Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

ezsobre

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 18, 2007
49
2
Hi all. Just bought a new laptop and an appletv so i could get mirroring and streaming going. Problem is I have only one hdmi port on my tv (its old) and only one on my sony blu-ray player, which is just an hdmi output (also a few years old) which acts as the receiver into which my internet and speakers connect and interact.

I'm not too savvy on hdmi, but can i get what i'm seeing on google called an "hdmi splitter" (or is "hdmi switcher" i want?) to solve the problem? Will that effectively act like a power strip? Or does the switcher only allow one signal at a time to go in/out and you have to switch between them? Also, i'm guessing I can't use the splitter on the bluray if it only has an output port, but maybe on the tv? If I use a switcher on the tv hdmi and plug the bluray and appletv into it, will the appletv be able to reach the speakers connected to the bluray, or does the switch mean only one can operate once? If the latter, I will a toslink optical audio cable connecting the atv to the bluray solve the problem?

Alternatively it looks like I can run a optical cable from the tv to the receiver the speakers are connected to. In theory then i could connect the appletv via hdmi directly to the tv, and run the audio out of the tv and into the bluray receiver, and just use that as an audio receiver and forget about video from it since i have the appletv now. Anyone tried that? I don't have an optical cable so will need to pick one up to test.

Thanks for any suggestions.
 
Last edited:

markrath

macrumors member
Nov 23, 2011
59
52
Here is what I have and how I solved a similar problem:
TV with 3 HDMI in and 1 Optical out
BlueRay (and surround sound) with 2 optical in 1 HDMI in and 1 HDMI out
Dish Hopper
AppleTV
XBOX 360
I also wanted to on occasion run my computer/iPad etc through HDMI

I have my Dish in HDMI 1 of the TV and optical 1 of the BlueRay
I have the AppleTV in the HDMI 2 of the TV and the 2 of the BlueRay
My BlueRay goes into HDMI 3 of the TV

Here comes the splinting part: I have a device that has 4 HDMI in and 1 out (splitter if you will) it's connected to the HDMI in of my BlueRay. I can run my xbox, computer and two other devices into this. Only one device can be seen on the tv at a time however. Since it's going into the BlueRay there is no need for additional sound output.

In your situation a splitter into the tv and using the optical out should work. My experience with my HDMI 4 and 1 has been a little spotty with my xbox. I believe it's because the xbox may require more power so I think I just need to experiment a little.

Long answer to a short question yes the splitter should work however it may have some limitations. Like most things if you pay for a high end splitter you may have less issues.

Good luck

Hi all. Just bought a new laptop and an appletv so i could get mirroring and streaming going. Problem is I have only one hdmi port on my tv (its old) and only one on my sony blu-ray player, which is jsut an hdmi output (also a few years old) which acts as the receiver into which my internet and speakers connect and interact.

I'm not too savvy on hdmi, but can i get what i'm seeing on google called an "hdmi splitter" (or is "hdmi switcher" i want?) to solve the problem? Will that effectively act like an power strip? Or does the splitter only allow one signal at a time to go in/out and you have to switch between them? Also, i'm guessing I can't use the splitter on the bluray if it only has an output port, but maybe on the tv?

Alternatively it looks like I can run a optical cable from the tv to the receiver the speakers are connected to. In theory then i could connect the appletv via hdmi directly to the tv, and run the audio out of the tv and into the bluray receiver, and just use that as an audio receiver and forget about video from it since i have the appletv now. Anyone tried that? I don't have an optical cable so will need to pick one up to test.

Thanks for any suggestions.
 

takeshi74

macrumors 601
Feb 9, 2011
4,974
68
It would probably be easier to answer your questions if you'd post the model of your receiver and bluray. Might as well post the model of TV as well. Are your speakers stereo or surround? Some TV's with ARC don't support surround sound for audio output.

It would probably be easiest just to get a receiver with multiple HDMI inputs but there might be a solution that doesn't require the outlay.

I'm not too savvy on hdmi, but can i get what i'm seeing on google called an "hdmi splitter" (or is "hdmi switcher" i want?) to solve the problem?
I have a device that has 4 HDMI in and 1 out (splitter if you will)
Those are called switchers. They switch from one source to another. A splitter splits one source to multiple targets.
 
Last edited:

westrock2000

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2013
524
22
HDMI switcher connected to TV. Then connect all your devices to the switcher. Make sure the switcher has an "auto" feature to automatically switch to the most recently active device. It will be completely seamless and require no effort on your part.

I bought one for ~$35 at Fry's. Bytecc brand. Also available at Amazon.
http://www.frys.com/product/7037801
 

ezsobre

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 18, 2007
49
2
Will I need to separately connect the atv to the bluray for the speakers? Or will the sound run from the atv through the switcher to the bluray connected speakers?
 

ezsobre

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 18, 2007
49
2
@takeshi74

It's an entry level bluray either Sony bdp s350 or 550. One Hdmi out. Optical audio jack, coaxial and stereo outs. Component, s video and composite video outs. Speakers are surround. TV is an older Olevia which is basically just an LCD monitor with Hdmi jack and all the above audio and video plugs.
 

westrock2000

macrumors 6502a
Oct 18, 2013
524
22
@takeshi74

It's an entry level bluray either Sony bdp s350 or 550. One Hdmi out. Optical audio jack, coaxial and stereo outs. Component, s video and composite video outs. Speakers are surround. TV is an older Olevia which is basically just an LCD monitor with Hdmi jack and all the above audio and video plugs.

You could look for a switch similar to this one
http://www.monoprice.com/Product/?c...=1011002&p_id=7974&seq=1&format=2#description

That splits out the digital audio from the HDMI to a dedicated optical/coax. That way all the devices behind the switch will send digital audio to the speakers and the video can continue through the HDMI OUT to the TV.
 

ezsobre

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 18, 2007
49
2
Solution?

I think i found a solution that doesn't require a switch. Toslink cable from atv to sony bluray. Put bluray in audio mode. Run hdmi from atv to tv. Done. Thanks for your help.
 

hallux

macrumors 68040
Apr 25, 2012
3,437
1,005
So, your speakers connect directly to the Blu-Ray player? Normally you need an A/V receiver to provide the speaker connections.

Can the optical jack on that player act as an input? I looked up both models that you say yours might be, both list the optical as OUTPUT, not input. Also, does your TV have an optical output? I'd run everything to the TV with HDMI (using a switch if needed) then run optical from the TV to your audio device.

Mine is set up like this:

DVR and ATV connected to the TV through HDMI (I have 2 HDMI inputs, swap the DVD/Blu-Ray in for the ATV if needed or wanted). TV routes audio through optical out to my RCA surround receiver which sends to my speakers.
 

Mrbobb

macrumors 603
Aug 27, 2012
5,009
209
I think i found a solution that doesn't require a switch. Toslink cable from atv to sony bluray. Put bluray in audio mode. Run hdmi from atv to tv. Done. Thanks for your help.

Glade u found a solution.

But sooner or later, the next HDMI source will again bump you through this limitation.

Next upgrade, more HDMI ports on TV or new receiver with multiple HDMI-INS.
 

ezsobre

macrumors member
Original poster
Dec 18, 2007
49
2
I had the bluray model wrong. Its a 570, which as an optical in from a tv. I set it in tv mode (rather than audio), connect the appletv with optical cable, and then connect appletv with hdmi to my tv, and it works like a charm.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.