MacBook sudden shutdown
drake said:
My guess, the computer is overheating and the Intel protection is kicking in.
I am also experiencing shutdowns with my MacBook (base model) purchased mid-May. The random shutdowns have NEVER happened when the MacBook is hot. They have always happened in the first few minutes of switch on or coming out of sleep (when cold). Always the shutdown is immediately preceeded by the fan spinning up.
When a sudden shutdown occurs, using the power button causes the MacBook to power up and shut down within 1-2 seconds, again with the fan spinning up. It needs around 4 attempts to make it boot properly.
I have tried resetting PMU and also PRAM but it makes no difference. I have also wiped the HDD and re-installed from the supplied disks. I have inspected the battery and there is no visible damage. The battery capacity indication in System Profile is normal. In any event, I always run the MacBook off the power supply so its unlikely to be a battery problem.
Sometimes the MacBook will run for a couple of days without this problem happening.
The problem first started when the MacBook was about two week old. About that time I also replaced the standard RAM with 2gb third-party RAM. Initially I thought it was due to me shutting the lid and leaving the MacBook in sleep mode. So I started shutting down and the problem continued.
Eventually I removed the third-party ram and put back the original RAM. The problems still continued even with further PMU and PRAM resets (bong three times).
I have been busy with work so I did not get round to taking it to the local Apple store in London until last Sunday (2 July). I was told that I had left the problem too long without contacting Apple so they could not replace the MacBook. Also the problem could not be reproduced at the Genius Bar and I do not think this helped the situation. So they took it in for testing.
I just checked the Apple website and it appears that the repair has been cancelled on Monday (3 July) but I do not know what this means as I have not been contacted by the store.
I suspect that there is a defective thermal sensor in the computer which is causing the cold MacBook to think it is overheating. I am assuming this as the sudden shutdown is always preceeded by the fan spinning up.
I am also concerned that the sudden shutdowns are so intermittent (once every two days) that Apple may not be able to reproduce the fault and will return the faulty MacBook to me.