Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
OK, then... why not a laptop with a removable keyboard?
- Thread starter ShovelHead84
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Counterfit
macrumors G3
No cables means it has to have power (battery). That alone adds size, then figure in a data connection of some sort, probably RF so lack of line-of-sight isn't a problem. Those all currently add size and weight, two enemies of good laptop design.
In the future, however, when short range power delivery is possible without wires, this could be feasible.
Edit: Just saw the thread about the Dell M2010, which has a detachable keyboard. Search and see for yourself.
In the future, however, when short range power delivery is possible without wires, this could be feasible.
Edit: Just saw the thread about the Dell M2010, which has a detachable keyboard. Search and see for yourself.
Satellite 1950 series
Toshiba made a laptop almost 5 years ago that had a wireless removable keyboard.
The Satellite 1950 and some of the 1955 series had that feature.
I have a 1950, best laptop ever for desktop replacement. The new Dell XPS 2010 may rival it but it weighs twice as much so it is not so portable.
Toshiba made a laptop almost 5 years ago that had a wireless removable keyboard.
The Satellite 1950 and some of the 1955 series had that feature.
I have a 1950, best laptop ever for desktop replacement. The new Dell XPS 2010 may rival it but it weighs twice as much so it is not so portable.
Eraserhead
macrumors G4
Why would you want one? I'm genuinely puzzled as to the point. You can hook up an external keyboard to a laptop if you wish (as well as an external display), and it hardly adds weight to the laptop having a keyboard.
Why I have a Satellite 1950
Why would you want one?
16" screen with 4:3 aspect ratio, more vertical space is better for software development than horizontal (I can see more lines of code which is more important than being able to watch movies on an airplane).
But you were asking about the keyboard weren't you? 😉
A removeable keyboard means you can sit back comfortably instead of hunching over the laptop to be able to type. Not to mention being further from the screen is easier on your eyes.
Then there is the fact that you don't have to carry a seperate keyboard around with you as was suggested, it may not weigh much but you still have to go through the hassle of packing and unpacking it and finding a good place for it in your bag. An extra keyboard is just a needless pain.
As to how it would be accomplished with no cables?
Toshiba did it with radio frequency I think (I might be wrong on that) and the wireless mouse may be infra red (but I could be wrong on that too, I know it has an infra red receiver but maybe that was for something else).
It has a small rechargeable battery that charges will the keyboard is "docked" and lasts for hours disconnected (days if you aren't playing games with it).
The range is good for several feet and there are a couple channels in case you sit next to someone using the same laptop.
Why would you want one?
16" screen with 4:3 aspect ratio, more vertical space is better for software development than horizontal (I can see more lines of code which is more important than being able to watch movies on an airplane).
But you were asking about the keyboard weren't you? 😉
A removeable keyboard means you can sit back comfortably instead of hunching over the laptop to be able to type. Not to mention being further from the screen is easier on your eyes.
Then there is the fact that you don't have to carry a seperate keyboard around with you as was suggested, it may not weigh much but you still have to go through the hassle of packing and unpacking it and finding a good place for it in your bag. An extra keyboard is just a needless pain.
As to how it would be accomplished with no cables?
Toshiba did it with radio frequency I think (I might be wrong on that) and the wireless mouse may be infra red (but I could be wrong on that too, I know it has an infra red receiver but maybe that was for something else).
It has a small rechargeable battery that charges will the keyboard is "docked" and lasts for hours disconnected (days if you aren't playing games with it).
The range is good for several feet and there are a couple channels in case you sit next to someone using the same laptop.
benthewraith
macrumors 68040
Compaq made a tablet PC that had a removable keyboard. You can see it in Stargate Atlantis, it's the laptop in Weir's office. Needless to say, had I not gotten a Mac, that would have been the laptop I would have.
Josh396
macrumors 65816
I don't see how you have to put hunching over your laptop to use one. I use one, not as my main computer, but I can easily sit 2-3 feet away from the keyboard and still be able to see the screen perfectly fine, not to mention the fact that I have bad eyes.
Eraserhead
macrumors G4
definitely, I certainly never hunch over my Macbook. I kinda see the point on software dev. though I have never found vertical space to be an issue when developing (though Expose is damn helpful)