Pluses and Minuses
There are pluses and minuses to the keynote, I think.
The additional power is great for OSX, and getting everyone on that "new thang" is important to Apple. The screens are good, and the way they've done it is quite nice.
Personally, I wouldn't get one, but my mum would love it. If I'd let her have a Mac, anyway.
Those are the people apple need to get. The people who just want a computer. Basic needs. Consumer machine... mmm pretty.
On the down side, it really does look like a lamp : )
Unfortunately the price is too high. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying it's expensive for what you get. It's pretty good value considering what you get. BUT it's pretty expensive for a computer. The addition of a G4 and particularly flat panels comes at a real price, and that price may cause joe and jane to look for a less pretty machine.
I agree with RedEye to a large degree. Value for money is nice. But sometimes there's value to keeping things cheaper.
For the price of a new iMac I could get a top end Athlon with a 19" monitor. But hey, that is just MY needs.
iPhotos rock. I think some parts of it are fairly irrelevant. In many ways I was reminded of Windows, and how superiority often can be invented by making things seem harder than they really are. (Seriously people, how hard is it to put an AOL CD in and make it work?) Windows XP has a lot of the advantages of iPhotos, for example. The "chain of pain"? what ********. You just go to the digital camera like it's a hard drive. It opens automatically on connecting. Browse using the thumbnail view, or built in image viewer. You can even ORDER PRINTS ONLINE! Did Microsoft copy this one?
If you use ACDSEE, the new version also gives you some of the other features, metadata addition and album creation and storage.
Personally I do so much digital media stuff daily that I abandoned the newest version in favour of an older version. Small fast, less features.
Oh, and you can crop in acdsee, too. Hell, you could crop in LView (1993).
That being said iPhoto is a really nice addition to OSX. Great for consumers. Has some features I found very impressive, like dynamic resizing of thumbnails.
All that being said, I think that one thing I really question is apples whole digital hub concept.
Center of my digital lifestyle? I don't have a digital lifestyle. I'm still having trouble with my old analogue lifestyle! I don't HAVE a digital camera, still or video. I don't WANT to make digital videos. I don't have an mp3 player.
I would personally question this assumption that within the next few months everyone will be taking mp3s from their mp3 player make background music to use in the DVD they're making of the footage they just shot with their DV camera.
Sure, it's nice that you can do it. Though to be completely honest, it's not like it's that hard on a PC (except for the burning, that is).
I personally am not sure that they're right about the direction to take there. I think most people still just want a computer to do... you know... computer things on it.
Games, anyone? The addition of GF2MX cards is great, particularly on a machine limited to 1024x768 anyway. But there needs to be games to play on them. They're getting some, but just not enough.
The desktop is next for revision. That was what I really wanted to see. I'll still be interested to take a look.
It's going to have to be good. Some of apple's markets (digital video, graphic design, etc) are VERY performance driven, and apple is losing ground there with the stagnant performance of the current architectures.
Anyway, enough from me...