Hi,
I just bought (and installed) the G.SKILL FM-25S2S-128GB 2.5" 128GB SATA II Internal Solid state disk (SSD) from newegg http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231221 for $229 and I thought in making it a review.
I am going to be quick today since I am on exams and I need to go back to study in a bit, but this weekend probably I will post some photos and benchmarks.
This is NOT the TITAN drive which is supposed to be better, however this one was considerable cheaper and for my first attempt I'd rather would get a cheap one, also this sets a "lower limit" (e.g. most drives, except for REALLY BAD ones, should be better.)
I have to say the drive performs really well, (some people claim everything is instant,... NO IT IS NOT INSTANT< NO NO NO) however pretty much every single loading time is cut in half, really word loads in 3seconds rather than 8 with the regular HDD, the system boots in seconds (~4x-5x seconds) rather than ~2mins with HDD, which IT MEANS A LOT (keep in mind that doubling the ram from 2GB -> 4GB can shave usually milliseconds, if you are lucky 1 sec or so, (A bit more for boot time, maybe 5secs).
Also everything seams a LOT faster due to the fact that its silent (no drama, you click, a delay, it opens, rather than you click, the HDD starts clicking, then a delay, then opens )
I have to say that the installation was not very easy in the sense that the manual I used did not have special instructions at the begining regarding what tools I'd need, so imagine when i got half the laptop open and I found I needed an stupid TORX #6 (10mm) screwdriver.... at 8pm in the night... and that time either put the computer back or go to homedepot running to get to buy it before it closed.......
Preliminary benchmarks are showing the drive's speed as about twice as my old hitachi HDD (e.g. if read in old HDD was 40MB/s in this one is about ~90MB/s or so (using xbench) I'll do better benchmakrs when exams over since then ones I did i was installing some programs at the same time so it could have interfered.
I did not expected any improvement in heat since most of my computer's heat comes from the back side where the CPU, GPU and RAM are located and makes sense since most of the heat is generated by them, so I did not expected any cooling improvement from exchanging the drive, however for my surprize the computer is running cooler (about 2ºC cooler, maybe a 3~4, however this could be due to the fact I actually cleaned it when i opened, so time will say) for now its nice to report that those ~2ºC have had a great effect since it seams it is enough to keep the fans @ 2K rpm which just enough for me to not notice them (I start notice them after 2500~3K rpm.
As for battery life, I did not expected either any improvement, however yesterday something weird happend, I had the computer unplugged, I saw a full movie (about 1Hour from the internet, so wireless was working also, the movie was HD also (not 1080 but 420p, hulu kind, so about average CPU usage)) and then I had the computer like another 2 hours on to read from web browser, so about 3H of battery life 1 hour of those watching HD (kinda) movie (usually I dont get that much,) also when battery was like at 10% it let me use the computer for 40mins, Im thinking this is due more to the fact I did not calibrate the computer for a while... so in future post I let you guys now.
Conclusions: Assuming reliability (I'd be happy if it doesnt break in the next 12months, or its performance doesnt drop, etc, e.g. it keeps working just as its been for the next 12months) it is the single best performance upgrade for your money even better than RAM. In fact if you are comfortable opening your computer and you own a MBP this is a must (for MB is arguable since $200 represents ~20% of the laptop itself). Regarding storage capacity this model offers 119GB (after formatted, it is the 128GB model) which for $230 isent particularly bad if you consider the performance boost and the other smaller advantages (such a slightly less heat, NOISE and perhaps better battery performance depending on what particular task).
Obviously if you want the best of the best you going to have to go for the TITAN or if you want even better then Intel, samsung or toshiba alternatives (~500-800 for similar capacity.)
I just bought (and installed) the G.SKILL FM-25S2S-128GB 2.5" 128GB SATA II Internal Solid state disk (SSD) from newegg http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820231221 for $229 and I thought in making it a review.
I am going to be quick today since I am on exams and I need to go back to study in a bit, but this weekend probably I will post some photos and benchmarks.
This is NOT the TITAN drive which is supposed to be better, however this one was considerable cheaper and for my first attempt I'd rather would get a cheap one, also this sets a "lower limit" (e.g. most drives, except for REALLY BAD ones, should be better.)
I have to say the drive performs really well, (some people claim everything is instant,... NO IT IS NOT INSTANT< NO NO NO) however pretty much every single loading time is cut in half, really word loads in 3seconds rather than 8 with the regular HDD, the system boots in seconds (~4x-5x seconds) rather than ~2mins with HDD, which IT MEANS A LOT (keep in mind that doubling the ram from 2GB -> 4GB can shave usually milliseconds, if you are lucky 1 sec or so, (A bit more for boot time, maybe 5secs).
Also everything seams a LOT faster due to the fact that its silent (no drama, you click, a delay, it opens, rather than you click, the HDD starts clicking, then a delay, then opens )
I have to say that the installation was not very easy in the sense that the manual I used did not have special instructions at the begining regarding what tools I'd need, so imagine when i got half the laptop open and I found I needed an stupid TORX #6 (10mm) screwdriver.... at 8pm in the night... and that time either put the computer back or go to homedepot running to get to buy it before it closed.......
Preliminary benchmarks are showing the drive's speed as about twice as my old hitachi HDD (e.g. if read in old HDD was 40MB/s in this one is about ~90MB/s or so (using xbench) I'll do better benchmakrs when exams over since then ones I did i was installing some programs at the same time so it could have interfered.
I did not expected any improvement in heat since most of my computer's heat comes from the back side where the CPU, GPU and RAM are located and makes sense since most of the heat is generated by them, so I did not expected any cooling improvement from exchanging the drive, however for my surprize the computer is running cooler (about 2ºC cooler, maybe a 3~4, however this could be due to the fact I actually cleaned it when i opened, so time will say) for now its nice to report that those ~2ºC have had a great effect since it seams it is enough to keep the fans @ 2K rpm which just enough for me to not notice them (I start notice them after 2500~3K rpm.
As for battery life, I did not expected either any improvement, however yesterday something weird happend, I had the computer unplugged, I saw a full movie (about 1Hour from the internet, so wireless was working also, the movie was HD also (not 1080 but 420p, hulu kind, so about average CPU usage)) and then I had the computer like another 2 hours on to read from web browser, so about 3H of battery life 1 hour of those watching HD (kinda) movie (usually I dont get that much,) also when battery was like at 10% it let me use the computer for 40mins, Im thinking this is due more to the fact I did not calibrate the computer for a while... so in future post I let you guys now.
Conclusions: Assuming reliability (I'd be happy if it doesnt break in the next 12months, or its performance doesnt drop, etc, e.g. it keeps working just as its been for the next 12months) it is the single best performance upgrade for your money even better than RAM. In fact if you are comfortable opening your computer and you own a MBP this is a must (for MB is arguable since $200 represents ~20% of the laptop itself). Regarding storage capacity this model offers 119GB (after formatted, it is the 128GB model) which for $230 isent particularly bad if you consider the performance boost and the other smaller advantages (such a slightly less heat, NOISE and perhaps better battery performance depending on what particular task).
Obviously if you want the best of the best you going to have to go for the TITAN or if you want even better then Intel, samsung or toshiba alternatives (~500-800 for similar capacity.)