CapsuleNeo or Silver Catena

[Churel]

Hi there, I just bought an iphone 3gs white and Im realy confused. Which case should I choose ?

More Thing engraved edition silver catena
http://www.more-thing.com/metallic-s...ne-3g-3gs.html



stunning design, slim body but lack of protection ?

SwitchEasy CapsuleNeo

http://www.switcheasy.com/products/Neo/Neo.php



grants nice protection, average design...

[Rayfire]

Some reviews are saying that the quality on those More-thing catena cases are poor, and if dropped could crack easily.

[Churel]

My CapsuleNeo Just arrived. I really like it. Looks good. I want to buy the white one also but I couldn’t find one anywhere.

[hybrid45]

Never saw that Catena case before but I have the Capsule Neo case on my phone. I'm more concerned with protection and the case proved its worth to me on one careless night.

I was wearing loose basketball shorts and getting out of my car. The phone slipped out, fell maybe 3 feet to my paved driveway, bounced maybe 3 times on its corners, then slid face-down said driveway about 5 feet. I picked it up, woke it from sleep, the iphone itself was immaculate but the case's edges were all dinged up. Needless to say, I think the case did it's job. Best $30 I ever spent on my phone.

[wingnut8]

I don't know if it was just my neo, but I had the white one and the spine part didn't fit tight. it always got dirt under it.

[Churel]

Originally Posted by hybrid45

Never saw that Catena case before but I have the Capsule Neo case on my phone. I'm more concerned with protection and the case proved its worth to me on one careless night.

I was wearing loose basketball shorts and getting out of my car. The phone slipped out, fell maybe 3 feet to my paved driveway, bounced maybe 3 times on its corners, then slid face-down said driveway about 5 feet. I picked it up, woke it from sleep, the iphone itself was immaculate but the case's edges were all dinged up. Needless to say, I think the case did it's job. Best $30 I ever spent on my phone.

Good to hear that . I think the same way this case rly provides protection.

Originally Posted by wingnut8

I don't know if it was just my neo, but I had the white one and the spine part didn't fit tight. it always got dirt under it.

Yea I got the dust problem, at the edges of the screen and also the edge pushes the screen protection film and makes bubbles on the screen. It seems the vertical spine sagging more and pops in n out day by day. But still it seems satisfying.

[Churel]

Today I kinda miss my iphone and decided to remove my CapsuleNeo. I see that the hard plastic spine isn’t hard anymore. The plastic become soften somehow, maybe my iphone warming up too much I don’t know but I don’t like the situation. So I decided to install the invisible shield which I bought beforehand. The installation process was like a nightmare. I struggle with it about 1 hr. and the final product was like a preschool notebook covered with plastic cover. I couldn’t make it. Believe me guys it’s not easy to install it’s not like the videos on the YouTube. Anyways its look like I’m still looking for the perfect or suitable case.

[Rayfire]

Originally Posted by Churel

Today I kinda miss my iphone and decided to remove my CapsuleNeo. I see that the hard plastic spine isn’t hard anymore. The plastic become soften somehow, maybe my iphone warming up too much I don’t know but I don’t like the situation. So I decided to install the invisible shield which I bought beforehand. The installation process was like a nightmare. I struggle with it about 1 hr. and the final product was like a preschool notebook covered with plastic cover. I couldn’t make it. Believe me guys it’s not easy to install it’s not like the videos on the YouTube. Anyways its look like I’m still looking for the perfect or suitable case.

Yup that's one PITA installation process, plus it requires a lot of patience too

Good luck on your search!

[ntrigue]

Originally Posted by Churel

Today I kinda miss my iphone and decided to remove my CapsuleNeo. I see that the hard plastic spine isn’t hard anymore. The plastic become soften somehow, maybe my iphone warming up too much I don’t know but I don’t like the situation. So I decided to install the invisible shield which I bought beforehand. The installation process was like a nightmare. I struggle with it about 1 hr. and the final product was like a preschool notebook covered with plastic cover. I couldn’t make it. Believe me guys it’s not easy to install it’s not like the videos on the YouTube. Anyways its look like I’m still looking for the perfect or suitable case.

I just cut mine to fit the part of the back that rests on a counter. I knew better than to deal with the edges and corners.