OK, so now the "light bulb" goes on in my brain. I did set up this external drive using my old Windows-based PC and can confirm I used NTFS. So where does that leave me? Is MacFUSE that simple to use, leaving the format as-is? Or should I just nix this whole idea and get another HD, dedicated solely to the Mac? I still use a PC part time and the wife also has one, so we'd like to be able to do some backups, but maybe this is asking for too many complications? Having a second, Mac-based HD may not be all that bad, either?