I have no confidence in an iTV device. First off, it doesn't need to exist. Noone's made the case yet that it would give you a better experience than the current ATV3 connected to your own HDTV. All the content deals that would make or break an iTV could also come to market for the existing ATV3 (just like they did with HBO Go and ESPN).
Secondly, if Apple releases some uber-TV that's 4K/3D/240 Hz, in a 46" OLED screen that retails for $9,000, what good does that do for those of us who would want to use such a TV as the centerpiece of our home theater setup?It's too small for such a use. Additionally, what 4K content would you watch on it? Sony's new 4K server that retails $699 is only compatible with Sony 4K TVs, noone else's, so that's out. for Conversely, if Apple builds a 65" version with the same specs, they'd be charging over $15,000 for it.
Who'd buy that in today's economy?
Your lack of confidence wont really stop apple from moving forward with their plans (if its true)
No has made the case because it hasnt come out yet, we dont know what it will bring. Apparently commercial skipping is a rumor thats going around, something I personally would pay for. Especially now that commercials are what, about 30% of the show's time? Just the fact that it means no additional box to connect is a huge + for me; I personally prefer a single device with more features than several devices with the same features. I would kill for an iPhablet!
All we can do is speculate, but I do like how you speculate to the high end right away. I have hope still I dont see Apple anywhere near the 3D market. They have not expressed any interest in it, and I for one am grateful for that. Also, the surprising thing is that Apple is working with existing broadcasters as opposed to replacing them, so odds are they wont do anything over the top that wont be supported by the providers, so Im not so sure on the 4k screen. Size is a preference, I have a 46" TV in my living room, and more than content with it. Rumors claim 55" and 65" screen sizes. Analysts, based on rumors, price the iTV no more than $4000 (from what I recall).
But again, all these are rumors and speculations. Im convinced they are creating an iTV, especially with Tim Cook expressing "interest" in that market. Im just hoping for native live streaming from the iTV to any Apple device, that would be very convenient for me. I could ditch my slingbox and ATV. Im tired of all those cables and wires!