Thanks for sharing your valuable opinions on this.
I still can't pull the trigger...
I have gone this path many times and it's always difficult to answer, but actually I would tell you to hear what Apple's management has told Macworld this week during a small interview...
"When I walked into Apples offices for my conversation with the three executives, they noticed that I had brought a phone, a tablet, and a laptop, and had ultimately selected my MacBook Air as my tool of choice for the interview. (To write about the 30th anniversary of the Mac on an iPad would have felt like a betrayal.)
You had a bunch of tools, Federighi said, pointing at my bag. And you pulled out the one that felt right for the job that you were doing. It wasnt because it had more computing power
. You pulled it out because it was the most natural device to accomplish a task. Sometimes you want a large display, with many different windows open, and sometimes you just want to lay back on the couch or are standing at the bus stop. Theres a natural form factor that drives the optimal experience for each of those things. And I think what we are focused on is delivering the tailored, optimal experience for those kinds of ways that you work, without trying to take a one-size-fits-all solution to it."
http://www.macworld.com/article/209...he-mac-at-30-the-mac-keeps-going-forever.html
What I am trying to say is that the best advice I can give you is, use each device for what it was created for, and don't try to make it to something else, just because it is possible. Use what it feels natural to use, and don't think about it!
Having said that, I would say that for notes taking a Macbook Air is definitely better. Especially if you do a lot of copy paste you would hate an iPad...
I have a lot of devices (just look at my signature) and I use an iPad only for small tasks, nothing else. The iPad was created for specific usage scenarios and use cases, and note taking, while it is certainly possible to use it for note taking, a laptop is a much better choice. (unless you want to use handwritten notes)