I recently started
Elite Dangerous a space sandbox game that I believe hopes to compete with
Eve Online This started as an ED post, but it's too general, too rambling so put it here. Figuring out if a space sandbox is for me. I'll compare
Elite Dangerous to 3 other MMO games-
Worold of Warcraft, World of Tanks , and Eve. Hopefully I'm not sounding like I've turned into Mr Negative over night, but this is how I see it.
I'm an
Elite Dangerous newb. When you first start out in ED you'll be impressed with the Space Stations, but after a short while they will become routine, like a trip to the grocery store. In my first 5 or 8 hours I've played
Elite Dangerous, not counting a good hour setting up my joystick, the majority of my time has been mostly looking at the bulletin board or the commodities page, researching where the best trades happen, and making a decision on mission or commodity with the hope of pulling in some big money instead of a paltry 1200 credits. Have to get this ship upgraded!
Tieing for first place, might be running through the combat tutorials multiple times which are the most fun I've had. The second most time I've spent is droning through black space looking at only a destination marker In the far distance, covering emmence distances, but there is nothing to see while doing this (so far). I've seen the
Eve screenshots and based on the celestial sights, Eve beats ED hands down for pretty. The forth most time is being impressed with space stations and learning how to dock efficiently. The least time was being interdicted by a pirate in route and fighting him until System Authorities appeared to assist. This was the most fun in game. Somehow I still got that bounty.
In
WoW you have a fairly consistent intriguing and varied environments with lots of NPC interaction and tons of quests. Can you mine and craft? Yes. Huge death penalty? No. Honestly interactions/fighting during quests are very repetitive. What keeps me going with WoW, when I do play it? Environment, lore, and story. Last time I played was 2 years ago and I figure they might get 6 months out of me this time. Total play time approx 3 years. Subscription.
WOT has short encounters, a variety of maps, and a relatively small death penalty which consists of repairing your tank. In the bottom half of tiers you'll always make money. In the upper tiers not always the case, but if you kicked ass in the battle, you'll make money, sometime relatively large amounts of money even though your tank explodes. A tier 9 tanks costs about 17000 silver to repair, while rewards for a battle can vary from a loss of -17000 to a gain of 75-100k, for 15 minutes of work. There are no quests, just raw PVP using strategy and teamwork to kill the other team. Always exciting, frequently frustrating when you team is composed of idiots. Total play time 2 years and still going. And I don't have a tier 10'tank yet. This is because I'm playing about 30 different tanks. No subscription but paying premium ($9/month).
When I compare
ED to Eve, Eve has a subscription which for me is historically bad. No subscription is usually better although I'll acknowledge that WoW is the absolute best in what it has accomplished in the MMORPR arena, with a subscription. I don't think mining will hold me in either game.
Both Eve and ED can have HUGE death penalties. For myself, this is a turnoff although they can be somewhat mitigated. Not sure about Eve if a large mega ship is blown up. It seems like Eve allows for large group efforts, huge battles and territorial conquest, while Eve is mostly going it alone, unless you band with a group of friends or a guild. You can create a private server (in-game), but other than conraderie, I see no compelling reason to work as part of a guild unless it is specifically to coordinate efforts killing tough pirates. But as I understand it, you can't even easily keep track of your partner. But even so, there will be no other real coordinated guild efforts. Last shot gets the bounty so be careful and switch off on who gets the last shot. Both of these games seem to big time sinks like many sandbox games are, if you are doing group battles, Eve is probably worse for time, but I acknowledge has a greater potential for a thrilling group experience.
Last night when I was considering what game to play, did I choose breaking out the commodity charts and hauling some fish from point A to B in the dark all alone earning some cash in
ED? No, I ended up running around Pandaria for a couple of hours questing probably 10 quests, including running a 20 minute instance. Then I devoted a couple of hours in tanks, jumping into 15v15 PVP battles within 30 sec of logging on- very focused.
Enough of my rambling. Where does that leave me with
ED? I don't know. It does not mean I'll likely be playing
Eve. I keep going back to the ED combat tutorials cause they are fun, but there is not so nearly as efficient means in game to experience this. Obviously I need to figure out bounty hunting in short order if I am going to be playing ED for some period of time. I recently downloaded Starpoint Gemini 2, a solo space game with I presume to include a campaign. Now would be a good time to mess with that for a comparison. Maybe I need my hand held in the vastness of space.