Toggle sidebar Toggle sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Spaces "jumps" to active Application

johny5

johny5

macrumors 6502a
Original poster
I have had a look around for the answer to my question but cant find one 🙁
I use spaces and in one space I have macpar running extracting files whilst I am happily working in another space.

When the files have finished extracting I get thrown to the space where Macpar is sat and I really dont want that, I could be halfway through writing an email or in a spreadsheet so really dont want to be thrown back to the macpar app space to see that it has finished.
Is there any way around this? ie let macpar decompress everything, then finish and when I am ready I can navigate to that space myself.


thanks!
 
I've also noted this behavior and thought that it was something Apple would be fixing with 10.5.1. But they didn't. Maybe with 10.5.2. At least an option to turn off automatic switches between Spaces would be nice.
 
This isn't Apple's fault, it's the specific application's fault for calling itself to focus. Send a request to the program's developer to remove the focus call.
 
mnkeybsness said:
This isn't Apple's fault, it's the specific application's fault for calling itself to focus. Send a request to the program's developer to remove the focus call.
Click to expand...

But shouldn't we be able to setup Spaces to ignore focus calls from the non-current space?

Cheers,
 
panzer06 said:
But shouldn't we be able to setup Spaces to ignore focus calls from the non-current space?

Cheers,
Click to expand...

You would think that it would default to only call focus within it's space... the whole idea of spaces is to have multiple things going on independently of one another.
 
No, because often times and application really does need your attention and should bring you to it. Imagine that you right click on the application's icon in the dock and try to quit, but you have an unsaved document–the application now needs to take focus to prompt you to do something.

What I'm saying is that there are proper and improper uses of applications grabbing focus on their own. Some application developers seem to think that it's a necessary thing for random task completions, but they start to overuse it. This is just like the original poster is talking about: a task finishes and doesn't actually need to prompt the user to perform an action, but takes focus anyway.
 
mnkeybsness said:
No, because often times and application really does need your attention and should bring you to it. Imagine that you right click on the application's icon in the dock and try to quit, but you have an unsaved document–the application now needs to take focus to prompt you to do something.

What I'm saying is that there are proper and improper uses of applications grabbing focus on their own. Some application developers seem to think that it's a necessary thing for random task completions, but they start to overuse it. This is just like the original poster is talking about: a task finishes and doesn't actually need to prompt the user to perform an action, but takes focus anyway.
Click to expand...

If that space is my active space I'm fine with that; but shouldn't I be able to choose if I want to be interrupted by anything in the non-current space?

Cheers,
 
mnkeybsness said:
This isn't Apple's fault, it's the specific application's fault for calling itself to focus. Send a request to the program's developer to remove the focus call.
Click to expand...

I do agree, however I think there should be options in both the application and OSX spaces prefs with regards to turning it on or off.

Even better, how about in the spaces prefs you can specify individual apps to be able to allow or disable the control of the focus window, in a similar way that you already have the option as to which space the applications reside.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back