Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ATV3, Blu-Ray, MakeMKV, Handbrake --- Audio?

S

silver8ack

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jul 22, 2010
207
0
Brand new to the ATV3 scene. Been using handbrake for a long time for ripping DVDs. Just got a blu-ray drive and started ripping blu-rays. Everything is working great except for audio.

I've been using the Apple TV 3 preset in handbrake. When I play the movie on the ATV3 there is no sound at all. I hold select, go to Audio, select Stereo, and stereo works great. Now get this... I go back into audio and select Surround, and the surround sound works.

Wtf is going on here? This has happened with HP: Goblet of Fire and Casino Royale.

I encoded Gob of Fire with iVI and everything works fine. I'd pay the $10 but I feel handbrake produces a better looking film(less studders).

I've about had it with apples "it just works" crap. I've had nothing but trouble with imovie and iPhoto working together, movies missing blah blah. I switched to apple years ago because I was blown away with how great everything worked together. It doesn't seem to anymore.

Ok /rant. Just sick of waiting 16 hours to find I have to piddle with the stupid audio. Any ideas?
 
B

bt22

macrumors 6502
Feb 15, 2009
309
19
Alabama
it's possible you've already read this. in case you haven't....

Apple is still better than Windows.... Especially since the release of Window's 8. I have a custom built windows 7 gaming computer and everything else is Apple. I much prefer Apple for daily driver...

https://forums.macrumors.com/posts/6012016/
 
S

silver8ack

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jul 22, 2010
207
0
I figured it out.. I am also using Subler to add metadata. I was checking both audio tracks, thinking that I had to do so in order to enable 5.1. Silly me.. you have to make sure it's disabled in order to enable it lol.

And yea... in a rage I tried setting up Plex and using my PS3 today... bleh. I'm back in love with Apple again.
 
P

Pyromonkey83

macrumors 6502
May 24, 2009
325
0
silver8ack said:
I figured it out.. I am also using Subler to add metadata. I was checking both audio tracks, thinking that I had to do so in order to enable 5.1. Silly me.. you have to make sure it's disabled in order to enable it lol.

And yea... in a rage I tried setting up Plex and using my PS3 today... bleh. I'm back in love with Apple again.
Click to expand...

I was just going to tell you this before I saw your own reply... +1 on figuring it out. :D

Just out of curiosity, when in Subler you have disabled the AAC conversion for your surround sound right? Either make sure it is on AC3 pass-thru in the settings or manually change it. Either way, AC3 is the only surround sound that works on the Apple TV, AAC 6-channel gets downmixed to a weird 3.0 audio by the Apple TV.
 
B

bt22

macrumors 6502
Feb 15, 2009
309
19
Alabama
Now I have a question. I ripped my first Blu Ray last night. I used MakeMKV then used Apple TV 3 preset in handbrake. The output file from Handbrake is 1920 x 816 i believe. In the video tab I set framerate as same as source. Should I have selected Keep Aspect Ratio in the picture tab? Or can I manually set width and height? I know I am late to the game, but I really like ripping the Blu-Rays...
 
M

mic j

macrumors 68030
Mar 15, 2012
2,663
156
bt22 said:
Now I have a question. I ripped my first Blu Ray last night. I used MakeMKV then used Apple TV 3 preset in handbrake. The output file from Handbrake is 1920 x 816 i believe. In the video tab I set framerate as same as source. Should I have selected Keep Aspect Ratio in the picture tab? Or can I manually set width and height? I know I am late to the game, but I really like ripping the Blu-Rays...
Click to expand...
If you are using the aTV3 preset, you do not need to make any additional changes. I use the preset for my encodes and the only changes I make to the preset are: 1) use anamorphic strict for picture and 2) web optimize.

If you don't use anamorphic strict you may rarely run into a movie which yields a 720p format even thought the starting format is 1080p. Using strict eliminates that glitch. Web optimize moves some metadata at the end of the movie to the beginning. This causes the movie to load faster on the aTV (particularly helpful with BR's).

No need to edit the nitrate setting. Even though it says 30, that is just a maximum setting for compliance with the aTV. It will records same as source with that setting. Also, HB will automatically detect your movie format and trim the black areas accordingly, so there is no need for you to manually set the aspect ratio.
 
T

tonycobe

macrumors newbie
Nov 5, 2009
4
0
ripping blu rays!

Sorry for the dumb question but, I love handbrake and have ripped dvd's for quite some time, I have many blu rays and a brand new iMac (which I love), I didn't know you could rip blu rays! Any info is appreciated. What kind of hardware do I need (I didn't know mac worked with blu ray) and do I need a special version of handbrake? ANY info is appreciated!! I would love to rip the blu rays! Also how much space does a typical movie take using APTV 3 settings on the hard drive (how many gig) what else do I need to know? THANKS A MILLION!!! And am I right, you can't play blu ray movies on a iMac right? Sorry for all the questions
 
M

mic j

macrumors 68030
Mar 15, 2012
2,663
156
tonycobe said:
Sorry for the dumb question but, I love handbrake and have ripped dvd's for quite some time, I have many blu rays and a brand new iMac (which I love), I didn't know you could rip blu rays! Any info is appreciated. What kind of hardware do I need (I didn't know mac worked with blu ray) and do I need a special version of handbrake? ANY info is appreciated!! I would love to rip the blu rays! Also how much space does a typical movie take using APTV 3 settings on the hard drive (how many gig) what else do I need to know? THANKS A MILLION!!! And am I right, you can't play blu ray movies on a iMac right? Sorry for all the questions
Click to expand...
You need a usb external blu-ray reader drive. They can be found for as low as $55-60.

The stable release of HB will transcode a BR, however, if you want regular or forced subtitles burned in, you need a Nightly release of HB. Not sure how you are ripping our dvd's but for BR's, I would recommend using MakeMKV decrypt and create an mkv file (can also be stored as an archive copy of the movie) which can then be used by HB.

A typical movie will be 5-10GB. Encoding time is super dependent on your iMac's processing power, but even with the most powerful I don't think anyone would call the process fast. I usually run 1 per night. However quality is excellent. Also be aware that your DTS or DTS-HD will be converted to Dolby Digital 5.1. No HD audio for the aTV.

Edit: I just noticed you said you had a new iMac, so your transcodes may be relatively rapid (a couple hours). Maybe someone else can give you a more accurate time estimate.
 
P

Pyromonkey83

macrumors 6502
May 24, 2009
325
0
mic j said:
Edit: I just noticed you said you had a new iMac, so your transcodes may be relatively rapid (a couple hours). Maybe someone else can give you a more accurate time estimate.
Click to expand...

27" Mid-2011 3.1Ghz i5 iMac takes approximately 3 hours per encode
rMBP 2.6Ghz takes approximately 2.5 hours per encode
27" Late 2012 3.2Ghz i5 iMac takes approximately 2 hours per encode

All of these are at 1080p from blu ray source (Using MakeMKV) converting to the ATV3 preset. Both iMacs are using standard Hard Drives, the rMBP is obviously on SSD. All setups have 16GB of RAM.
 
M

mic j

macrumors 68030
Mar 15, 2012
2,663
156
Pyromonkey83 said:
27" Mid-2011 3.1Ghz i5 iMac takes approximately 3 hours per encode
rMBP 2.6Ghz takes approximately 2.5 hours per encode
27" Late 2012 3.2Ghz i5 iMac takes approximately 2 hours per encode

All of these are at 1080p from blu ray source (Using MakeMKV) converting to the ATV3 preset. Both iMacs are using standard Hard Drives, the rMBP is obviously on SSD. All setups have 16GB of RAM.
Click to expand...
Glad to see you are fully awake and full of good information!!!! :D
 
P

Pyromonkey83

macrumors 6502
May 24, 2009
325
0
tonycobe said:
Also how much space does a typical movie take using APTV 3 settings on the hard drive (how many gig) what else do I need to know?
Click to expand...

This is dependent on you encode quality settings. A full rip from the blu ray will consume approximately 30-50GB. After encoding, those drop, but by how much involves what settings you use, or what preset.

Using the ATV3 setting you will likely get around a 10-15GB file. I have modified the ATV3 preset slightly and made my own. The changes I made were:

Change from a CQ encode to Variable Bit Rate 2-pass @ 5600kbps
Change to Strict Anamorphic
Change to Constant Frame rate, Same As Source (this one is completely optional, and doesn't really affect much of anything)

This will give you file sizes between 4GB-7GB and in my opinion look fantastic. I can slightly tell a difference between it and the source blu ray, but only if they are put side by side. The difference is so minimal at this setting that it is completely worth it to me to save the disk space over the ATV3 preset.
 
M

mic j

macrumors 68030
Mar 15, 2012
2,663
156
Pyromonkey83 said:
Using the ATV3 setting you will likely get around a 10-15GB file.
Click to expand...

Just went back to look at my file sizes. Using the aTV3 preset, almost all of mine are 5-10GB. With most being around 8-10GB. I do have a few that are larger (up to 17GB) but as you know, it really depends on the movie.

Not sure I agree with your HB settings (except for Anamorphic Strict). But to each his own, and if it's giving you smaller files sizes and the quality you like...ride on!!! Quality is a very subjective thing and dependent on a lot of variables.
 
B

bt22

macrumors 6502
Feb 15, 2009
309
19
Alabama
I ripped Looper last night. I used my custom built windows computer so i could take advantage of the sata connection and installed an internal Blu Ray drive and not have to use usb 2.0 on my 2011 mac mini. The MAKEMKV file was 44.4 GB and the handbrake file was 5.8 GB. Should the output file from Handbrake be 1920 x 1080 instead of 1920 x 816. That is what Handbrake shows as the resolution, I believe. I am currently at work and don't have access to the file. I have a quad core i7 930 processor with 6 GB of ram but have 7,200 rpm drives and it took almost 3 hours to do the whole process. A little over 2 hours in just handbrake. I only watched a few minutes of the finished product but the quality seems wonderful compared to a DVD rip. I am looking forward to watching the movie. It seemed like the blacks were not as pixilated (sic) as standard dvd rips.
 
M

mic j

macrumors 68030
Mar 15, 2012
2,663
156
bt22 said:
I ripped Looper last night. I used my custom built windows computer so i could take advantage of the sata connection and installed an internal Blu Ray drive and not have to use usb 2.0 on my 2011 mac mini. The MAKEMKV file was 44.4 GB and the handbrake file was 5.8 GB. Should the output file from Handbrake be 1920 x 1080 instead of 1920 x 816. That is what Handbrake shows as the resolution, I believe. I am currently at work and don't have access to the file. I have a quad core i7 930 processor with 6 GB of ram but have 7,200 rpm drives and it took almost 3 hours to do the whole process. A little over 2 hours in just handbrake. I only watched a few minutes of the finished product but the quality seems wonderful compared to a DVD rip. I am looking forward to watching the movie. It seemed like the blacks were not as pixilated (sic) as standard dvd rips.
Click to expand...
I envy your HB transcode only being 2 hours. :p

Your output file dimensions are fine. It varies with the movie and how it is formatted (letterbox, 16:9, 4:3, etc).
 
S

silver8ack

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jul 22, 2010
207
0
Wow.. A few hours?? Haha. My 2007 iMac took about 15hours to encode Casino Royale last night. I think it averaged about 2.5 fps.

Ended up with a 12.5 GB file. I use the Apple TV 3 preset and change the quality, or RF, to 18. I also use HandBrakeCLI, and have a sort of batch thing going.
 
M

Mac Eagle

macrumors member
May 5, 2010
89
41
I have a 2011 27" i7 3.4Ghz iMac and my Blu-ray encodes are taking on average about 80-90% of the movie length. Typically averaging somewhere between 30-40 FPS.
 
M

Menneisyys2

macrumors 603
Jun 7, 2011
5,997
1,101
Mac Eagle said:
I have a 2011 27" i7 3.4Ghz iMac and my Blu-ray encodes are taking on average about 80-90% of the movie length. Typically averaging somewhere between 30-40 FPS.
Click to expand...

That's quite a lot faster than my 2009 27" iMac (3.0 GHz C2D) - about four times the time of the runtime of the title using the Advanced preset. (The default Main preset is much, about 2.5 times faster)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom