No HEAT problem with IBM 7200rpm/60GB; Apple tech is full of Bull Durham
maclamb said:
I am considering having a certified Apple tech install a 7200 RPM hitachi drive into my ibook G4 1G.
He said he is hesitant to do so as he has had problems with the heat from the drive "frying" the mobo. He said he has had ibooks come back after he has done this.
Has anyone actually done this/or knows someone (for real) who has done this- problems? issues?
Hi MacLamb.
A few days ago I finally received my 7200rpm 60GB (55.7 usable) Hitachi IBM 2.5" HD from ZipZoomFly.com (same price from NewEgg.com) $212, no tax, no S&H.
Install in iBook took me several hours and I would
not do it again, MacLamb is smart to pay a tech to do it.
NO HEAT problem whatsoever. IBM Runs cool, smooth and very quiet. Less active than 4200 rpm Toshiba that I removed. Highly recommend upgrade.
Self-install in
PowerBook is relatively easy and not a problem,
iBook is time consuming and difficult. Dangers include breaking the plastic bottom when removing, not putting all the screws back correctly (I had 3 left over, probably from the Combo Drive, and damage to things like the cable to touch pad "mouse", the hard drive or combo cable, power cables to various other parts, slip with screw driver and damage a circuit, etc. Let a tech do it.
One odd thing, the Toshiba 30GB HD I removed had
4 permanent black studs where one would expect screws on the sides, which fit nicely into 4 rubber grommets (or washers) 2 on aluminum strips - one on each side of the drive, for vibration dampening. Since NO screws are supplied with the new drive, I had to add 4 hard drive screws to the new IBM for it to install properly - this was unexpected but as long as you have the standard drive screws handy, it will not be a problem at all. Attached below is a photo of the old Toshiba drive - note the 4 black studs sticking out, 2 on each side.
Also, there was a nice thick clear plastic shield APPLE had stuck (like glue) to the bottom of the Toshiba, which I pulled off and applied to the bottom of the new IBM replacement drive to help protect its tender green underbelly of circuits. The old Toshiba will end up being inserted in a metal FireWire housing for a mobile 2.5" drive and I'm not as concerned with it as the nice new IBM. I'll find something to stick on it at that time.
Obviously, you have to Initialize (Erase) new HD with Panther install CD (disks 1 & 2) using
Disk Utility on the install CD, followed by a mandatory RESTART before new HD would be recognized by CPU. Initially it said, "you cannot install OS X on this drive" which threw me for a loop. So, I had to
name the blank drive "Macintosh HD" THEN the installer would allow me to install Panther on it, strange? Should have been automatic as part of install.
Apple really needs to make this 7200 rpm drive an under $200 option for "build to order" on all books, especially on the difficult to install anything inside iBooks. PowerBooks are way easy and very much do-it-yourself.
If I ever sell my iBook, i'll remove the IBM 7200 rpm drive because it is definitely a Black Pearl in the White Oyster shell.
To be blunt, that Apple tech is full of bull****. Check out info on xlr8yourmac.com, no where to you find support for his "heat problem" bull. I know at least 6 people with books who have had it done and all are very satisfied, including me.