|May 18, 2013, 04:49 PM||#1|
Mac Pro no video.
I have a mac pro A1186 emc no 2113 M43 base/3.0qx/2x512/7300gt/250/sd
It had a faulty video card that i removed and replaced a blown capacitor.
the video card worked for a while..so being confident I replaced all the caps that were going bad.
Then as i replaced card..pop!!! I think i had a short on the card...
So needless to say i now have no video...
I replaced the video card with what was a "used known working" (Nvidia A386 rev A01) from ebay.
Still no video.
On pressing test switch LEDS show....
EFI = ON
Power = ON
GPU = OFF
CPUA = OFF
CPUB = OFF
CPUA = OFF
CPUB = OFF
TRICKLE = ON
SLEEP = no led missing
I have tried placing video card in other slots to see if power in different slot.
on Removing video card, heatsink feels warm, so maybe getting power.
I have started mac as target drive to remove files.
I have also booted Mac to OS as I can hear volume chirp go up and down while using keyboard. I can also eject DVD/CD using keyboard.
I have also tried booting with ASD 35108.
1.Is it possible that I purchased an incorrect video card or faulty one?? possible.
2.Is it possible to test power supply to make sure i have all voltages?
3.IS it possible to test logic board to see if I have blown a SM fuse ,resistor or voltage regulator?
I have a pc RADION HD 5770
Placing in PCIE slot fan runs full speed =Still no video but boots (needs flashing for mac)
with Nvidia A386 rev A01 in slot 1 machine boots..but still no GPU.
Where should I start diagnosis.
Thanks for your help
Last edited by studiopaul; May 18, 2013 at 06:03 PM.
|May 18, 2013, 05:47 PM||#2|
Sounds to me like you now have a very nice door-stop. Maybe make a lamp out of it or something. I don't think it's worth buying replacement parts for unless you can find some exceptional deals. With the prices I typically see you can replace the entire machine for about the same as just the main-board alone. And at that point why not go for something newer and faster for just a little extra?
|May 18, 2013, 06:00 PM||#3|
let me be clear...
the original video card, had a swollen (blown capacitor)
This is where the repair took place.
Later I had the same problem and decided to repair replace all the old dried capacitors...this is how i shorted out video card...more likely blowing motherboard.
I hope this is clear
|May 18, 2013, 06:05 PM||#4|
K, I see. And of course I come to the same conclusion that way too.
The good news is that there's no cat living in your machine. Always something to be thankful for!
|May 18, 2013, 07:07 PM||#6|
however I would like to find the fault and repair.
at least know if its PSU or motherboard and confirm.
I have set up a network on this computer..is there any way to remote login and switch on screen share?
Last edited by studiopaul; May 18, 2013 at 07:26 PM.
|May 19, 2013, 09:59 AM||#8|
power mac no video
wheres the bang head face!!!!
Yes this is the card!! was sold as pcie for Mac pro...duuoooohhh!
Ok so let me get this straight..Mac has a G5 PCIE graphic slot.
I just checked my Power MAC G5 A1047 emc1969c
card does not fit..so assume there is an in between model.
I purchased a video card, one from apple when this machine was fully working (with failing original card)..i forget the model..it was the one they issued as an upgrade with the white exhaust fan.
Plug and play they said...this one did not work...hence my original repair to the failing card.
any suggested known good, correct replacements? with exact model numbers and correct flash firmware?
Wondering if anyone has had good experience at flashing one of these?
Last edited by studiopaul; May 19, 2013 at 12:36 PM.
|May 19, 2013, 12:57 PM||#9|
Ok so im trying to find known achieved flashing of RADION HD 5770
I do not have a PC..so are there any way to load a boot code CD/DVD to flash this card?
Anyone ever try this?
I found this:
anyone??? Bueller?? Bueller?? lol
On inspection I have a missing power cable to the radeon HD 5770
I will try purchase in next few days.
Anyone know if this card will boot or if needs to be flashed?
Last edited by studiopaul; May 19, 2013 at 03:03 PM.
|May 25, 2013, 06:37 PM||#11|
5770 will work unflashed if you have 10.6.4 or higher installed. Power cable is necessary ofc. You can upgrade OS in target disk mode if necessary, using another Mac.
If your MP boots without graphics card, it seems that logic board and PSU are OK.
|May 25, 2013, 08:26 PM||#12|
Thanks 666... so i assume i can do a fresh drive install from dvd with 10.6.4 it will auto configure?
got power cable...something tells me 10.6.8 is installed..so this could be bad ????
Last edited by studiopaul; May 25, 2013 at 08:44 PM.
|May 25, 2013, 10:22 PM||#13|
|May 27, 2013, 10:48 AM||#18|
Unflashed 5770 should at least give VESA screen if booted from DOS disk.
Some people are having problems with Freedos, IDK why, I'm always using WinMe boot disc.
Try this way:
– ensure that you have 10.6.8 installed on MP – try target disk mode if you have another Mac
– if you have a PC, test 5770 in it, if it's OK, proceed to the next step
– DL WinMe bootdisk.iso from:http://www.allbootdisks.com/download/iso.html and burn it on CD
– reset SMC in MP, PRAM too (it will clear default boot drive set in NVRAM)
– install the 5770 in MP and don't forget to plug PCIe cable in
– try to boot from WinMe CD
Try slot 3 as well if it won't work in slot 1.
If you'll get video, you can think about flashing the card.
|May 27, 2013, 11:38 AM||#20|
a) boot second Mac normally then go to Sys Prefs/Startup Disk and check available boot volumes (OS version will be listed with volume name)
b) boot your second Mac from MP's HDD (alt/option to select boot drive) if possible. If your second Mac is too new for OS version installed on MP HDD, this method won't work
There is also another, "network" way: https://discussions.apple.com/thread...art=0&tstart=0
|May 27, 2013, 12:25 PM||#21|
Looks like my old G5 will not show as a possible boot in both methods.
I assume too old as a boot option.
I will now try the different DOS options you suggest and moving video card into different slots..
And once again thanks for the help
|May 29, 2013, 11:10 PM||#22|
so tried to check drive (target disk mode) on Macbook and it indeed shows as 10.6.8
I tried moving graphic card to other slots..(remember this video card takes up the space of 2 cards). on boot freedos.. still blank screen.
Should i proceed to try other dos programs or assume mother board at this point as we now know i have 10.6.8 installed....???
|May 30, 2013, 12:55 AM||#23|
To me, it sounds like you just need a new video card. I don't know how you came to the conclusion that a blown capacitor on your video card could lead to a dead motherboard. That's like saying you cut your finger, so you will get a brain tumor.
Stop trying to mess around with unsupported video cards to reduce the number of things that can go wrong. Just get a video card meant for Mac Pro 1,1 (aka 2006 Mac Pro) and you should be fine.
Things to remember:
1. You have a Mac Pro 1,1. Those need video cards with EFI32 firmware.
2. Video cards with EFI64 firmware will not work for you.
3. Video cards for G5s will not work for you.
4. You can't use your G5 to flash a PC video card to be compatible with your Mac Pro. (At least I've never heard of it being done.)
5. Your G5 will not boot off of your Mac Pro in Target Disk Mode.
|May 30, 2013, 11:49 PM||#24|
Ok , if you didnt read all the post..i will explain once more.
I had the original video card fault.. it showed a swollen or dry capacitor.
I replaced with a new capacitor = card worked fine until it showed other faults.
so...i replaced all caps on this card...here's where a problem may have arisen.
On power up there was a pop..and it blew the cap one of the caps on video card...thats where the concern is for the blown motherboard comes into play...a short circuit on video card may have zapped the motherboard.
I know you can not boot from G5 mac..as the osx is not supported..i get that.
i managed purely to read the osx from an intel macbook..it shows osx 10.6.8
now..10.6.8.. is meant to support this card..if that is the case i still have no video output.
It would be great if I could prove that the video card was operating under a dos boot..or not..in order to prove motherboard either working or failed.
At this point I may have to buy a known working video card..just to find motherboard is fried...unless someone can inform me of a way to network to this cpu and look at it from a diagnostic state ( switching on monitor share via ethernet ).
|May 31, 2013, 01:07 AM||#25|
If your MacBook is able to run 10.6.8, boot it off of MP HDD and turn screen sharing on. See my 2 previous posts. Read carefully.
You don't need a Mac card, only known working PC one to boot DOS on MP.
Did you test 5770 in a PC? Did you buy power cable for it? What about WinMe boot disk? Did you reset SMC and PRAM?
Do it and post results instead of explain your issue over and over again People are trying to help you, but you need to co-operate
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|What video card for a 3.1 Mac Pro||dobro03||Mac Pro||20||Nov 23, 2014 07:36 AM|
|Professionals Successfully Push Mac Pro to Absurd Limits With 558-Day Video Timeline in Final Cut Pro||MacRumors||Mac Blog Discussion||113||May 27, 2014 02:59 AM|
|New MacBook Pro Retina or Mac Pro for Video Editing||Joel M||MacBook Pro||5||Nov 3, 2013 12:42 AM|
|MacX DVD Ripper/Video Converter Pro VS. Mac DVDRipper Pro VS. DVDRemaster 8||evenstill||Mac Applications and Mac App Store||5||May 20, 2013 09:46 AM|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:54 AM.