iPod Agent 18 VideoShield for iPod any good?

im using that same hardcase- I have no problem with it very protective fits snugly tight. dropped my ipod in it and the ipod is dent free, but if im understanding you correctly you're asking if the case scratches the ipod? like the silicone ones? maybe? mine doesn't cause i bought the the screen protector with it

Yes- it shields the screen. Yes, it is as snug as it gets. Mine isn't scratched at all, but I take care of it.

yeah, do get one.

i use mine and love it. minimal effort required, protects really well and is still a good form factor.

S

Eh, I'd have to disagree with them. It fits snug, you don't have to worry about the case getting scratched, but at the top of the iPod, grit and dust get inbetween the case and the iPod, and there is just enough movement inside of the case that those will make essentially micro-scratches and tiny gouges. These won't be REAL obvious, but after awhile they'll annoy you if you're pretty paranoid about it. And I still don't know why they made the front frosty... it just looks bad. Oh, and if you did get one already, you could always put a piece of clear packing tape on the inside of the back piece to make sure the iPod is extra secure.

Yes is fits snugly and yes it protects pretty well, but it does get "wet spots" between it and the iPod and when they appear on the screen it's really annoying. I have no idea how to eliminate them. These spots appear where ever the case touches the iPod. It's actually annoying enough that I stopped using mine.

I Contour iSee case is very similar to the Agent 18 the only difference is the iSee includes a removeable belt clip and the iSee does not get "wet spots", (although it's snug and your iPod can't move in it) so maybe a consideration for you as well. Well, maybe a couple minor wet spots on the back, but none on the front.

The contour case has one advantage. If you drop the videoshielded iPod in a certain way, it's possible for the two halves of the case to disassemble because they're snapped together. The showcase is buckled closed. I like the videoshield though. Low-profile and does provide protection against keys, etc.