New RMBP's coming with Samsung screens?

[Schranke]

I have a customized rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/256 wait to be opened back at home. Will look-up the screen when i get home tomorrow.
Hope for a good screen, since i need to work with graphic and pictures.

[Mac-Tech]

Originally Posted by Schranke

I have a customized rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/256 wait to be opened back at home. Will look-up the screen when i get home tomorrow.
Hope for a good screen, since i need to work with graphic and pictures.

This is the spec rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/768 I am going to order and I hope by the time I order mine all the LG's would be gone. I am thinking end of this month I will place my order and HOPE HOPE I get a Samsung display....

I really thought after Nov 24th anyone who BTO would end up with a Samsung screen automatically...I guess thats not the case anymore....

----------

Originally Posted by AndyDiamond

CTO 2.7/16/768
Ordered 23 Nov

LG screen

Do you think if you waited until the end of Nov 30th you would have got the Samsung screen? I just figured they would have got all the LG out of the factory by now....and stick with Samsung until they resolve the issue with LG screens...... This is why we need STEVE JOBS!!! No one can do it like him...

[anode]

I have a rMBP 15", manufactured 2012/11/08 that has the Samsung screen.

It was ordered on black friday, drop shipped from China, delivered the following Friday.

[Mac-Tech]

Originally Posted by millerrh

Just got mine Friday and it's got an LG.

Can you return it and ask for a Samsung either calling Apple or going into the store if its less then 14days? I mean they can not deny you for that right? Instead of them replacing the LG panel with a Samsung Screen....

----------

Originally Posted by anode

I have a rMBP 15", manufactured 2012/11/08 that has the Samsung screen.

It was ordered on black friday, drop shipped from China, delivered the following Friday.

You got lucky.... =) Whats the difference if it comes from China or California?

[anode]

I suppose that the manufacturing date is what is important.

If it came from a California distribution center, the manufacturing date may not have been as recent as the one from China.

[Mac-Tech]

Originally Posted by anode

I suppose that the manufacturing date is what is important.

If it came from a California distribution center, the manufacturing date may not have been as recent as the one from China.

So are you saying that if it came from California then its LG and if it came from China its Samsung?

[anode]

I'm saying that mine was manufactured on November 8, 2012, ordered on November 23, 2012, was shipped to me from a distribution center in China, and it came with the Samsung display.

I don't know if they are installing LG screens one day and Samsung the next. If they are exclusively using the Samsung screens now, then getting a unit that was manufactured in November is a good thing.

If there is older stock in other distribution centers, then that might explain why someone who placed an order around the same time, might get one with an LG screen.

I've ordered a number of Apple computers over the years. The first being an Apple II in 1979. This is the first one that wasn't shipped from California.

[millerrh]

I got one manufactured in November (week 48) and it has an LG screen. So they are still using both.

[jlin615]

rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/768. Samsung here.

[nyle]

15" BTO week 48 received today - Samsung

[Mac-Tech]

Originally Posted by jlin615

rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/768. Samsung here.

NICE! This is the same spec I am going to order soon...fingers crossed for a Samsung!!!

----------

Originally Posted by nyle

15" BTO received today - Samsung

This is good NEWS!!! I really hope they only supply a Samsung panel with BTO!!

[Golfer00ksu]

Originally Posted by millerrh

I got one manufactured in November (week 48) and it has an LG screen. So they are still using both.

Same here.

[ixodes]

Originally Posted by AppleMacFinder

BTO (Built-To-Order) - when you choose standard configuration
CTO (Customized-To-Order) - when you choose some additional upgrades as well

Please refrain from guessing when you don't know what you're talking about.

It misleads people that are honest & ask for help.

Thank you.

[skydesigner]

Today I got my third (!) rMBP. First two where Samsungs screens. But had very bad screen uniformity (yellow edges).
This time (always the same config: 2,3/16/256) I got an LG. No IR after 10 minutes. But its not as bright and it also doesn´t have a uniform screen. The middle is significant brighter as the left and especially the right side.

I´ll send this one back, too and forget about the rMBP. I mean... for 1000 EUR you might accept that is is not perfect. And I truely believe you could just use it and WORK..... but this thing is so expansive. I want it to be perfect. Otherwise I could really buy a 700 EUR (I´m from Germany) notebook.

[monkeybagel]

Originally Posted by skydesigner

Today I got my third (!) rMBP. First two where Samsungs screens. But had very bad screen uniformity (yellow edges).
This time (always the same config: 2,3/16/256) I got an LG. No IR after 10 minutes. But its not as bright and it also doesn´t have a uniform screen. The middle is significant brighter as the left and especially the right side.

I´ll send this one back, too and forget about the rMBP. I mean... for 1000 EUR you might accept that is is not perfect. And I truely believe you could just use it and WORK..... but this thing is so expansive. I want it to be perfect. Otherwise I could really buy a 700 EUR (I´m from Germany) notebook.

Are you ordering these things from Apple directly? How are they handling the excessive exchanges?

I really look for Apple to reinstate a restocking fee before long. It's hard to believe the number of exchanges and returns people make on this forum. To each their own, but I am surprised they don't start refusing exchanges after few and say "it's clear we don't have a product that is meeting your needs."

[skydesigner]

Originally Posted by monkeybagel

Are you ordering these things from Apple directly? How are they handling the excessive exchanges?

I really look for Apple to reinstate a restocking fee before long. It's hard to believe the number of exchanges and returns people make on this forum. To each their own, but I am surprised they don't start refusing exchanges after few and say "it's clear we don't have a product that is meeting your needs."

I´ve to admit there lays truth in your saying. On the other hand: they should establish better QC to make sure they are all at the same VERY high level. But they are not and still they charge a big premium.
My post was just as information for others. I don´t want to start (another) discussion about that.

[monkeybagel]

Originally Posted by skydesigner

I´ve to admit there lays truth in your saying. On the other hand: they should establish better QC to make sure they are all at the same VERY high level. But they are not and still they charge a big premium.
My post was just as information for others. I don´t want to start (another) discussion about that.

But how are they handling them? What are you telling them? Do they comment about the number you have made, or are they just nice and say here is a shipping label?

[Schranke]

Originally Posted by Schranke

I have a customized rMBP 15" 2.7Ghz/16GB/256 wait to be opened back at home. Will look-up the screen when i get home tomorrow.
Hope for a good screen, since i need to work with graphic and pictures.

Reporting back since i just opened the new
Got a Samsung, so I am Happy
ordered it on black friday

[iPersian]

Originally Posted by Golfer00ksu

Same here.

was it a BTO?

[millerrh]

Originally Posted by iPersian

was it a BTO?

BTO = Build To Order. It means one of the custom configurations and not the kind they sell in the retail store.

[AndyDiamond]

so what's the big deal about LG vs Samsung anyway?

My (LG) screen looks freakin' awesome - I don't give ***** about who made it quite frankly. I think you guys have to much time on your trainspotting hands!

[millerrh]

Originally Posted by AndyDiamond

so what's the big deal about LG vs Samsung anyway?

My (LG) screen looks freakin' awesome - I don't give ***** about who made it quite frankly. I think you guys have to much time on your trainspotting hands!

It's not a brand flame-war. It's that LGs have exhibited a ghosting/image retention problem, where Samsungs have not. So people want to see if they are susceptible to the issue.

[AndyDiamond]

Originally Posted by millerrh

It's not a brand flame-war. It's that LGs have exhibited a ghosting/image retention problem, where Samsungs have not. So people want to see if they are susceptible to the issue.

I understand - are you saying anyone with an LG screen should send it back?

[millerrh]

Originally Posted by AndyDiamond

I understand - are you saying anyone with an LG screen should send it back?

Some people may choose to. Others might just choose to keep an eye out for the issue so they know to take it in for repair. I myself got an LG and am going to sit on it until the return period expires to see if I notice the issue.

One thing people are saying is that it sometimes takes a fair amount of time (2 months or so) for it to develop. But that once it does, it goes downhill real quick. Many people have received replacement LG after replacement LG all exhibiting the issue. So much so, I'm led to believe almost 100% of LGs will have this at some point unless there is some new data that shows newer ones are fixed somehow.

Some other people have had issues with Apple saying these faulty displays are really within spec. This is my big concern. There's no way I will find any sort of IR acceptable. I will likely exchange my computer at the end of the return period even if I don't see it just on the faith that it will develop at some point and the worry that Apple won't stand by their product.

[KevinC867]

Originally Posted by AndyDiamond

so what's the big deal about LG vs Samsung anyway?

My (LG) screen looks freakin' awesome - I don't give ***** about who made it quite frankly...

I understand your point. My LG screen was also fantastic on day one, and I wasn't looking for problems. However, after a few months it exhibited the image retention problem pretty strongly. It was annoying to watch a video and continue to see text that was on the screen previously. I brought it in last Friday and Apple replaced it with a Samsung display. I now feel more secure about the future of this display and the resale value of my machine.

I believe that most LG displays are probably fine, and Apple seems to be taking care of the folks with bad ones, so there doesn't seem to be a need for folks with working LG displays to try to return them. The only nagging questions are whether the problem might sometimes appear after the warranty is over, rather than after just a few months. Also, the effect on resale value is a question, but it's hard to say how many buyers would be aware of the IR issue.