Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iLife: how many computers?
- Thread starter BIS2
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Legally, just one. There might be some sort of desktop/notebook workaround, but I think it's per-device.
*Gasp* Seriously? The family pack wasn't on the Canadian education page, so I just figured they'd merged them as part of the price hike (hey, it'd be nice) but now I see it's on the normal Canadian page. I've already ordered and was planning on putting it on my iMac and a laptop... Frick.
Looks like Apple is finally cracking down. Previously, there was essentially no checking. I suppose the mini will substantially raise the number of multi-Mac families out there. There goes buying the mini just to yank iLife off of it and stash in on my PM.... 
Are you sure? It's never been like that before. Not that I do that :cough: but I guess if it's true, that's why the Family Pack is only $20 more American. It's even worth it for 2 or 3 Macs. I'm sure the Canadian store will update with info on it soon, but you could always call them if it's still not there by the 22nd.sjpetry said:Even if you try to put it on more than 1 computer it won't let you.
my understanding is that you are legally entitled to put it on one laptop and one desktop for your personal use. Even M$ allows that, I'm pretty sure. It would really bite if apple wouldn't allow that... seems like "fair use" to me!
(not to mention the fact that I think it will really encourage piracy if they are so strict as to thwart legitimate fair use)
(not to mention the fact that I think it will really encourage piracy if they are so strict as to thwart legitimate fair use)
QCassidy352 said:
You are legally entitled to whatever the end user license agreement entitles you to, no more and no less. Have you read the EULA? Didn't think so. Apple owns the software, you don't - the EULA is the legal contract between yourself and Apple to allow you to use the software under term of the license. http://www.apple.com/legal/sla/
"This License allows you to install and use one copy of the Apple Software on a single computer at a time. This License does not allow the Apple Software to exist on more than one computer at a time, and you may not make the Apple Software available over a network where it could be used by multiple computers at the same time."
*Certain MS products* allow you to install on a desktop and a laptop, as long as one of them is used no more than 20% of the time -- that is a provision in MS's EULA on some but not all of their desktop applications.
"Fair Use" has nothing to do with it - that is a term with a specific meaning. http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#107
If you are in the US, under the Copyright Law (Title 17) you may make a copy of computer software media for backup purposes only; but not for installing on another machine. http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#117 Other countries may vary.
The option for multiple machines is to spend $20 more for the Family pack. Apple does more than most companies to encourage, not thwart, legitimate use.
CanadaRAM said:
i'm pretty sure the link to that site is neither printed o nthe box of the computer or ilife
hm iLife'05 is not listed either..so according the law here most "eulas" are completly useless/invalid
and any vendor has only to make _one_ mistake in the EULA (like taking away customer right) and it's invalid as well..like for example it happens/happend with microsoft EULAs where _they_ got sued..
EULAs aren't something where companies can simply demand things and do what they want
at leasts it's this way here (of course some parts like certain copyright parts are seperate laws but those don't include laws concerning on how much pcs you can install it)
and i seriously doubt that apple will use some kind of registration/activation thing microsoft does where you call via phone or something like that
for your conscience go with the family pack... it's not that much more like it is with other software vendors
takao said:
That's exactly the view I take.
And I'm pretty sure that the stuff can only go on "one computer with and Apple logo".
Previously iLife had no serial number so there was no way of knowing if you were running the same copy on two machines. I don't know if iLife now has a serial number - does anyone know?
Anyway, as others have said the 'family' version is pretty reasonable actually if you want to stay 'legal'
Anyway, as others have said the 'family' version is pretty reasonable actually if you want to stay 'legal'
takao said:i'm pretty sure the link to that site is neither printed o nthe box of the computer or ilife
hm iLife'05 is not listed either..so according the law here most "eulas" are completly useless/invalid
Usually the EULAs are printed on the envelope that the CD comes in (called a "shrinkwrap agreement" in that you agree to it by opening the envelope), and/or in the Installer process where you have to agree to the license to proceed with the installation.
Around here, the issue was that if the license was not readable before you purchased it (that is, on the outside of the box), then the seller could not refuse to take a return of the open box once you had a chance to read the license agreement inside the box. But you couldn't open the CD envelope with the agreement printed on it, and still return it after that.
chameeeleon said:
The educational price isn't available with the family pack. Apple just doesn't allow its software on more than one CPU. That is why they offer the family pack, which is a good deal when it allows installation on up to five Mac's. It's a great deal even without the discount, especially if you have more than two computers. Family pack $99, two at regular price would be $148.
I'll catch grief for this , but that's OK- I'm a big boy, I can handle it, I view it as a personal license or single user license, & since I'm the only user that has access to my desktop & laptop I'm putting my single user version on both... I know, I know , everyones gonna say "don't take money from Apples' pockets"- in reality I put more than enough money in Apples pocket that I can install this w/out guilt... Sorry, but when it comes to digging in our pockets Apple is second to none- there up there w/ Disney in that area...
OK, an additional question.....
Thanks for the info. Actually I'm a teacher so the price difference for me is $40, which is a bit more but not the end of the world. So my next question is, has anyone found the family pack listed at an EDU price? When I go to the education store, the family pack doesn't seem to be listed as an option.
Thanks for the info. Actually I'm a teacher so the price difference for me is $40, which is a bit more but not the end of the world. So my next question is, has anyone found the family pack listed at an EDU price? When I go to the education store, the family pack doesn't seem to be listed as an option.
So just to clarify...I wont be able to install iWork on my desktop and my laptop? To do this I will have to buy two separate copies?
Surely that can't be right.
Surely that can't be right.
Legally it looks like this is the case though unless you have the software actually running on both machines at the same time it probably won't be able to tell. I'm not telling you to do this but this is most likely the case.munkle said:
caveman_uk said:
If iWork requires a serial number, is it even going to be possible to install it on two different machines?
sjpetry said:Even if you try to put it on more than 1 computer it won't let you.
Hmmmm. Obviously I would never do this
but hypothetically, you're wrong.And it is very tight of Apple not to let you put the software on your desktop and laptop. You'd think that they would reward people who buy one of each.
Yes, as a matter of fact. I have a copy of iWork/iPhoto/iMovie. ('05) There is a seiral # for iWork. However all it does is ask you for the #, you put it in and go on about your life. Nothing special. I also have iLife '05 and iWork installed on two separate computers. So I hope this anwsers some questions.
PS. iWork r0x0rZ
PS. iWork r0x0rZ
As many as you can get away with.
Unless iLife 05 actually stops you installng on multiple Macs then you can install on as many as you like.
All software is overpriced, including from Apple and i have no problem breaking "home licenses".
Others do differ from me but if you've paid your money....
BIS2 said:
Unless iLife 05 actually stops you installng on multiple Macs then you can install on as many as you like.
All software is overpriced, including from Apple and i have no problem breaking "home licenses".
Others do differ from me but if you've paid your money....
Usually these things check over a network, if you have say Keynote open on one machine with a serial number then try and open it on another machine in the same subnet then it will error saying there is already a user with that serial on the network.
I can't see iLife doing this sort of check, which app's would they build this into? iTunes, iMovie, iPhoto?? They wouldn't put a random key on the cd as they are printed from gold masters, this would be far too expensive.
Unless it's in the installer, in which case pull your network cable out, install it and bobs your uncle.
I can't see iLife doing this sort of check, which app's would they build this into? iTunes, iMovie, iPhoto?? They wouldn't put a random key on the cd as they are printed from gold masters, this would be far too expensive.
Unless it's in the installer, in which case pull your network cable out, install it and bobs your uncle.