Buying a Video Card - Need Help

[markjones05]

My ATI Radeon X1900 is on it's way out and I need to buy a replacement card. Problem is, I don't know what card to get. The only two cards available for my MacPro on the Apple website are the ATI Radeon X1900 and The NVIDIA Geforce 8800 GT. The guy I talked to at Applecare said that there might be other cards available for my machine at other retailers, but I'm not really sure how to shop for something like this. Ive attached my Hardware Overview below, if anyone has a similar machine or knows about video cards and can point me in the right direction I would be immensely grateful.

(FYI) I am a video editor and motion graphics artist and this is my work machine.

Hardware Overview:

Model Name: Mac Pro
Model Identifier: MacPro1,1
Processor Name: Dual-Core Intel Xeon
Processor Speed: 3 GHz
Number Of Processors: 2
Total Number Of Cores: 4
L2 Cache (per processor): 4 MB
Memory: 4 GB
Bus Speed: 1.33 GHz
Boot ROM Version: MP11.005C.B08
SMC Version (system): 1.7f10

[Tallest Skil]

Get a 4870 if you want an ATI card, either Apple's or a stock PC one (use netkas' injector so that you don't have to flash).

[gugucom]

If you see an ATI HD3870 Mac&PC Edition for good money that would be worth a grab as well. It needs a dual slot cooler but that is a 20$ upgrade anybody can do himself. The energy bill is lower than a 4870 and you have no software issues with Leopard.

[gpzjock]

I bought an ATI Sapphire HD 4870 1 GB PC card for £140 ($226) and got it flashed to contain Mac and PC drivers. Saved a fortune and it canes pro apps as well as games.
Highly recommended! ATI cards support Core Image in OS X and are the standard cards of choice for Mac Pro workhorses. It runs cool and quiet.
The info on how to do the conversion is in the link below.
Good luck and don't buy an overpriced ($349) 512 mb one from Apple, or a GTX 285 (which is only better at gaming) for $449 and is currently only available for later models.

http://forums.macrumors.com/showpost...&postcount=886

[bozz2006]

I bought insanely overpriced Radeon 4870 from Apple for my mac pro (same generation as yours). I considered buying the PC version and flashing it, but after spending a lot of time reading and a lot of time thinking about it, it wasn't worth the hassle to me. There have been lots of bugs and quirks that cost me time. In the end, I decided that in the long run, spending $350 on the Apple card is a bargain compared to those who have had issues with their flashed cards. Some people like to tinker around with and tweak their cards. I just want mine to work. And, boy, does it eve!

+1 for the Apple ATI Radeon 4870

[bearcatrp]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

I bought insanely overpriced Radeon 4870 from Apple for my mac pro (same generation as yours). I considered buying the PC version and flashing it, but after spending a lot of time reading and a lot of time thinking about it, it wasn't worth the hassle to me. There have been lots of bugs and quirks that cost me time. In the end, I decided that in the long run, spending $350 on the Apple card is a bargain compared to those who have had issues with their flashed cards. Some people like to tinker around with and tweak their cards. I just want mine to work. And, boy, does it eve!

+1 for the Apple ATI Radeon 4870

Bozz, have you stressed the card yet? Considering this card as well as the nvidia or maybe the flashed version. Don't like buggy stuff in my system so probably buy an apple one. Curious to know if the fans kick up loud when stressed.

[Harry322]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

I bought insanely overpriced Radeon 4870 from Apple for my mac pro (same generation as yours). I considered buying the PC version and flashing it, but after spending a lot of time reading and a lot of time thinking about it, it wasn't worth the hassle to me. There have been lots of bugs and quirks that cost me time. In the end, I decided that in the long run, spending $350 on the Apple card is a bargain compared to those who have had issues with their flashed cards. Some people like to tinker around with and tweak their cards. I just want mine to work. And, boy, does it eve!

+1 for the Apple ATI Radeon 4870

Sounds like I'll be going this route, too, Bozz.

Could you, or someone else, answer a few questions for me though?

1. Even though it "officially" requires a newer Mac Pro, will the 4870 still be OpenCL compatible in Snow Leopard?

2. When the 4870 is hooked up to the power supply (2 cables right?), is there still room to power a pair of Velociraptor Hard drives in the second optical bay?

Thanks!

[bozz2006]

I don't play games but I have have edited several short movies on it and tested it by playing 8 handbraked movies at the same time with quicktime and had no slowdowns, no flakiness, no problems. This is admittedly more card than I need, but my 7300GT was getting flaky and I wanted to upgrade, so I decided to go all out.

[bozz2006]

Originally Posted by Harry322

Sounds like I'll be going this route, too, Bozz.

Could you, or someone else, answer a few questions for me though?

1. Even though it "officially" requires a newer Mac Pro, will the 4870 still be OpenCL compatible in Snow Leopard?

2. When the 4870 is hooked up to the power supply (2 cables right?), is there still room to power a pair of Velociraptor Hard drives in the second optical bay?

Thanks!

I don't know about OpenCL compatible, but I imagine it will work fine. I'm not worried about that in the least.

It does have two power supplies, which plug into two ports near the airport card. I can't imagine that it would interfere with having VRs in the optical bay. Do you have them in now? Do they just use the extra SATA ports, or do they need their own power leads as well?

[Harry322]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

I don't know about OpenCL compatible, but I imagine it will work fine. I'm not worried about that in the least.

Good to hear.

Originally Posted by bozz2006

It does have two power supplies, which plug into two ports near the airport card. I can't imagine that it would interfere with having VRs in the optical bay. Do you have them in now? Do they just use the extra SATA ports, or do they need their own power leads as well?

I'm about to purchase them - and connect them to one of the macuprgrades optical bay sleds. I can't tell from the pictures on their site, but it looks like they connect to the power supply on the second optical drive - not the ports that would be occupied by the 4870.

Let's hope for the best.

Thanks for the help!

[bozz2006]

That is how I would assume that they are hooked up. Might be a good idea to give them a call and ask though.

edit: Hoping for the best!

[Harry322]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

That is how I would assume that they are hooked up. Might be a good idea to give them a call and ask though.

edit: Hoping for the best!

Thanks. I will call and ask to be sure.

One other issue that's been bugging me, especially as I calculate the costs, is whether to buy the expensive, but somewhat crippled Apple card or flash a retail one for dramatically less money.

I know which route you went Bozz, and I'm inclined to agree. But I am wondering if I purchased a 1GB 4870 with a faster clock speed, how noticeable the performance would be in Motion and FCP.

And I should note that I don't have Windows, and would rather not install it to flash the card. What are the downsides of using Netkas' injector - which doesn't require flashing, as I understand.

Thanks

[Topper]

Originally Posted by markjones05

My ATI Radeon X1900 is on it's way out and I need to buy a replacement card. Problem is, I don't know what card to get. The only two cards available for my MacPro on the Apple website are the ATI Radeon X1900 and The NVIDIA Geforce 8800 GT. The guy I talked to at Applecare said that there might be other cards available for my machine at other retailers, but I'm not really sure how to shop for something like this. Ive attached my Hardware Overview below, if anyone has a similar machine or knows about video cards and can point me in the right direction I would be immensely grateful.

(FYI) I am a video editor and motion graphics artist and this is my work machine.

ATI Radeon HD 4870 Mac Edition

If you like flashing cards and all that kind of hoopla... ATI Radeon HD 4890.
.

[Harry322]

Originally Posted by Topper

ATI Radeon HD 4870 Mac Edition

If you like flashing cards and all that kind of hoopla... ATI Radeon HD 4890.
.

Topper, does a flashed 4890 work with OpenCL?

Would a flashed 4870 for that matter?

[Muncher]

What about the new GTX 285 mac edition? Or is that not compatible with your Mac Pro?

[Harry322]

Originally Posted by Muncher

What about the new GTX 285 mac edition? Or is that not compatible with your Mac Pro?

Sadly, no. I have the 1,1 2006 Mac Pro.

So the options I'm considering are:

1. The 4870 Mac Edition - expensive, less powerful, but 100% compatible with the Mac Pro, OpenCL and any warranty-related issues I may have. The safe choice.

2. A PC version of the 4870. More powerful and cheaper. I would need to flash it, which requires Windows and boot camp - two things I don't want or know about. A great choice - but I'm worried about compatibility with OpenCL and the potential dangers of flashing.

3. A 4890. More powerful than the 4870 (?), but requires using an injector. As far as I can tell the only downside to this is that I will never see the grey apple screen while I wait for the computer to boot again (I don't care about boot camp or Windows). Is that the only downside to using Injectors?

Which of these three cards would offer the best performance in FCP and Motion? Is the 4890 worth it to someone who doesn't do Windows or gaming? Can anyone weigh in on this and help me narrow it down?

Thanks!

[Muncher]

Originally Posted by Harry322

Sadly, no. I have the 1,1 2006 Mac Pro.

So the options I'm considering are:

1. The 4870 Mac Edition - expensive, less powerful, but 100% compatible with the Mac Pro, OpenCL and any warranty-related issues I may have. The safe choice.

2. A PC version of the 4870. More powerful and cheaper. I would need to flash it, which requires Windows and boot camp - two things I don't want or know about. A great choice - but I'm worried about compatibility with OpenCL and the potential dangers of flashing.

3. A 4890. More powerful than the 4870 (?), but requires using an injector. As far as I can tell the only downside to this is that I will never see the grey apple screen while I wait for the computer to boot again (I don't care about boot camp or Windows). Is that the only downside to using Injectors?

Which of these three cards would offer the best performance in FCP and Motion? Is the 4890 worth it to someone who doesn't do Windows or gaming? Can anyone weigh in on this and help me narrow it down?

Thanks!

The 4890 is a very powerful card for someone who's not a gamer. I think the best solution for you would be to get a 4870, probably just the mac edition since you don't want to deal with flashing. On the other hand, if the 4890 is cheaper than the mac 4870, and you're feeling adventurous, you might try that instead.

[bozz2006]

Originally Posted by Muncher

. On the other hand, if the 4890 is cheaper than the mac 4870, and you're feeling adventurous, you might try that instead.

But, be prepared for a few headaches if you do. For that matter, be prepared for headaches with a flashed 4870. As I mentioned earlier, in my opinion it is definitely not worth the potential hassle. Not even close.

[Zokim]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

But, be prepared for a few headaches if you do. For that matter, be prepared for headaches with a flashed 4870. As I mentioned earlier, in my opinion it is definitely not worth the potential hassle. Not even close.

I agree, I too bought the apple 4870 for my 2,1 mac pro and I'm happy with it.

[markjones05]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

I bought insanely overpriced Radeon 4870 from Apple for my mac pro (same generation as yours). I considered buying the PC version and flashing it, but after spending a lot of time reading and a lot of time thinking about it, it wasn't worth the hassle to me. There have been lots of bugs and quirks that cost me time. In the end, I decided that in the long run, spending $350 on the Apple card is a bargain compared to those who have had issues with their flashed cards. Some people like to tinker around with and tweak their cards. I just want mine to work. And, boy, does it eve!

+1 for the Apple ATI Radeon 4870

This computer is from 2006, in the description its says:

Compatibility:

* Requires Mac Pro (Early 2009 with 1066MHz DDR3 memory) or Mac Pro (Early 2008 with 800MHz DDR2 FB-DIMM memory) with PCI Express 2.0 slot

Are you sure this will work with my MacPro????

Update: I can now no longer even work in After Effects without my entire time line dissapearing. I am looking to buy this card TODAY at a local apple store.

[bozz2006]

I confirm that it works. I have it in my 2006 Mac Pro.

[markjones05]

Originally Posted by bozz2006

I confirm that it works. I have it in my 2006 Mac Pro.

Thanks mate, Im on my way out the door!

[knightflyer99]

Let me know how it works for you as I too have an old 2006 and need to upgrade my 1900 as its becoming flaky.....

[markjones05]

Originally Posted by knightflyer99

Let me know how it works for you as I too have an old 2006 and need to upgrade my 1900 as its becoming flaky.....

Thanks to bozz2006 I did purchase the card despite every single person at the apple store swearing up and down that it would NOT work. I started to get worried so I asked what the return policy was and they said if it's open you can not return it. So I went to an apple reseller where it was 10 dollars cheaper and I could return it for a restocking fee and they also said there is no way it would work. I bought it anyway, installed it (took about 3 minutes, no software necessary) and it works like a charm. Thanks to everyone on this forum for once again knowing more than all the so called mac experts, including Apple....

[markjones05]

Originally Posted by bearcatrp

Bozz, have you stressed the card yet? Considering this card as well as the nvidia or maybe the flashed version. Don't like buggy stuff in my system so probably buy an apple one. Curious to know if the fans kick up loud when stressed.

I did a pretty large After Effects render last night, and heard no increased noise from fans during the course of the render. It does, however, run a tiny bit louder than my old X1900, but not to a degree that is noticeable without putting your ear near the tower.