Hello there, I'm struggling with similar issue with my 21.5 inch 2011 iMac, the only difference is that I can't even get 2560x1440 on 25" display. On miniDP-hdmi cable and same type adapter I only got 1080p. Strangly or not three DP cables I tried won't work at all. I have tried miniDP-miniDP, and 2 different miniDP-DP cables. One of them is actively used by my colleague on 2014 Mac Book (with thunderbolt 2) with success. After tried so many options I pretty sure that first gen thunderbolt need kinda special cable with additional electronic inside, or the only option is to hunt for better quality miniDP-HDMI cable. Maybe someone can guide me for good quality cable of that type? Thanks a lot!