I will be making an appointment for Tuesday to talk to another genius and see what they says. I will let you know what happens.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 5 making rattling noise.
- Thread starter fel10
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I will be making an appointment for Tuesday to talk to another genius and see what they says. I will let you know what happens.
Good luck to you.
BTW this was the right answer:
If everything else about your phone is great, I honestly wouldn't bother returning it. I've been there and had that headache. Your chances of getting one that doesn't have that noise are very slim. They will all do it, just some are louder than others.
the camera changed between the 4 and 4s so the iPhone 4 and prevous iphones don't do it as much. My old 4s (now my wifes) did it but not as loud as my 5. After a year and some change the camera is fine.
Ultimately, nobody can make up your mind for you but I highly encourage you to keep what you've got or you may be signing up for an extra headache/runaround all for nothing.
BTW this was the right answer:
If everything else about your phone is great, I honestly wouldn't bother returning it. I've been there and had that headache. Your chances of getting one that doesn't have that noise are very slim. They will all do it, just some are louder than others.
the camera changed between the 4 and 4s so the iPhone 4 and prevous iphones don't do it as much. My old 4s (now my wifes) did it but not as loud as my 5. After a year and some change the camera is fine.
Ultimately, nobody can make up your mind for you but I highly encourage you to keep what you've got or you may be signing up for an extra headache/runaround all for nothing.
So quick update. Went to another Apple store, made an appointment. Talked to one of the "genuises", he looked at my phone, and he told me the same thing. I asked him if I could try another phone and he took me to the iPhone display to show me that all of them had this same noise. Well, I shook some of them, and even though some did make a very small rattle sound, they were not as loud as mine. So I asked him if he could bring me another phone to test it out. So he did. Except, I don't think he brought me a brand new phone. First of all, the phone he brought me was in one of those white boxes, and I heard that those white boxes contains defective products. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Anyways. So I took it out of the box, and shoock it, and guess what. The battery was loose inside the phone. Made a huge thumping sound when I shook it. I told him the battery was loose, and he said no, it was probably something else. And the whole time I'm thinking, this guy is obviously trying to fool me. I think I've seen enough videos on YouTube to know its the battery.
Well, I'm still not completely satisfied with my new iPhone. Besides the noise, it works great, but the rattle makes it sound like a cheap phone. At this point I don't know if I should try another store or just live with it.
Anyways. So I took it out of the box, and shoock it, and guess what. The battery was loose inside the phone. Made a huge thumping sound when I shook it. I told him the battery was loose, and he said no, it was probably something else. And the whole time I'm thinking, this guy is obviously trying to fool me. I think I've seen enough videos on YouTube to know its the battery.
Well, I'm still not completely satisfied with my new iPhone. Besides the noise, it works great, but the rattle makes it sound like a cheap phone. At this point I don't know if I should try another store or just live with it.
That's ridiculous!!!! DEMAND they exchange it and speak to a manager. A loud rattle is NOT normal. IT should only rattle when you tap on it or set it down.
My iPhone 5 was made Week 49 (Dec) and is absolutely flawless. Took many to get there though, I won't lie.
I think you should call Apple and ask to speak to a SENIOR Apple Advisor. I have dealt with many regarding defective iPhone 4S'.
My 64Gb Black AT&T made the rattle noise, and it was promptly replaced by one that did NOT rattle the week following release. I personally tested the display models, every single one, and found the 16Gb models rattled and the 32/64 models did NOT, except for one. My understanding that a LOUD rattle means a loose battery, which can be fixed, but a slight rattle means you just got unlucky. They don't provide replacements for slight rattles anymore. :-(
It's been gone over a million times. A slight rattle when tapped or set down is normal. It's the autofocus lens that must remain loose to function. I big thud when the phone is shaken is a loose battery and needs to be repaired. Now some phones don't rattle as much when tapped or set down, but again, it's normal.