Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Stick or automatic?
- Thread starter 204467
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
robbieduncan
Moderator emeritus
You know what's even better than stick or auto? Polls. Which let you track the popularity of the answers...
Sun Baked
macrumors G5
The stick shift is generally cheaper to buy, since it usually doesn't cost $500-1500 more.
Cheaper to maintain, since the fluid is generally 100k, and unlike some automatics doesn't need to be changed every 30k miles.
And about the same cost when they need repair -- if you get one with the expensive dual mass flywheel.
---
Generally if you get in the habit of popping the vehicle into Neutral at stops, the stick is generally only a pain when the stop and go traffic is moving slow -- but not fast enough to let you rest of hobble along in 1st.
Cheaper to maintain, since the fluid is generally 100k, and unlike some automatics doesn't need to be changed every 30k miles.
And about the same cost when they need repair -- if you get one with the expensive dual mass flywheel.
---
Generally if you get in the habit of popping the vehicle into Neutral at stops, the stick is generally only a pain when the stop and go traffic is moving slow -- but not fast enough to let you rest of hobble along in 1st.
Right movie, wrong character. Ringo said it, you only get five awesome points. You should feel happy though; that's the first time I've ever given anyone that many! Yeah, I know, not very good logic. But hey, whatever...
Dude, I can't create a poll that fast. You need to learn how to wait and not be a jerk about it.
Me1000
macrumors 68000
I life in a rural area so there isn't a lot of stop and go traffic. I drive a 2000 Toyota Celica, with a 6-speed manual.
I think I would prefer a stick in any car of mine right now, at least with the current traffic conditions anyway. I can see how places like New York, San Francisco, etc. might drive (no pun intended) someone to an automatic though.
I think I would prefer a stick in any car of mine right now, at least with the current traffic conditions anyway. I can see how places like New York, San Francisco, etc. might drive (no pun intended) someone to an automatic though.
I'd say stick even though I drive an automatic. When I worked valet parking for a couple months, I didn't want to drive anything but stick, even though people don't usually bring their manual cars to valet them.
But Stick is generally faster, with exception to paddle shifters, save more gas and are more fun... but really suck in traffic and when you are stopped on hills.
Automatic can be fun too though.. look ma no hands!
But Stick is generally faster, with exception to paddle shifters, save more gas and are more fun... but really suck in traffic and when you are stopped on hills.
Automatic can be fun too though.. look ma no hands!
Stick FTW!
I live in LA and I still love it! Nothing like blowing through the canyons shifting through the gears!
Autos are boring 🙂
I live in LA and I still love it! Nothing like blowing through the canyons shifting through the gears!
Autos are boring 🙂
dukebound85
macrumors Core
yetanotherdave
macrumors 68000
It's still confusing to me that this is even a question. In the UK it's assumed that a car is manual transmission. If you want automatic you have to go searching for it. Everyone learns in a manual, if you learn in an automatic, you are restricted to automatic cars only.
I hate auto's. They don't know to change down when I want to really turn on the speed, they lag a second or two when you put your foot down, and I never know what to do with my left foot!
I hate auto's. They don't know to change down when I want to really turn on the speed, they lag a second or two when you put your foot down, and I never know what to do with my left foot!
Stick.
I find it humorous when people complain about using a stick in heavy traffic. If you learn to not actually stop then you won't be using the clutch so much.
Also, the clutch in most cars these is is so light it's almost funny. The heavy-duty clutch in my Mustang feels like I'm stepping on a plum after I get out of my work truck. If your leg is tired after holding in the clutch through one red light then you'd probably be crying if you had to do the same in my KW 😀
I find it humorous when people complain about using a stick in heavy traffic. If you learn to not actually stop then you won't be using the clutch so much.
Also, the clutch in most cars these is is so light it's almost funny. The heavy-duty clutch in my Mustang feels like I'm stepping on a plum after I get out of my work truck. If your leg is tired after holding in the clutch through one red light then you'd probably be crying if you had to do the same in my KW 😀
dukebound85
macrumors Core
majority of cars in us are autos. if you learn with an auto, you are not restricted to autos either
haha ive made the mistake driving an auto and using my left foot to slam the brakes thinking it was the clutch...
You don't realize what traffic is like in this area. You have to stop! Many times.