Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

here2rock

macrumors regular
Mar 23, 2012
170
0
Australia
I did Cinema4D, also max threaded, and no problems with the sound. Virtually silent.

Could the sound be from internal hard disk? How about replacing the mechanical or fusion drive with a 500GB hard disk? This will fix some of the problems you might be having with noise and also your Mac Mini will run a lot cooler.
 

Luap

macrumors 65816
Jul 5, 2004
1,249
743
It's better than the Mac mini if you are living in a small space and noise is an issue.

You can hide it away, you don't need to see it.

Apple need to work harder at bringing down the noise levels, it is good to see others doing so.

So.. You could hide the "alternative" away so that you wouldn't see it. But you couldn't hide the Mini away so that you wouldn't hear it?
What a silly post/thread... :rolleyes:
And unless it can run OS X natively, then the alternative really is no alternative. At all.
 

Acorn

macrumors 68030
Jan 2, 2009
2,642
349
macrumors
My sister needs a windows machine upgrade badly. she has all sorts of issues with the fan pegging at max speed and I have been unable to fix it. Its like once I track down whats causing it and shut it down a few days later something else pops up causing the same issue.

My sister hates her computer because its so slow and loud. I want to get her a mini but I just dont think she will be happy with the noise it makes.

This fan less computer looks nice but it throttles the machine badly so not much good to me.
 

xlii

macrumors 68000
Sep 19, 2006
1,867
121
Millis, Massachusetts
My sister needs a windows machine upgrade badly. she has all sorts of issues with the fan pegging at max speed and I have been unable to fix it. Its like once I track down whats causing it and shut it down a few days later something else pops up causing the same issue.

My sister hates her computer because its so slow and loud. I want to get her a mini but I just dont think she will be happy with the noise it makes.

This fan less computer looks nice but it throttles the machine badly so not much good to me.

I have the late 2012 mini and it doesn't make any noise under normal usage. The fan will make noise is you throw some of the newer games at it or Prime95. For movies, internet, email, iPhoto, iTunes, editing documents... you won't even hear it. My wife loves it.
 

Omnius

macrumors 6502a
Jul 23, 2012
562
30

It's more prone to physical damage as an external component.

In addition, damage to the cable becomes more expensive to replace.

Further, the huge power bricks are a hassle to find space for and annoying for people with organized desks/computing areas.


And to address the issue of heat, it really didn't do us any favors on the core 2 duo minis. They still ran hot. You have a very small form factor with lots of components inside. It's pretty much inevitable that a machine of this type will run hot. You could evaluate liquid cooling but leaky G5s is something Apple is not likely to forget. And frankly, a liquid cooling system would probably require a bigger mini.
 

Cubytus

macrumors 65816
Mar 2, 2007
1,436
18
It's better than the Mac mini if you are living in a small space and noise is an issue.

You can hide it away, you don't need to see it.

Apple need to work harder at bringing down the noise levels, it is good to see others doing so.
It seems you never heard a PC for a long time. Virtually ALL PCs make more noise than equivalent Macs, including laptops.

I do not see this problem with my two 17" MBPs, which have external power supplies. So i do not see a problem with the Mac mini and an external power supply.
Obviously you don't move them very often. A MacBook (Pro) charger's power cord is the part most likely to be damaged beyond repair. Preferably right near the plug, since it can't be opened and soldered back. This is typically not covered by warranty, and a replacement is $100.
 

Mr. Retrofire

macrumors 603
Mar 2, 2010
5,064
518
www.emiliana.cl/en
Obviously you don't move them very often.
;-)

I travel a few 1000 kilometers/year with one of my MBPs (including the charger). No stability problems.

A MacBook (Pro) charger's power cord is the part most likely to be damaged beyond repair. Preferably right near the plug, since it can't be opened and soldered back. This is typically not covered by warranty, and a replacement is $100.
Cheap, compared to other options. I think external power supplies are not the problem.
 

Cubytus

macrumors 65816
Mar 2, 2007
1,436
18
;-)

I travel a few 1000 kilometers/year with one of my MBPs (including the charger). No stability problems.


Cheap, compared to other options. I think external power supplies are not the problem.
Often, a MacBook (Pro) charger will do just fine for the whole Mac life. However, it was actually disturbingly frequent that, on previous generation chargers with the "sugar cube" Magsafe plug, the low voltage cable had a strong tendancy to wear itself to the point of shortcircuit inside the insulation, which was not covered by warranty. Even the "aluminum tube" style of Magsafe plug isn't entirely free from this problem, even though the low voltage cable is sturdier.

White MacBook: charger cord broken in the plug itself. Unrepairable.
Previous unibody MacBook: charger replaced twice under warranty for failure in the cable. Mac sold after AppleCare expired.
Current MacBook Pro: charger low voltage cord failed close to the brick. Warranty denied. Crack opened brick, used electrical domino to join wires back. Too cramped to actually solder it back. Strain relief gone, brick held together with electrical tape. Too fragile leave home now, as water from dripping boots would easily get inside when laid on the floor of coffee shops in winter. Around the same time, I accidentaly let the long cord make its way in a turned on radiator. Cord fried in a big spark.

A $100 charger is very cheap compared to a $3000 machine, sure. But compared to a $500 used MacBook, that's another story.

My suspicion: laptops and chargers from people who haul them on foot all day long take much more of a beating than professional laptops moved from time to time in a motor vehicle.
 

here2rock

macrumors regular
Mar 23, 2012
170
0
Australia
Has anyone done a scientific way of measuring the noise and heat on the Mac Mini? There seem to be a difference of opinion on these two issues.
 

AlbertEinstein

macrumors regular
Jan 3, 2013
132
0
It all comes down to the acoustics of the room and the space between the user and computer. If OP has placed his Mac Mini very close to him or if his room is very empty this would be reflected by any computer he would put in (as with all electronic devices, there is always noise).

Or the fans are full of dust. Try to vacuum as often as possible.:apple:
 

fig

macrumors 6502a
Jun 13, 2012
916
84
Austin, TX
I did Cinema4D, also max threaded, and no problems with the sound. Virtually silent.

What sort of C4D work do you do? I'm looking at a Mini and do a good bit of Maya work (mostly animation, not much rendering) but haven't found a lot of people running 3D apps on the new Mini.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.