Let's also not forget the "hoard mentality" that Macrumors causes. One person finds a small amount of light bleed, slight yellow tint, or the tiniest scratch on the back of their new phone and suddenly "everyone" sees it on their devices. If you are like 99% of the population, you've never even been to Macrumors and thus don't even know about these "issues"....
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How is Apple coping with all the iPhones returned?
- Thread starter Grolubao
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Let's also not forget the "hoard mentality" that Macrumors causes. One person finds a small amount of light bleed, slight yellow tint, or the tiniest scratch on the back of their new phone and suddenly "everyone" sees it on their devices. If you are like 99% of the population, you've never even been to Macrumors and thus don't even know about these "issues"....
I don't think it's a hoard mentality. It's human nature that when something is pointed out to us, we hyperfixate on it. Like when you talk about a certain car, next thing you know that is all you see. When someone says your wife or GF is a total bitch, that is all you see, etc.
Call it what you will, Hoard Mentality/Human Nature, in the end visiting sites like Macrumors creates "issues" where there wasn't necessarily one to begin with. Yes some people did have fairly major scratches and scuffs, but that caused "everyone" to see all the little imperfections that didn't bother them before and now are a big deal and next thing we know we have stupid "scuffgate"....
I disagree with MR creating issues. This site didn't create light bleed, it brought it to many peoples attention. The issue is still the light bleed. Does MR ramp up some issues that without a forum might be noticed much less by the general public? Of course. When the news reports Toyota has a recall that creates the same thing. Everyone and his brother is talking about the recall-to some it's no big deal, to others it's the end of their world.
Website forums like MR do tend to magnify the issues that a general consumer wouldn't normally spot. Now for the price you pay for a phone, quality should definitely be there but a little spot or scuff on my iPhone 5 wasn't a big deal to me. It's meant to be handled and ill eventually put more scuffs on it from my own usage.
Now if you really want to magnify an even more obvious issue not generally noticed by the general public, try watching the majority of the edge lit LED TVs out there in a dim room or dark room. Clouding and flash lighting galore and even some banding but the average person doesn't really notice this when they fire up their sets and watch their content.
I'm an avsforum regular. You'd be amazed by the stuff you wouldn't generally notice but are definitely issues .
Now if you really want to magnify an even more obvious issue not generally noticed by the general public, try watching the majority of the edge lit LED TVs out there in a dim room or dark room. Clouding and flash lighting galore and even some banding but the average person doesn't really notice this when they fire up their sets and watch their content.
I'm an avsforum regular. You'd be amazed by the stuff you wouldn't generally notice but are definitely issues .
Last edited:
Hello,
After just getting my second "White Box", I still do not think they are refurbished yet. Or perhaps just the 64gb Model. Both I have received, for Hardware Issues, have been cosmetically flawless. By contrast, the Black Box 64gb Model I exchanged had chips where the Glass Bands meet the Aluminum on the Back Panel.
Both the ones I received are Week 38 Builds that were manufactured at the Chengdu (DN) Foxconn Facility. I am not sure if the same holds true for the other White Box units of different storage capacity.
Cheers,
JJ
After just getting my second "White Box", I still do not think they are refurbished yet. Or perhaps just the 64gb Model. Both I have received, for Hardware Issues, have been cosmetically flawless. By contrast, the Black Box 64gb Model I exchanged had chips where the Glass Bands meet the Aluminum on the Back Panel.
Both the ones I received are Week 38 Builds that were manufactured at the Chengdu (DN) Foxconn Facility. I am not sure if the same holds true for the other White Box units of different storage capacity.
Cheers,
JJ
Look, I'm talking out of the box! If I unpack my TV and I see that it has scratches you can get I'm going to return it, at least if it's an expensive TV. You get what you payed for.
If I open a brand new iPhone 5 and it has scratches you can bet I wouldn't want it.
If I open a brand new iPhone 5 and it has scratches you can bet I wouldn't want it.
Refurb: they take out the working internals and package it in a new aluminium housing. Then put it in a white box.
This.
It's not "BS". Apple has had plenty of resources "refurbing" iP5's from day ONE. The reason why you see so many "is my precious phone a refurb because I'm OCD and would die but can't tell by looking at it" threads is because Apple has the BEST refurbs. Typically you WON'T be able to tell.
It's only the people who absolutely positively cannot live with the idea that their used phone has been swapped for a cosmetically new, internally used "refurb" that have a problem with this.
The rest of us know that Apple does the process right, and 99 times out of 100 (exaggerating, it may only be 98) the "refurb" is a superior phone in terms of not having bugs anyway.
Again, if there hasn't been PLENTY of time for Apple to have refurbs by now (despite confirmantion from 2 store managers by me), please explain how long you think it should take and WHY? If it's just wishful thinking because you want a "brand new" one instead of a "refurb" just get over it and move on =).
I bought my iphone 5 black version yesterday for $916 TOTAL (non-contract obviously), came with black superficial scuffs on the bottom part of aluminum backing, and i bough this phone for $916 did i tell you.
I'm debating if I should just stick with it or return it for a non-scuffed black iphone 5, but therein lies the potential that once i get the new iphone 5 exchange, there might be scuff out of the box, and this is a phone that cost me $916 full price, oh my god man. I was going to the apple store today to exchange it, but i was looking at inventory last night between 10 pm and 4 am at the apple website and they didnt have any 32 or 64 gb iphone 5 black. they only had white.
i might go monday early morning to exchange it if i can and avoid the freaking black friday weekend holiday shopper. but man $916 with a scuff.
I'm debating if I should just stick with it or return it for a non-scuffed black iphone 5, but therein lies the potential that once i get the new iphone 5 exchange, there might be scuff out of the box, and this is a phone that cost me $916 full price, oh my god man. I was going to the apple store today to exchange it, but i was looking at inventory last night between 10 pm and 4 am at the apple website and they didnt have any 32 or 64 gb iphone 5 black. they only had white.
i might go monday early morning to exchange it if i can and avoid the freaking black friday weekend holiday shopper. but man $916 with a scuff.
i had a dream last night that my iPhone 5 had dirt in a crack, and it looked horrible.
i had the dream probably because thats all people talk about on this forum!!!
cracks, blemishes, dirt, flaws..etc..
my phone is actually spotless and doesn't have any cracks. lol...the dream was a nightmare!
i had the dream probably because thats all people talk about on this forum!!!
cracks, blemishes, dirt, flaws..etc..
my phone is actually spotless and doesn't have any cracks. lol...the dream was a nightmare!
This.
It's not "BS". Apple has had plenty of resources "refurbing" iP5's from day ONE. The reason why you see so many "is my precious phone a refurb because I'm OCD and would die but can't tell by looking at it" threads is because Apple has the BEST refurbs. Typically you WON'T be able to tell.
It's only the people who absolutely positively cannot live with the idea that their used phone has been swapped for a cosmetically new, internally used "refurb" that have a problem with this.
The rest of us know that Apple does the process right, and 99 times out of 100 (exaggerating, it may only be 98) the "refurb" is a superior phone in terms of not having bugs anyway.
Again, if there hasn't been PLENTY of time for Apple to have refurbs by now (despite confirmantion from 2 store managers by me), please explain how long you think it should take and WHY? If it's just wishful thinking because you want a "brand new" one instead of a "refurb" just get over it and move on =).
Ok but I am not convinced that apple just swap out the internals.. What if battery is faulty or the home button malfunctioning or screen flickering or wi-fi is faulty or video chip problem.. Apple surely must have brand new phones on stand by its just packaging them in a white box is cost effective
And not anyone with scuffs will post either. I didn't think I would get bad iPhones, but I went through 4 already for dust under the screen, interlacing screens, and dust under the camera lens.
People with complains will voice their opinion a lot more than people that are happy and satisfied.
Its human nature.
Technically, a refurbished is just a repaired device that is cleaned up and resold. Much like the junk Asurion and other insurance companies replace lost/stolen phones with.
Apple uses remanufactured devices after inventory of new stock replacements runs out. Remanufactured phones are phones completely rebuilt from perfectly good parts from "remorse" returns.
Apple uses remanufactured devices after inventory of new stock replacements runs out. Remanufactured phones are phones completely rebuilt from perfectly good parts from "remorse" returns.
