Been Glossy for 2 years and still going strong. From what I have read and heard from others, the situation is opposite of what you describe. In most cases, people who DON'T like glossy but get it for one reason or another (Wife, Work, Availability) mumble and grumble for a day or so until they get really into the screen and its look.
Glossy will have some reflections in certain situations. There are people who see these reflections once and completely forget about them. Then there are people who see these reflections and just can't constitutionally forget about them, it grinds at their subconscious even.
Besides, MBP glossy screens are much more subdued than my PC glossy screens (My PC glossy screens are like mirrors compared to MBP glossy screens which are more like Glass Windows, TAKE THAT AERO).
Both types of screens are really quite beautiful though, as long as you don't fall into the small percentage of people who are so turned off by the thought of reflections that using a glossy screen actually results in mental and physical strain. Also, I've never really understood the screen color accuracy issue, I just calibrate the screen on my own with a Huey Pro and everything is perfect anyway!