iPhone 5 Camera pics not full screen?

[lordhamster]

Originally Posted by kamalds

My GS3 lets you choose between 16:9 or 4:3 pics. Iphone users are not even given choice.

I doubt you are getting a true 16:9. The sensor is probably scaled to 4:3, with other options being simply a digital zoom/crop.

[master-ceo]

Originally Posted by freedevil

I agree with the OP. I would like my pictures to fit the whole widescreen. This is lame and the pics look small and weird now.

This is why Steve Jobs was the man.

[Tea-Aholic]

Originally Posted by lordhamster

I doubt you are getting a true 16:9. The sensor is probably scaled to 4:3, with other options being simply a digital zoom/crop.

That's correct. Sensors in phones are 4:3 and a 16:9 is just cropping the top and bottom bits off to achieve a wider ratio.

[Beanoir]

Originally Posted by Small White Car

It makes me sad that, after more than a century of photography, some children on the internet think that established standards should be thrown away because of the shape of a cell phone screen.

Never mind what happens when people try to get their photos made into prints and find that no photo print shops, frames, or albums are suited for these hypothetical 16x9 photos. Some black boarders on the screen are confusing to people, apparently, but that wouldn't be?

4x6?
8x10?
5x7?

^This

[scyap]

Originally Posted by docprego

I think Apple should have made the photos zoom by default so that they fill the screen. Then a double tap could bring them back to their actual size. As it is now most people will be simply confused by this.

AFAIK, my iPhone 4/4S also displays taken-photos zoomed-in a little bit.
If I completely zoom out, I would get black bars at the top and bottom.

[docprego]

Originally Posted by scyap

AFAIK, my iPhone 4/4S also displays taken-photos zoomed-in a little bit.
If I completely zoom out, I would get black bars at the top and bottom.

Interesting. I just tried this on my 4S and indeed there are black bars on the top and bottom if I zoom completely out. This means that photos are zoomed to full screen by default. I wonder why this behavior has changed?

[Hpye]

I want to take the picture like this ratio with my camera but can't

[thekb]

The bottom line is there is no sane reason this is not a user selectable option.

There is no reason the camera app shouldn't allow you to set the desired aspect ratio and there is no reason you shouldn't be able to dial in exposure compensation, or desired resolution. It's odd that you can crop to whatever ratio you want after the fact, but it has to be done to each individual picture -- a time consuming process.

This is particularly disappointing when one of the big selling points (for me at least) was the airplay capability. Projecting 4:3 pictures onto my 16:9 flatscreen TV is underwhelming.

[Mrfatboy]

Originally Posted by thekb

The bottom line is there is no sane reason this is not a user selectable option.

There is no reason the camera app shouldn't allow you to set the desired aspect ratio and there is no reason you shouldn't be able to dial in exposure compensation, or desired resolution. It's odd that you can crop to whatever ratio you want after the fact, but it has to be done to each individual picture -- a time consuming process.

This is particularly disappointing when one of the big selling points (for me at least) was the airplay capability. Projecting 4:3 pictures onto my 16:9 flatscreen TV is underwhelming.

I agree. I took some awesome sunset pictures tonight and displayed them on my HDTV via AirPlay. 4:3 was a bummer.

[vastoholic]

Originally Posted by Mrfatboy

I agree. I took some awesome sunset pictures tonight and displayed them on my HDTV via AirPlay. 4:3 was a bummer.

So take a panorama shot instead. It's apple's way of giving us that option I guess. Obviously not my preferred method because who know what aspect ratio you'll end up with. I think I'll send some feedback about this request and maybe, just maybe they'll add in an option later on down the road.

[hotsauce]

Originally Posted by docprego

I think Apple should have made the photos zoom by default so that they fill the screen. Then a double tap could bring them back to their actual size. As it is now most people will be simply confused by this.

Why don't you take the pic in 4:3 and zoom in yourself if you want to fill the screen? Or crop it to 16:9. What are we talking about again?

[ToddH]

Originally Posted by freedevil

I agree with the OP. I would like my pictures to fit the whole widescreen. This is lame and the pics look small and weird now.

Give the screen a spread!!! Geez! It's an 8mp camera. Just spread it out until it fills the screen. Dang you people are picky and full of complaints & Never satisfied.

----------

Originally Posted by Hpye

I want to take the picture like this ratio with my camera but can't

Sorry! The imaging sensor is not shapped that way. It is more square than rectangle. The only camera that comes close is the the Mamiya RB67 which is a 6x7cm film camera. My Nikon D800e, which is a pro camera with 36.3mp will not even shoot at that format.

[jetlitheone]

Originally Posted by Tea-Aholic

That's correct. Sensors in phones are 4:3 and a 16:9 is just cropping the top and bottom bits off to achieve a wider ratio.

And the photos are 6mp as opposed to 8.

there will be a tweak when the iphone 5 is jailbroken im sure of that.

[Merkie]

Originally Posted by Hpye

I want to take the picture like this ratio with my camera but can't

Yeah you can. View the image, tap "Edit", tap the crop button, tap "restrict dimensions", choose "16x9". Cameras that have a 16:9 option do this automatically, but it's the same process.

[Applesethi]

iPhone five shoots video in 16 x 9 aspect ratio therefore the only way you can take a widescreen shot is by capturing a photo whilst shooting a video this works for me check out the photo quality isn't that great but it's still good at my mums 46 inch fullscreen Samsung TV

[FreakinEurekan]

Originally Posted by Small White Car

It makes me sad that, after more than a century of photography, some children on the internet think that established standards should be thrown away because of the shape of a cell phone screen.

...

4x6?
8x10?
5x7?

Is any of this ringing a bell?

Fact is those "Standards" were ill-conceived to begin with and should have been thrown away years ago. 4x6 is a 1:1.5 ratio, 5x7 is 1:1.4, and 8x10 is 1:1.25. As you enlarge the photo, more and more of it gets cropped off.

35mm still negatives are 1:1.5 (24mmx36mm). 4x6 works with that, but it should be 5x7.5 and 8x12 to properly scale.

[HeyGuessWhoItIs]

Hey, this is all well and good and I realize there are ways that users have suggested to show 16:9 landscape and 3:2 portrait full screen ratios but, that's CROPPING the photo. Why would I want to crop the photo?? In no way am I complaining, but for those of us who choose to use regular CAMERAS for photography (including print) and want to use our phones forlet's say displaying images on our phones (without cropping them), then what are alternatives??


Reference Point (closed thread)
http://forums.macrumors.com/showthre...1459118&page=2

[007bond]

Originally Posted by iphonefan74

The only phone I am aware of that shoots widescreen photos as an option is the Droid Razr Maxx.

Yep. Most motorola phones (like the Atrix 2) have a 6MP shooting mode that shoot pictures in widescreen. Personally, I don't like it at all. I usually switch to 8MP

[Arelunde]

Originally Posted by Merkie

Yeah you can. View the image, tap "Edit", tap the crop button, tap "restrict dimensions", choose "16x9". Cameras that have a 16:9 option do this automatically, but it's the same process.

This is a good option. I didn't realize it was there (thank you!) Also, stretching the photo via zoom works too. Single tap restores it to original aspect.

[bgro]

I had this same "issue" when I first got the 5. But it makes complete sense now. SLRs shoot in 3:2 and the 5's ratio is 16:9, and the 4/4S is 4:3. So pictures will look different depending on the "monitor" you are using.

[Merkie]

Originally Posted by bgro

I had this same "issue" when I first got the 5. But it makes complete sense now. SLRs shoot in 3:2 and the 5's ratio is 16:9, and the 4/4S is 4:3. So pictures will look different depending on the "monitor" you are using.

SLRs shoot in 4:3 and the 4/4S is 3:2.

[jps1012]

I know it might not be pure but i really wish the lens was setup to take full screen pics.

[jps1012]

Originally Posted by Merkie

Yeah you can. View the image, tap "Edit", tap the crop button, tap "restrict dimensions", choose "16x9". Cameras that have a 16:9 option do this automatically, but it's the same process.

Does this lower the resolution of the pic? Or does only zooming lower resolution?

[mandark100]

Many phones does have the option to take photos in widescreen(obviously the resolution is lower. If the phone has a 8MP camera widescreen photos are of 6/5MP). I don't know if there is any option to capture widescreen photo in iPhone 5.

[xesf92]

Cameras pictures for 4:3. IPhone screen is opened.