Kelmon you're right. Had Surface pro 2 been launched I would have snapped that up, and before I went into the store recently to take another look at the RMBP I was still dismissive of Apple and their Macs.
My dream machine is a 13inch PC tablet with a retina class screen (see Samsung ATIV Book Q that was never released).
When posting and voicing my concerns I seem to pile on the negatives.
Things I dont like:
The dock
The way I close a window and the program hasnt exited. I need to click "File, quit" or control q. Really annoying too. I expect the program to stop running and allow the program underneath to take over.
The inability to maximize a window like in windows. I feel like Im wasting space, conversly, Kelmon, you feel like you're wasting space for the opposite reason.
Brushed Aluminum design (Johnny Ive, please fix that) and lack of customizability.
Wasted space on the sides of the dock.
The animation to fully maximze an app to take up the entire screen is a slow animation meant for old people. I want that stuff dont at the speed of thought.
Needing to press the control key to right click (though Im getting over that)
In sum, sometimes when I use a mac I feel like Im constipated. Prime example: the sticky notes widget. In windows I can add new sticky notes quickly after I open the app. On OSX I need to go back down to a corner every time to add a new sticky note. Its slower and mentally jarring compared to Windows' sticky note app. Little things like that (slow animation speed) (I want the browser, not the dock) make using macs give me a constipated feeling.
Converserly Windows is pretty fast. The charms bar comes right up. Swiping stuff comes right up. Moving the mouse to the top left brings up all other apps pretty quickly. Windows 8 adds an unecessary step inbetween a lot of things (really, click and drag up the image to unlock your computer? Back in my day screen savers just let you move the mouse), but I've gotten used to it.
Those negatives being said a friend of mine showed me his mac mini a couple year ago with the magic mouse and I was quite impressed. Sliding between multiple screens, adding multipe desktops to multiply the multitasking. Even with my time in the store when I got busy and started "moving stuff around" i was adapting to it well and enjoying it and I was doing it really well with the track pad. For what I use a PC for (WP/internet/media at the market price
) a RMBP would be almost over powering, but I work hard for my money and I like nice things. I dont want to come home and look at anything I own and value and feel like its not for me. Sounds silly, so I'll explain further. The water ski I own was just as expensive and rides just well as all the other skis, but its the one that looks like MY ski and I'm proud to ride it every time Im out. My last Samsung PC was MY PC. 11inches of slim, simple and beatiful, until it broke. When I picked up the Retina Macbook Pro I got a good feeling like... Dang, I should walk out of here right now. Simple, pure, sexy, it felt like MY PC.
Im sure I'll adapt to OSX just fine. My last session in the store was pleasant, and fun. What it come down to is form factor. I read and browse on my sofa all day. I used my last PC a lot like a tablet except that it was akwardly on my stomach and chest with a KB. I intend to use a Surface pro the same way, however that small screen space could be a pain when I get that "research itch" when I bury my face in a computer for hours and days on end reading up on stuff... like right now.
A RMBP on the other hand has a lot of screen real estate, so I could multi task better. It feels good, the battery lasts longer. The retina screen means my eyes wont get nearly as blurry or bad after power sessions using it.
Then again I could just get a surface pro 2 and a TV/monitor and mix the two when I need the screen realestate, it would save me money instead of buying both.
I could also make like honey badger and do what i want and not give a ..... get a surface pro 2. RMBP and a TV/monitor. Do i need all that? Absolutely not, but it would cover every base and eliminate all inconveniences I have with computing.
You guys have been very helpful.
I also checked wikipedia. the current RMBP should be able to run an Apple OSX for the next 4-5 years.