Excellent info. It does seem to be a pretty easy solution to just keep hubby's dumb phone the shared plan. I really have no idea about how much data to buy. This will be the 12 year old's first smartphone. I don't want to be overly restrictive but I know she is used to having pretty tight reins from her parents and I don't want to undermine the good job they are doing raising their kids. Thanks for stating this in such an easy to understand way.
A lot of great information here. Verizon has some great offerings and the price breakdowns are awesome, but they don't take monthly taxes into consideration. I would make sure and find out how much their charge for taxes and add it to your spreadsheet. I used to pay $13 on a $50 postpaid plan at T-Mobile. My main reason for going pre-paid was to be able to reduce my monthly bill. $13 x 24 months = $312 in taxes on service I don't pay anymore. I now pay $0 taxes on a $35 pre-paid/auto pay plan at
Cricket Wireless.
I've been a happy T-mobile @ $50 a month , unhappy Verizon customer (iPad experience - too expensive and customer service wasn't very nice when I had trouble activating), melancholy Straight Talk customer (customer service doesn't answer the phone and they don't have visual voicemail on the iPhone - service is also $45/month). I am super happy with Cricket at $35/month.
If you live in an area that has good AT&T Prepaid Coverage, I would definitely consider Cricket Wireless. Your service per phone for unlimited talk/text/mms/data is $35/month including taxes. It includes 500MB if high speed data, then the speed gets reduced to a lower speed which is still fine for maps and music. I ported my number to Cricket and the SIM card worked beautifully in my unlocked iPhone 4 (AT&T). It took less than 15 minutes in the store. You can port your old number over and do it on the website for $10 SIM fee, or in person at the store for a $20 SIM fee and they handle all the details for you (check with individual stores, your mileage may vary). Here in San Francisco, I have found that AT&T and T-Mobile have better coverage than Verizon.
They also have deals where you can get your 12 year old a less expensive starter phone, or you can actually use an older model iPhone as well. I picked up a Nokia Lumia 630 for $49.99 - $50 rebate = zero cost except for the tax on the device. It is definitely not an iPhone but it does have enough features and games to keep a new smart phone owner happy for minimal cost. Cricket is owned by AT&T and is their "brand"of prepaid wireless. The beauty of using a prepaid company is that you don't pay the extra $$$ in taxes that postpaid accounts levy on customers. Cricket also sells iPhones, but I would suggest buying the phone at the Apple store for the same price and unlocked. Apple offers free shipping and special financing.
Cricket also offers a discount for adding multiple phones. If you are on the $40/month unlimited plan you can save a lot of money:
First Eligible Line No Discount
Second Eligible Line $10 Monthly Discount
Third Eligible Line $20 Monthly Discount
Fourth Eligible Line $30 Monthly Discount
Fifth Eligible Line $30 Monthly Discount
The maximum monthly discount is $90 when you have 5 eligible lines on your account.
Compared to the excellent Verizon EDGE breakdown, here is what Cricket will cost you:
Cricket Wireless
Basic Unlimited Monthly service:
Line 1 = $40
Line 2 = $30
Line 3 = $20
Line 4 = $10
Total = $100
Each line gets their own 500MB of 4G LTE speed, then gets reduced. If you want a line with 2.5G of high speed data, add $10, 5G of high speed data, add $20. You can customize each line as you see fit, but so far the 500MB has suited me well.
$100 x 24 months = $2,400
Device Cost for 3 new iPhone 5s 16GB
3x $649 = $1,947 (plus tax)
Upfront Cost
$80 SIM/Activation fees (could be waived depending on store/doing it online)
2-Year Total = $4427 (plus tax on the iPhones)
Compare that to the other carriers.
If you decide to go with
Cricket Wireless, they are having a referral promotion that if you get referred my a current customer, you get a $25 credit after 45 days as so does the person referring you. If you decide to go that route, please send me a private message so we both can take advantage of the credit. If you want to do it with another forum member that suggested Cricket, that is fine as well, just take advantage of the promo.
Hope this helped and made some sense. Your hubby can use your iPhone 5 as a full smartphone. Verizon iPhone 5 GSM is carrier unlocked due to an FCC ruling so it should work on Cricket without any problems. That also makes your iPhone 5 have better resale value due to the versatility of being unlocked.
Cricket was one of the least painless switches I have made, and I have been using the iPhone on alternate carriers since 2008 to save money.
You can always test Cricket in your area by just having them put a SIM card in your phone at the store and seeing what the signal is like. Doing a test for a month as well might be a good idea - and easy since there is no commitment.
Let me know if you have any other questions.