec 22, 2012, 06:32 AM||#13|
Had the same problem
I had the same problem a litle while ago. It started after the first patch of pandaria (can't remember the one). I tried everything from reinstalling the game to reinstalling the os.
Eventually i found two ways to make it work:
1 Adding more ram to the system. I upgraded to 10GB of ram which seemed to fix the problem. (I play on a 2007 mac pro)
2 bootcamp with windows.
My computer is a 2007 mac pro with 10GB of ram and a ATI Radeon hd5770. Playing under OSX gave me 50-60 fps on "good" while playing under windows i can set everything to ultra and get the same FPS.
|Dec 22, 2012, 08:56 AM||#14|
i also see bootcamp as the best way to get good fps.
to the former poster about bashing.
there is a difference between bashing and criticising. blizz should tell customers if they want to play their games on mac the will have to face fps problems.
in my case i had to buy win7 to play sc2 and D3 as i would expect from may 2500€ imac mid 2011.
it seems apple doesn´t care much of optimizing theis drivers or what ever.
yet there is a gap! Arkham city oder Arkham asylum run like buttercream maxed out .Dirt 2 the same ... Sc2 did
so i would see a duality between blizz making a worse job and apple not caring.
i bought a mac not to use win anymore. so i like to play a few games ... have to use win again.
i wouldn´t care if the games under osx lose a few fps compared to win but playing some games make you think of a broken GPU or missing ram ...
using win shows the real game power of your machine.
apple should work on this! anyone in the 10.8.3 beta? any differences?
if you look at D3 oder SC2 it is a shame what they did to mac users ... is i said ... mid 2010 imac maxed out native res the game ran perfect even in 4v4 epic battles ... now it stutters in a lower res with low/med settings ...
gave apple my mac to check the hardware ... nothing found everything ok...
this all happens under clean install with just the games installed - after ram changes ... pram resets - chache folder deletes and so on ...
its just bad software ...
|Jan 3, 2013, 09:56 PM||#15|
Well I was getting really tired of restarting to my Bootcamp vista 64 partition to play WoW so I currently just wiped my hard drive clean of windows. I did this for several reasons including mediocre fps performance compared to my native windows laptop. I cant say the FPS was horrible but on 'high' settings it was choppy and frequently below 40fps. I read a lot of posts about the difference between Bootcamp and mac OSX performance being close so I decided to gut the hard drive and give it a go.
I am currently running Snow Leopard 10.6.8 which I read on many forums is better for gaming drivers than Lion so we shall see. I am currently downloading WoW so i'll give you my impressions soon as I can play [with full system specs]... wish me luck
PS ---> one thing I do know is that mouse cursor sucks in OSX, which i'm going to have to find a workaround for, but hoping for decent framerates!
Also as far as blizzard is concerned they have been making mac games since I have owned my first computer when Warcraft 1 was available and have always had great support for OSX. I believe the OP should include more system specs and specific FPS rates/problems.
|Jan 4, 2013, 12:41 AM||#16|
I'm not here to bash or anything.. I just need some help.
I have a uRMBP (2.7,16RAM,768) and I'm being forced to play this at a.. Well lower than what I expected resolution.
I have.. No idea how to fix this besides just putting everything on fair and lowering the resolution to something similar to 1920x1080.. It used to run perfectly fine.. But 10 addons later.. It kinda just.. Bleh.
Anyone got any ideas what I'm doing wrong?.. I'm a WoW newb.. also a Guild Wars 2 newb..
iPhone 3Gs 32 Gb,iPhone 4S 64gbMacBook Pro 15' mid2010, and future rMBP 16/768/2.7
|Jan 4, 2013, 03:45 AM||#17|
Just came back to report my fps in Mac OSX 10.6.8
Currently running a Radeon HD 6870 in a 2.8Ghz Octo Mac Pro 3.1, 4gb Ram (Don't Buy IRam, i've had multiple sticks fail and they are ignoring my warranty request) . I am running the game High-Ultra (2x Multisampling, 8x Anti-Alias) with Shadows on Low, Water on Fair, and SSAO disabled. I am averaging anywhere from 46-90 FPS in most areas. I have yet to do a 25 man raid but I will definitely let you know how that goes.
I can definitely say in Graphic Intense areas such as Vale of Eternal blossoms that my graphics are running smoother than in bootcamp Vista. I would frequently chop down to 35 fps in this area on High Setting on (1x Multisampling with Low Shadow, Low Water, & SSA disabled). My fps in this area does go lower but its a much smoother transition and hovers around 46-50 fps.
Surprisingly my Mouse is working fine and not nearly as choppy as last time I played Starcraft.
All these FPS are with the game around 81% downloaded...
Overall I am quite pleased with the OSX performance, while high burst fps is lower, the average rate is more consistent and less choppy and the anti-aliasing makes my performance suffer less in OSX than vista as well as multi-sampling. I swear the Graphics on same settings look better in OSX as well, just in Vale I was doing dailies and the smoke environment effects where actually visible and smooth. No more rebooting to Bootcamp.
Edited---> Forgot to mention 1920x1200 Resolution for all this info...
Last edited by bakeumsj; Jan 4, 2013 at 03:52 AM. Reason: Forgot Resolution
|Jan 4, 2013, 05:30 PM||#18|
i doubt there will be a possibility to play blizz games in native rezz with maxed out candy on macs these days.
search battle net forums and you will see people talking about fps problems for years now.
osx and blizz games do not fit anymore.
as i said i own a nearly maxed out mid 2011 i7 iMac
3,4 ghz 12gb ram ati 6970m 2gb
wow is not playable in raids in native res with maxed settings low and med are better
sc2 runs in low med ...
except d3 these games ran maxed out ... with ever osx update and blizz patch these games loose fps ...
a lot of users cant lie ...
|Jan 6, 2013, 08:28 AM||#19|
I'm not saying Mac will outperform windows on blizzard games but its not a whiteout either. I am running a 5 year old machine with Xeon processors not optimized for gaming and my ram is only 4 gigs and I'm on average getting 50 fps on high settings in WOW so clearly something is not going right. Have you tried smc fan control? Is your hard drive full? Are you expecting to run this game on ultra settings with shadows ssao and water effects on high at 2600x1600 resolution? Perhaps it really is something with Blizzard or the Osx video drivers but I suspect a lot of this is operator error...
|Jan 7, 2013, 06:27 PM||#20|
xeon machine - so Mac Pro? these macs used to have desktop gpus. friend of mine also 4 year old mp with ati 4870 i think. this card outperforms my ati 6970m with 4 times the ram of his card.
thats point one.
all the blizz games are native. if you compare them to their win versions u loose fps under osx. in some strange cases some people tell they win fps in osx. i doubt that.
as i said - sc2 ran perfect maxed out on my machine. the fps jump from 90 to 10 to 40 to 3 and so on. in d3 you loose 20-30 fps compared to win and geht rubber banding and stuttering also in lower resolutions under osx.
wow is a special case ... i will not comment that piece of sh**t.
blizz and apple give a **** on drivers ... the devs have to look on gpu drivers and speed in every second update. nothing happens.
to be honest ... i loose hope playing games on mac which look good an run smooth...
bootcamp sadly is the answer ...
user error? omg?
|Jan 8, 2013, 12:27 PM||#21|
iPhone 3Gs 32 Gb,iPhone 4S 64gbMacBook Pro 15' mid2010, and future rMBP 16/768/2.7
|Jan 26, 2013, 02:12 PM||#22|
hey guys try to keep this thread alive.
anyone heard the rumors about 10.8.3 and much better support and drivers for amd cards?
any tests with games about an fps increase under 10.8.3?
would be nice if apple worked on that issue.
|Feb 11, 2013, 12:36 PM||#23|
installed 10.8.2 again cause of troubles with my machine.
d3 and sc2 didn´t improve regarding fps and stuttering.
would be really nice to hear good news about 10.8.3 and testing these games ...
|Feb 11, 2013, 02:54 PM||#24|
The zones in MOP are more resource intensive it seems. I run on max settings, 1920x1080, and get between 75 and 90 fps in most areas. Dungeons are the best, I get upwards of 160 fps reported.
MOP outdoor zones are the worst, down to 40-ish.
Mac Pro 5,1; Radeon 5870; 2.8GHz Quad, 32GB RAM, game and OS running off a Samsung SSD.
I own stuff.
|Jun 7, 2013, 05:06 PM||#25|
I don't know if this will help anyone with these particular games, but I was getting weird stutters in Call of Duty 2 and 4 on my Mac Mini and it seemed like there was a correlation to hard drive activity (loading something new while playing would be when it would suddenly stutter for a moment). I have a RAID0 setup (which you would think would be better since it's faster) and by testing with a regular drive, I found the problem was worse with the RAID drive and that confirmed the hard drive (or driver) had something to do with the stuttering (not the GPU, which when it was not stuttering was completely smooth).
I found a suggestion on a Diablo 3 forum to get rid of hard drive related stutters (supposedly Diablo 3 is just awful in this regard, especially in multi-player; I don't know since I don't have the game). But I took their suggestion and tried with Call of Duty 2 and 4 and they are now 100% stutter free (just like users reported with Diablo3).
The key is to get a good sized USB thumb drive (they were using USB2 models, which makes even less sense when you consider the speed constraint, but apparently the stutter is not due to absolute read speed) and then copy the game folder over to that drive and run it off the thumb drive instead of your hard drive. They claimed Diablo3 was then magically stutter free. Many called BS on it, but others confirmed it.
I was in need of another thumb drive anyway, so I figured I'd try it out with Call of Duty 2 & 4 and so I bought a SanDisk 32GB USB3 thumb drive (much faster than a USB2 one, although still slower than my RAID0 setup; although random access may be better) and loaded them onto it. They are both now 100% stutter free. No more audio cutouts or frame pauses. It's SO much better. Since the saved games are still in the home directory somewhere, I don't even have to worry about copying back any data when I'm done. I can just erase the thumb drive folders and put something else on there and copy them back again if I want to play them again at some time in the future.
This may or may not solve your problems with various Blizzard games. It depends on what is causing it, but seeing as this supposedly fixed Diablo 3 for a bunch of folks and it certainly fixed Call of Duty here, it may be worth a try, particularly if you already have a thumb drive lying around.
Mac Mini Server 2012 (2.3GHz Quad i7, 8GB, 2x1TB RAID 0) ; External 12x Memorex Blu-Ray USB3, External WD 3x3TB,1x2TB HD USB3)
15" Matte MBP 2.4GHz, 4GB/500GB, NVidia 8600M GT; 3 ATV; 3 iPod Touch
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|mixing 24 fps clips with 25 fps||2ms||Digital Video||1||Feb 6, 2014 09:26 AM|
|15" rMBP FPS Gaming Issues||bniedzj||MacBook Pro||12||Dec 30, 2013 02:57 PM|
|FPS/Lag issues with GTA IV PC Version||john925||Windows, Linux & Others on the Mac||0||Apr 4, 2013 10:13 PM|
|OS-neutral: "If Quake was done today" (modern FPS vs classic FPS)||Idgit||Mac and PC Games||32||Jan 12, 2013 09:23 PM|
|Suden game performance issues, Any game drops to low fps after 10-15min||LaDirection||Mac and PC Games||8||Oct 5, 2012 12:55 AM|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:28 AM.