mkrishnan said:
Yeah....
I dunno, though. I understand that the UK has passed laws that help teachers restrain students. But teachers are not properly equipped for physical intervention against students with weapons.... This is awful. What is the answer? To have armed guards in schools? Ugh.
I work with some of the most dangerous people in Europe, and can be involved in up-to 15 restraints a day. We're trained to remove weapons with the exception of firearms (we were shown, but only out of interest), and we work in teams to do this. Despite that I'll tell you straight - when weapons are involved, back away and call the police. No ifs, buts or maybes. You don't go in against weapons.
The idea that teachers should be trained to restrain pupils is ludicrous.
Scenario 1: Pupil becomes aggressive towards a teacher. The teacher feels unsafe and makes the decision to restrain. Firstly one person alone cannot safely (both physically and legally) restrain another. So that needs two people. Now who's going to look after the rest of the class? 3 people. Once you've taken the child to the ground, you're going to need someone on the head and someone (or two, depending on their strength) on the legs. So we're at 5/6 people.
Scenario 2: Two pupils are fighting. You need 3 staff on each pupil to safely separate them. So we're at 6 staff. When you take them to the ground you'll need minimum 2 more and preferably 3 more per pupil, so that's 10/12 staff to safely separate the fight, and 1 to control the rest of the pupils. So we need 11 to 13 staff to safely end a confrontation between two children. 4 of those staff are injured in the restraint and require time off work. Who covers them?
Now...the child has kicked off for whatever reason, presumably they're not too happy at the teacher. Will they be more happy or less happy when the teacher is putting them in locks? Restraint is fast, it's hard and it hurts. Where will they restrain the pupil, in-front of every other pupil? How will the teachers exit?
Scenario 3: The teacher feels threatened by a pupil. They make the decision to restrain but while doing so the pupil is hit by another pupil. Now the teacher has a whole lot of legal problems because they were holding someone down while another was assaulting them.
That's just scratching the surface, in my head there are hundreds of 'what ifs' flying around, most of which are based on prior experience.
AppleMatt