Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Siri's Accuracy Continues to Improve as Apple Works to Reduce Reliance on Google
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You're being ridiculous. So you're saying a person should be able to mumble, speak in a lazy manner, speak unusually fast or mispronounce words and a "computer" is suppose to fully understand a human??? GTFOH.
I also noticed this!
Probably a rounding artifact no one on the publisher's end caught.
Barry Kripke, is that you?
----------
I agree. I get close to 90% and I'm from overseas
Half the time she just says she can't help me at this time since upgrading. Way worse then IOS6 for me.
This last line really points out the true difficulty of what Apple and Google and anyone in voice recognition have to deal with. In my local dialect of Midwestern English sugar is pronounced as if there is an h after the s. Is there a pronunciation difference between aunt and ant? How about pin and pen? Is drag a regular or irregular verb? And I could go on and on for days, and this is all just within the umbrella of US English. Try adding in the various dialects of British English, Canadian English, Australian English, etc.
How about the Spanglish spoken in places like Gibraltar or Southern California where the speaker will switch mid-sentence between English and Spanish? Heck, as one poster pointed out, even humans have a hard time understanding each other a lot of the time. So, why do we expect a machine as stupid as a computer to be perfect?
Could it improve? Yeah. Will it improve? Yeah. Will it ever be perfect? Heck no.
That being said, I have to really question just how much this is really an article concerning Apple doing well. Doesn't Apple still use Nuance for the voice to text conversion which is then fed into Siri's knolwedge base search engine? If that is true then isn't an improvement in understanding what is asked an improvement for Nuance? While the drop in returning a correct response when the question is understood (nuance did its job) actually a bad thing for Apple?
It's truly amazing that Apple and Google are able to create these apps. The variation in voice, pronunciation, tone, pitch, amplitude, dialects, languages, and so on is amazing. Having a machine be able to sort this all out with such speed and accuracy is even more amazing.
I finally was able to upgrade to a 5s, and am starting to use Siri more and more every day.
I finally was able to upgrade to a 5s, and am starting to use Siri more and more every day.
Until Apple adds on-device voice parsing (like Google does) and rely less on server based transcription, Siri will never be as good and fast as Google Now.
Apple created a separate Motion coprocessor, maybe it's time for Siri to have its own chip.
Apple created a separate Motion coprocessor, maybe it's time for Siri to have its own chip.
Siri amazes me whenever I speak to her. She understands and displays every word I say well over 95% of the time, even with the TV blasting away in the background.
Offline parsing is rarely done on Android. It is there as a backup. What makes Google fast is it is able to translate it in real time and not have to wait for you to finish. You can see this happening live as it tends to guess what you say but when you are done it will go back and correct some words based on the totality of what you said.
No, I'm saying when you've got that situation, the response should be to continue to improve the technology until it can understand the way real people speak in the real world, rather than tell people they now have to speak differently. Yes, in this instance it may be beyond the bounds of what can be achieved now, but look at how limited voice recognition was 10 years ago and imagine what it could be capable of in another 10 years if driven to improve rather than just adopt the attitude that it's people who are the problem.
This has never, ever happened to me. Do you only use Siri at 2:00 a.m. when they run their updates?
LOL, do you mean from the 90's and 00's? In the 80's Math was math, no calculator or Computer allowed in class, got to learn to do calculations by hand, and do it right or else...
My experience of Siri is one of total frustration. Even simple questions like 'Give me directions to from ____ to ____' yields a totally incorrect answer about something completely unrelated. The conversational stuff shown in the adverts is just impossible and must be carefully scripted when its demonstrated. It understands the words I speak but cannot comprehend anything other than syntactically extremely basic questions. After all this time I thought it would have improved more than it has.
I like your attitude. It truly is amazing that this can be done and I also am using Siri much more since upgrading from my 4S (also switched carriers and got LTE which helped a lot).
When iOS 7 first was released, I got a bunch of "Unable to process your request" errors, but lately she has been great. My latest surprise has been asking "what's a turducken" and in < 2 seconds getting a picture and description. A recent dissapointment was being able to ask about my next appointment, but not being able to figure out how to get directions to my next appointment.
Getting a Kinivo BTC450 bluetooth adapter for my car has significantly increased my use of and dependence on SIRI
Getting a Kinivo BTC450 bluetooth adapter for my car has significantly increased my use of and dependence on SIRI
Last edited: