Which of these Mac games work with a PS3 controller?

[Amnesiac1]

I repeat, these are running on MacOSX Leopard, not Windows via Bootcamp.

• Left 4 Dead
• Left 4 Dead 2
• Trine
• Braid
• Portal 2
• Team Fortress 2

Thanks.

[Cougarcat]

You mean Snow Leopard, right? Portal 2 and Left 4 Dead 2 require it.

Braid and Trine have controller support on the Mac, so I assume it would work. If you play the other games online with a controller your teammates will murder you.

[cerote]

With GamePad Companion from the Appstore they all do. Got both L4Ds going and Portal setup myself on my iMac. Even have Torchlight going too.

Wirelessly at that.

Was well worth the 8$.

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by Cougarcat

You mean Snow Leopard, right? Portal 2 and Left 4 Dead 2 require it.

Braid and Trine have controller support on the Mac, so I assume it would work. If you play the other games online with a controller your teammates will murder you.

Really? So, it's a bad idea to play Left 4 Dead or Portal 2 with a controller? Seriously, now... why?

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by cerote

With GamePad Companion from the Appstore they all do. Got both L4Ds going and Portal setup myself on my iMac. Even have Torchlight going too.

Wirelessly at that.

Was well worth the 8$.

What is Torchlight?

Also, how do you find playing L4D 1 & 2 a well as Portal 2 via a PS3 controller?

[Cougarcat]

Originally Posted by Amnesiac1

What is Torchlight?

Torchlight is an action RPG similar to Diablo II (made by many of the same developers.)

Originally Posted by Amnesiac1

Really? So, it's a bad idea to play Left 4 Dead or Portal 2 with a controller? Seriously, now... why?

Because a keyboard and mouse is far more accurate. You will only hinder your team. Since Portal 2 is largely single player, and a puzzle game, it doesn't matter so much.

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by Cougarcat

Torchlight is an action RPG similar to Diablo II (made by many of the same developers.)



Because a keyboard and mouse is far more accurate. You will only hinder your team. Since Portal 2 is largely single player, and a puzzle game, it doesn't matter so much.

Hm. You're saying it is not at all possible to attain a degree of accuracy with a PS3 controller that is commensurate with the degree of accuracy afforded by a mouse and keyboard?

Since the GamePad Companion app is only $7.99, I might as well purchase it and see what feels most comfortable...

Also, FYI, despite everyone laughing at the very notion of using a trackpad for gaming, I find it works wonderfully. I've been using the trackpad and keyboard to play Team Fortress 2 and it grants a certain comfort and ease that I don't get with a keyboard... moving the mouse around doesn't feel as great or effective as simply moving my fingers about on the trackpad.

I'll see if the PS3 controller is an improvement, though.

[Sambo110]

Yeah, you lose SO much accuracy with a controller, it's next to impossible to aim well. Remember that console games have a lot of auto aim, whereas PC's have none too.

And he is right, it is impossible to get as good accuracy with a controller. Microsoft once tested it, they got average PC players to play against pro xbox players. The xbox players got absolutely smashed.

[edddeduck]

Originally Posted by Amnesiac1

Hm. You're saying it is not at all possible to attain a degree of accuracy with a PS3 controller that is commensurate with the degree of accuracy afforded by a mouse and keyboard?

Since the GamePad Companion app is only $7.99, I might as well purchase it and see what feels most comfortable...

Also, FYI, despite everyone laughing at the very notion of using a trackpad for gaming, I find it works wonderfully. I've been using the trackpad and keyboard to play Team Fortress 2 and it grants a certain comfort and ease that I don't get with a keyboard... moving the mouse around doesn't feel as great or effective as simply moving my fingers about on the trackpad.

I'll see if the PS3 controller is an improvement, though.

Please note that the PS3 gamepad works as a standard gamepad (no drivers needed) in Snow Leopard 10.6 but in Leopard 10.5 the gamepad does not function correctly.

I don't know about the specific games you listed but if they support gamepads in the standard manner then they should all work fine in 10.6 but as I said in 10.5 I think you will have trouble as the PS3 support is not complete.

Edwin

[SlickShoes]

If you are not playing the games competitively then there is no need to go down the kayboard and mouse route.

I play on my laptop on the sofa with no real space for a mouse, a gamepad is way comfier and I don't get hand cramps from holding the mouse either.

You will not be as accurate, but you can still compete. L4D Portal and Team Fortress are fine, Counter Strike you will get owned using a controller by KB and mouse players.

As long as you are not looking to be top of the scoreboard every time a gamepad is more than fine.

That being said I still can't get mine to work with TF2 on OSX, only in windows does it seem to work for me.

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by edddeduck

Please note that the PS3 gamepad works as a standard gamepad (no drivers needed) in Snow Leopard 10.6 but in Leopard 10.5 the gamepad does not function correctly.

I don't know about the specific games you listed but if they support gamepads in the standard manner then they should all work fine in 10.6 but as I said in 10.5 I think you will have trouble as the PS3 support is not complete.

Edwin

I have Snow Leopard 10.6. So, do I need to buy the GamePad Companion app still or...?

[edddeduck]

Originally Posted by Amnesiac1

I have Snow Leopard 10.6. So, do I need to buy the GamePad Companion app still or...?

If the game supports gamepads then no, I usually avoid Gamepad companion unless the game has no pad support. If the game has pad support it is better to use the build in support.

Edwin

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by edddeduck

If the game supports gamepads then no, I usually avoid Gamepad companion unless the game has no pad support. If the game has pad support it is better to use the build in support.

Edwin

I see. That returns me to my original question, then. Do any of the games listed in the first post of this thread have built-in pad support?

[Cougarcat]

Originally Posted by Amnesiac1

I see. That returns me to my original question, then. Do any of the games listed in the first post of this thread have built-in pad support?

As I said, Braid and Trine do.

[Amnesiac1]

Originally Posted by Cougarcat

As I said, Braid and Trine do.

What about the others?

[Cougarcat]

According to their product pages, they do. TF2 is free now, so why not try it?

[ibc99]

Originally Posted by cerote

With GamePad Companion from the Appstore they all do. Got both L4Ds going and Portal setup myself on my iMac. Even have Torchlight going too.

Wirelessly at that.

Was well worth the 8$.

please please PLEASE let me know what your Gamepad Companion layout is for torchlight. In particular the movement. can't seem to get the joystick to function as movement.

[cerote]

Originally Posted by ibc99

please please PLEASE let me know what your Gamepad Companion layout is for torchlight. In particular the movement. can't seem to get the joystick to function as movement.

I don't have it setup as movement but have a trigger button setup as mouse click to move. So the joystick moves the mouse and use the trigger to click to move.

Will double check when I get home.

[ibc99]

Originally Posted by cerote

I don't have it setup as movement but have a trigger button setup as mouse click to move. So the joystick moves the mouse and use the trigger to click to move.

Will double check when I get home.

i would greatly appreciate it. i can't seem to get the controller to control the mouse...it just flies off toward the corner as soon as i turn it on.

[cerote]

Originally Posted by ibc99

i would greatly appreciate it. i can't seem to get the controller to control the mouse...it just flies off toward the corner as soon as i turn it on.

I have the left analog set for up down to y axis mouse up/down
for left and right push x axis set to right/left

I have the left analog set for up down to z-rotation multiple keys j q
And right and left push to z-axis multiple buttons s p