How do you use and what do you use with your MBA? The ultimate set up?

I just picked up a used MBA Rev. A. It pretty much does everything I need that doesn't require graphics power. For games or CAD I have a PC desktop with an 8800GT. What is the 10% of stuff you do on your desktop? That may dictate if you should keep it as is, or what direction you could head in.

Personally the MBA fulfils all of my needs, if I had the money I would buy the apple 24" LED display, I could plug my superdrive, external usb 'media' drive and a keyboard into it and I would have the perfect set up.

I might actually buy it in the summer, the wife has a MB too so she could also use the display. Just with a Baby on the way I need to work out where in the apartment to put it

Going all the way Apple has distinct advantages since all machines "talk" to each other much better.

I have started with a Mac Mini (2 years ago) to be used as a media player in the home theater setup. Then got enticed by the platform and now I have moved into two MBAs (Rev A first, Rev B now) an iMac for my daughter and 8 months ago replacing also the main home computer with a MacPro.

The current setup is that MBA Rev B does under Mac OS X 90% of my professional needs (word processing / spreadsheets / presentations / mind mapping and of course email and web browsing), the other 10% being handled in WinXP under Parallels 4.0 (the SSD / Rev B MBA runs XP under Parallels extremely well), the reason being to ensure 100% compatibility with other colleagues work who are still "trapped" in XP - unfortunately Microsoft Office is not fully in Sync among Windows Office 2003, Windows Office 2007 and Mac Office 2008 (especially in the support of greek fonts).

Mac Mini (even the old version with the integrated graphics chip) is an excellent media player for everything except 1080p video (720p is handled quite well) provided you increase memory to 2GB and store your media in a NAS or other intranet disk device to have as much storage as you need.

MacPro with ample memory (I use 10 GB) is really THE workhorse for intensive computational work (HD video editing, Divx to DVD conversion and vice versa).

I know that the switching question (and cost) is an issue but I really cannot remember now the life before Mac OS X, at the time when the home network included a Windows machine (in the role undertaken now by the MacPro), when of course file sharing could work but you had to think of all sort of incompatibilities and solutions (e.g. NTFS handling, network setup for each machine to see the others, etc). If you think in a different perspective the cost incurred to switch is offset by the ease and speed of doing things under Mac OS X (and if you absolutely need Windows for the odd task, then Parallels is only a "click" away!).

All the best in whatever you choose to do!

The mini seems like the most logical choice to me.

If downloading torrents is important to you, I would keep the HP. In my unscientific experience, bittorrent clients are noticeably slower on my macs than my pc, an IBM ThinkPad. I use my Rev. A MBA as my primary computer and use the PC for torrents only.

I use the macbook air rev b as a netbook with a 13.3inch screen.

Why do you want another computer? It can be a serious pain to keep things segregated or synchronized between the two. If the MBA suits your computing needs, then I would keep the 24" screen and use that when you are "desk bound." I would spend money a good back-up system to go with your Time Capsule, more drive space, nice speakers, good printer/fax/scanner (laser? color laser?, GPS, good head phones, iPod Touch, bluetooth keyboard, nice mouse, software, etc. I just don't see a compelling reason to buy a second machine for the situation you've described.

Now if you want to set up a home entertainment system, then that is a different story...

sangosimo said:

I use the macbook air rev b as a netbook with a 13.3inch screen.

Click to expand...

You can't use a laptop as a netbook. It either is or isn't a netbook, and the air is not a netbook.

why cant you use it as a netbook. there is nothing stopping you. Thats a ridiculous statement

darngooddesign said:

You can't use a laptop as a netbook. It either is or isn't a netbook, and the air is not a netbook.

Click to expand...

"netbook" is a word that describes a type of notebook computer. If I use the air for cloud applications, browsing, and other low power general purpose tasks I am using it as a netbook.

wikipedia netbook article said:

A netbook (a portmanteau of Internet and notebook) is a class of laptop computer designed for wireless communication and access to the Internet.[1]

Primarily designed for web browsing and e-mailing, netbooks rely heavily on the Internet for remote access to web-based applications"[2] and are targeted increasingly at cloud computing users who require a less powerful client computer.[3] Netbooks typically run either Linux or Windows XP operating systems[2] rather than more resource-intensive operating systems like Windows Vista.[4] The devices range in size from below 5 inches[5] to over 13,[6] typically weigh 2 to 3 pounds (~1 kg) and are often significantly cheaper than general purpose laptops.[2]

Click to expand...

If your MBA is your main machine I would use that one with your ACD, not the torrent box.

If I were you I would probably sell the HP and it's screen and get a mini with some cheep 15-17 LCD. And keep the MBA with it's ACD as your main machine.

5

I do number 5 its the perfect setup power and portability ALL the time. Go 17 inch if you can.

I use my MBA as my ultraportable. Tethered to nothing but its power cable when needed. It goes with me everywhere and is not confined to any desk.

People don't believe the MBA can handle their computing needs because they don't realize how little/or how much machine they really need. People buy on spec's so they can brag to their friends about the spec's. Most people don't need anything near what they buy. I've used a MBA for everything I've done from email to video editing, it works for it all and does it well. Windows users are always in a mind frame they need a ton of hardware to keep the MS crapware running, then use OSX and realize OSX will do the job of windows with nearly half the computing power.

The MBA Rev B with SSD will blow away my windows desktop with a 2.4 C2D, 4gigs, 7200 rpm drive. SSD being the big part of it but even the processer due to 6 megs of L2 Cache and faster FSB makes a difference.

Rev A and Rev B are night and day in terms of hardware and performance. The stable Rev A's do make great "netbooks" the Rev B's do a very nice job of doing nearly anything you ask of it. The torrent issue is one of space, so I agree the MBA is not an option for that type of use.

sangosimo said:

"netbook" is a word that describes a type of notebook computer. If I use the air for cloud applications, browsing, and other low power general purpose tasks I am using it as a netbook.

Click to expand...

A netbook is a type of laptop, a low cost, under 11" laptop, which the Air is obviously not one, its is not a kind of computing activity. Its like saying you use your station wagon as a sub-compact car. You can drive both, but your wagon is not a sub-compact.

I use my MBA as my Primary Mac. I have a rev B with 1.86 GHz and SSD. For me, as well as everyone I know that has a rev B MBA, the rev B is a fully capable MAC! It does not need to be a "second" computer to any other Mac for MOST Mac users. Maybe a Mac Pro user, maybe as secondary to only people who want a mobile Mac. However, the MBA is very powerful and capable as a desktop computer. With my way of thinking, most people should sell their iMac or "other" Mac and migrate to the MBA with SSD, and a 24" ACD.

The 24" ACD really makes the MBA feel like a desktop computer. Not to mention, it has ALL of the cables built in for power and to use as the USB hub. I feel my setup is PERFECT, however I am thinking of making a small change.

Right now, I use my MBA as my primary Mac, and it functions as a desktop computer while using with my 24" ACD. I have a wireless KB, and a Bluetooth Logitech Mouse which is silver. I have an iPhone, iPod, and Camera plugged into my ACD. I also use an AirPort Extreme Base Station AND I have a USB printer and a hard drive attached to the AirPort Extreme Base Station. That allows me to move around files as my MBA's 128 GB SSD is just a little too small for my media files.

My kids use a v2,2 MBP as their media and gaming machine. I also use Windows on it for a client application one day per month.

For my setup, I was thinking an Apple Media Center Server would be awesome. Then, I would get rid of the MBP. Since Apple seems to be dissing all of us who want this product, I guess we are forced to consider the Mac mini. Since my 24" ACD will also work with a Mac mini, I have considered letting my kids use the 24" ACD with a Mac mini for all of their gaming and media watching/listening. The problem is there are two kids, and currently ONE MBP... and I refuse to let them use my al. MB, which hasn't been touched for months, and I refuse to let them use my MBA, for obvious reasons.

So, while I should sell the MBP and buy a Mac mini, I think I am going to buy a Mac mini and use it as a media server. I think I will plug it into the ACD and also use with LCD TV.

If you wanted to add a computer to make a "system" of sorts, I think the 24" ACD along with a Mac mini makes a LOT of sense. The Mac mini can be set to use the ACD whenever you are downloading files and etc and can always be the file server and media file server. The power cable from the ACD can always charge your MBA even when using the ACD with the Mac mini.

As a desktop plus notebook plus display setup, I think the best route is MacBook Air, Mac mini, and 24" ACD. Can always use both separately. Can always leave your MBA's charger in your notebook bag. Can always make your MBA a desktop in a one computer system while allowing a Mac mini to serve your media and downloading of torrent needs.

My two cents.

darngooddesign said:

A netbook is a type of laptop, a low cost, under 11" laptop, which the Air is obviously not one, its is not a kind of computing activity. Its like saying you use your station wagon as a sub-compact car. You can drive both, but your wagon is not a sub-compact.

Click to expand...

Netbooks can be over 13 inches and ha e established use patterns, so I can use a MacBook air a netbook. A suv can be used as a minivan (not a suv) to haul people or a truck (not a suv) to haul stuff. Minivans and trucks both have established usage patterns that help describe how the suv is used.

I've actually been playing around with the idea of getting a 'headless' macbook pro. I've seen some go for around $400. These things just have broken LCDs, which seems like an easy enough fix, but I don't even want it for that. I just need some type of desktop performance.

Anyone here who has the SSD version answer a newb question for me: Does that in anyway affect game performance (for instance I've been playing Left 4 Dead on my MBA)?

Thanks.

I have a macbook air (rev. B), a mac pro, and a macbook pro as my primary computers.

The MBA entirely replaces the macbook pro for me... so I would point you to get the mac mini.

I use mobile me and dropbox to keep all my computers in a wonderful form of sync.

sangosimo said:

Netbooks can be over 13 inches and ha e established use patterns, so I can use a MacBook air a netbook. A suv can be used as a minivan (not a suv) to haul people or a truck (not a suv) to haul stuff. Minivans and trucks both have established usage patterns that help describe how the suv is used.

Click to expand...

But that's not the analogy I used

Netbooks are small cheap computers for basic computing tasks. Ultraportables are full fledged laptops that are smaller and thinner than regular laptops. There is no badge of honor in paying 2 grand for a netbook; however, that does get you a stupid sticker.