Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Infrared

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Mar 28, 2007
1,716
65
I was so so worried Mac OS X was being dumbed down. Having tried Lion,
I can say emphatically it's not.

Lion is more complicated, more inaccessible, more powerful and more
geeky than Snow Leopard ever was.

Take mission control. It's hugely complex compared to Expose or Spaces.
I'm loving getting to grips with it, but someone needs to write a book
so ordinary folk can use it.

Take versions. It's a brilliant and completely profound alteration of a
fundamental aspect of working with files. I can easily remember which
programs use versions and which don't. Will the ordinary user be able
to recall the difference? Will they remember that if they use app X they
need to duplicate first, but if they use app Y, they can "save as..." after?
I'm not so sure. But what do I care. That's their problem :)

Look at this:

compare.png

That's the same file open in Preview twice. Time is reversible in Lion
with versions, Memento-style, and now we're branching time, too. Each
of those images is projected from a parallel universe. Cool.

Natural scrolling. Great idea. I've adapted already. Like most power users
I love change. I love adapting and learning new things, all the time, every
time, constantly adapting and changing and learning anew. Change, change,
endless change, layering the memories one thousand deep. Exhilerating.

Launchpad. Great idea. Previously we could launch from the Dock, or by
clicking on icon on the desktop, or within a Finder window, or by hitting
the return key in Spotlight, or by using Recent Items under the Apple menu,
or by having '/Applications' in a stack in the Dock, and so on, und so weiter.
But that's not enough. That will never satisfy a power user. Why have 9 or
10 methods of launching an app when you can add 1 more? That's the power
of launchpad. It the powerful plusoneness of Lion, that adds more and more
and takes nothing away. Layer upon layer of complexity and flexibility rising
up into the lofty reaches of the intellosphere.

I'm standing at the top of this stack of complication. I see some little people
below. They look up, and their faces are small in the distance. What are they
thinking? How it's going for them, the novice users?

Riding the Lion and loving it,

Infra.
 
I'm not really a fan of Launchpad. I have a ton of apps and it doesn't really sort them all that great. Quicksilver is still a thousand times faster.
 
OP I know your post is sarcastic but I actually think your points are valid. And for the few problems people are having, when has Apple EVER made a drastic change and then not fixed it later?

Patience people.

Is this sarcasm too subtle?
 
I think you forgot the internet bandwidth conservation features of Lion, where i basically kicks you off the net after waking from sleep, like shouldn't you eat breakfast first.
 
Comment deleted, because it no longer represents my current view on subject.
 
Last edited:
Being a power user I was also skeptical regarding the upgrade. Anyway, since I was a bit anxious I decided to go for it and couldn't be any happier.

For me I just love mission control and the gestures with it. In one space I have iTunes, so whenever I want it I just slide 4 fingers right. Launchpad is great because there's a gesture that gives me direct access to the "dock". This way, I can have the dock hidden all the time.

I've noticed some very small UI glitches but should be fixed eventually, nothing big :)
 
Launchpad. Great idea. Previously we could launch from the Dock, or by
clicking on icon on the desktop, or within a Finder window, or by hitting
the return key in Spotlight, or by using Recent Items under the Apple menu,
or by having '/Applications' in a stack in the Dock, and so on, und so weiter.
But that's not enough. That will never satisfy a power user. Why have 9 or
10 methods of launching an app when you can add 1 more? That's the power
of launchpad. It the powerful plusoneness of Lion, that adds more and more
and takes nothing away. Layer upon layer of complexity and flexibility rising
up into the lofty reaches of the intellosphere.

take a dive to the very bottom layer, the core of it all.

Code:
 open /Applications/Preview.app

Natural scrolling. Great idea. I've adapted already. Like most power users
I love change. I love adapting and learning new things, all the time, every
time, constantly adapting and changing and learning anew. Change, change,
endless change, layering the memories one thousand deep. Exhilerating.

simply, truth.
 
Initially I was pissed off that Lion had automatically deleted the installation file after it finishes installing itself, and also automatically set page scrolling to inverse.

I had to turn the inverse scrolling off.

But now, after using mission control and the multiple desktops in Lion, I understand why Apple called inverse scrolling "natural" scrolling.

I ended up turning inverse scrolling back on, and I am liking it so far.

It took a while to get used to, but I now like it a lot.
 
I agree with the OP, Lions features definitely makes it easier for power users, but i think trying to teach someone how to use a Mac is going to be harder now with all the new stuff they added on, not looking forward to explaining all of that when someone else in my family decides to get a Mac and comes to me for help.
 
I agree with the OP, Lions features definitely makes it easier for power users, but i think trying to teach someone how to use a Mac is going to be harder now with all the new stuff they added on, not looking forward to explaining all of that when someone else in my family decides to get a Mac and comes to me for help.

I don't think you caught the OP's sarcasm.
 
Initially I was pissed off that Lion had automatically deleted the installation file after it finishes installing itself, and also automatically set page scrolling to inverse.

I had to turn the inverse scrolling off.

But now, after using mission control and the multiple desktops in Lion, I understand why Apple called inverse scrolling "natural" scrolling.

I ended up turning inverse scrolling back on, and I am liking it so far.

It took a while to get used to, but I now like it a lot.

If you go into the app store and hold opt when you click purchases you can re-download the installer.
 
If you go into the app store and hold opt when you click purchases you can re-download the installer.

Ugh, this would have helped me yesterday.. I had to install SL on an external HD, update it to the latest version, re-download lion and then burn it to a disc because I had already installed it before I had a chance to burn an install disc.
 
I <3 this post!!!

Simply Brilliant! Bravo to the OP.

But in all seriousness I think this brings up an excellent point. I think Lion is simultaneously pissing off experienced Mac users and complicating things for novices and switchers.

My boyfriend already growls at me every time he uses my computer and activates a hot corner. I think his head would explode if I kept reverse scrolling on and the thought of explaining Autosave/Versions/absence of Save As to a newb is just laughable.

To the OP: From now on every time I get frustrated with Lion I will return to this post for another laugh :D
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.