Gizmodo says Tris getting pulled from the App Store

[skestes]

http://gizmodo.com/5041287/free-ipho...from-app-store

Still downloadable as of this post though.

[aristobrat]

I think the article stated that it'd be removed Wednesday.

[Clyde099]

Get it while you can!

[x Danny]

Will it get removed when we sync iPods to iTunes?

[msmith2112]

Originally Posted by x Danny

Will it get removed when we sync iPods to iTunes?

Nope...

[11800506]

That's annoying... it's such a great app especially because it's free. I'm glad I already have it though.

[yoman]

Downloading now.... thanks for the heads up.

[x Danny]

Originally Posted by msmith2112

Nope...

Ah okay, goodie then. ^^;

[Small White Car]

Strange that he can't just change the name. That's what happened to Quinn.

http://www.macupdate.com/info.php/id/10063

Granted, it wasn't their name that changed, but a mention of Tetris on thier website. But once they took that wording off the site they were allowed to continue.

[Niiro13]

Originally Posted by x Danny

Ah okay, goodie then. ^^;

Just make sure you don't delete it from both the device and the computer...

[spyker3292]

@Small White Car

Still. It's stealing sales of the EA tetris app. So they would probably be pissed either way.

[aristobrat]

Does EA own the copyright for Tetris, or did they license it? I'd think that the copyright holder would have to be one to file any complaints?!

[Applepwns]

getting it even tho i don't have an iphone or ipod touch =D .. planning to get one tho..

[hawk1226]

Originally Posted by aristobrat

Does EA own the copyright for Tetris, or did they license it? I'd think that the copyright holder would have to be one to file any complaints?!

I'm not expert, but because of the relationship that apple has with EA...EA wants the app down and apple is willing to comply.

[Niiro13]

Originally Posted by aristobrat

Does EA own the copyright for Tetris, or did they license it? I'd think that the copyright holder would have to be one to file any complaints?!

A game can't be copyrighted, only patented...

But EA does have a license, since they bought one of the variants that was originally founded alongside the tetris company.

Originally Posted by hawk1226

I'm not expert, but because of the relationship that apple has with EA...EA wants the app down and apple is willing to comply.

And The Tetris Company decides, not EA :/. Since the Tetris company has the trademark and patent.

[Small White Car]

Originally Posted by spyker3292

@Small White Car

Still. It's stealing sales of the EA tetris app. So they would probably be pissed either way.

It doesn't matter if they're pissed.

It only matters if they have the right to force him to take it down. This guy seemed to think so. The guy who made Quinn did not seem to think so.

Why the difference? That's my question.

[Rojo]

Originally Posted by Small White Car

It doesn't matter if they're pissed.

It only matters if they have the right to force him to take it down. This guy seemed to think so. The guy who made Quinn did not seem to think so.

Why the difference? That's my question.

There may be no difference, other than the Tris guy is playing it safe...?

[ogdogg]

Tris needs a button to drop the piece all the way down. Having any decent long experience with the game is impossible until this update is put in place.

[jcde7ago]

Originally Posted by Rojo

There may be no difference, other than the Tris guy is playing it safe...?

If you read the Gizmodo article, the Tris developer simply doesn't have the resources to go to court and battle should The Tetris Company decide it wants to settle things that way.

Seriously though, i saw this coming the day Tris became one of the top apps...this reminds me EXACTLY of the Scrabulous debacle (for those of you in the Facebook know).

For those that don't know, Scrabulous was basically a re-branded Scrabble game, but gained a huge amount of popularity (literally hundreds of thousands were playing it). At first, Hasbro, the owner of the original Scrabble, didn't do much, but once Scrabulous became increasingly popular and once EA's official Hasbro-backed version of Scrabble (which sucked and never gained any popularity) was set to launch on Facebook, they hit Scrabulous + Facebook with pretty much a C&D order, much like how The Tetris Company is doing the same by taking it up to Apple + the Tris developer. It's all about money, folks....this isn't really so much about copyright infringements but about the fact that Tris stands as one of the top free apps and has taken away sales from the official Tetris app. Oh well, what can you do other than grab it while you can....

[marksman]

The author is an idiot if he does not think he is clearly violating their copyright.

He knows he is and is being a smart aleck about it.

I don't care if he had 1 billion dollars he would not win.

[Rojo]

Originally Posted by ogdogg

Tris needs a button to drop the piece all the way down. Having any decent long experience with the game is impossible until this update is put in place.

Uh...don't think you're going to get an update now. (At least not through the app store).

[jcde7ago]

Originally Posted by marksman

The author is an idiot if he does not think he is clearly violating their copyright.

He knows he is and is being a smart aleck about it.

I don't care if he had 1 billion dollars he would not win.

How is he CLEARLY violating copyright and being a smart aleck about it? He's obviously standing down and not risking having to go to court.

The coding, the images, graphics are all original and created by the developer. The Tetris Company has copyright claims to the "Tetris" name, music and game itself, but copyright doesn't cover the CONCEPT or IDEA of a game, which is the only thing that the developer "copied". Apparently, you have no idea how many hundreds of clones of Tetris and other games have been running around with impunity for YEARS. This is clearly a case of EA being greedy because their own official Tetris (cr)app is losing massive amounts of potential sales due to a free clone. Hell, if the developer would have named it "Trys" instead of "Tris," he'd probably be in the clear.

[otis123]

those tetris people are nuts when it comes to protecting that game, I think they will get anything with a T block in it removed.

[Liam191]

Brillant app been playing it 4 ages!!!!

[donga]

Originally Posted by jcde7ago

How is he CLEARLY violating copyright and being a smart aleck about it? He's obviously standing down and not risking having to go to court.

The coding, the images, graphics are all original and created by the developer. The Tetris Company has copyright claims to the "Tetris" name, music and game itself, but copyright doesn't cover the CONCEPT or IDEA of a game, which is the only thing that the developer "copied". Apparently, you have no idea how many hundreds of clones of Tetris and other games have been running around with impunity for YEARS. This is clearly a case of EA being greedy because their own official Tetris (cr)app is losing massive amounts of potential sales due to a free clone. Hell, if the developer would have named it "Trys" instead of "Tris," he'd probably be in the clear.

right. it's big corps throwing their weight around. if it weren't for him, when would tetris come to the app store? scrabble didn't come to fbook until after scrabulous became popular. if anything, these guys are helping the big corps find new markets