I’ve been considering a Mac Mini for a bit now but have been put off by all the “negative press” from Mac users about how poor value the Mac Mini represents with its closed off upgradability. One of the bigger head scratchers for me is all the suggestions (especially on YouTube) that your are better off buying a MacBook Air than a mini?? I mean, really? You get the same lack of upgradability, a much slower CPU, slower integrated graphics, fewer drive options, etc. all for a much higher price point. Looking at it from that standpoint I fail to see how the Mac Mini represents poor value. Seems to me the real overpriced units are the Mac Book Airs, not the Minis.
The MacBook Air is a better option as its 'slow hardware with fast storage' over 'slow hardware and slow storage'. My iMac with a HDD is amazingly fast for me, and still opens the likes of Photoshop in under 2 seconds but when I try the like of a HDD Mac Mini, they are very sluggish. Having a shot of a MacBook Air give nice performace due to the SSD compensating the low end hardware.
If you already own a monitor, and an Apple keyboard and mouse then the Mac Mini is something defiantly considering with a low budget. The entry model should only really be bought for basic tasks (the norm, but there is no reasons to why it can't edit photo and video, just it won't be as fast as other Macs) but the mid teir model is surprisingly good. Double the RAM, double the backing storage, higher end CPU (that actually performs pretty well considering it's dual core, with it having around the 13" retina Pros in terms of performance), and a better GPU.
If Apple really wanted to appeal to PC desktop users though, they should have made a Mac Mini with easy to upgrade RAM and HDD as well as Intel Iris Pro and Quad Core options. Maybe the excusion of an aluminium enclosure as that would really bring the price down. Having an Apple TV like box made out of white or black plastic, would really lower the price.
This is what I would want to see:
Mac Mini Entry model
Dual Core i5 (rMBP 13" level of perfromace)
4GB of RAM (user upgradable to 16GB)
Intel Iris GPU
mini Fusion Drive (64GB non PCIe SSD and a 500GB HDD)
Plastic enclosure
Price: £449
Mac Mini High Config. model
Quad Core i5 (upgradable to a quad core i7)
8GB of RAM (user upgradable to 16GB)
Intel Iris Pro
1TB mini Fusion Drive (64GB non PCIe SSD and a 1TB HDD)
Plastic enclosure
Price: £649