Weird Closed Captioning Issue

Ok, so I downloaded a movie from Itunes. When I play it on my computer, it plays just fine. When I play it on my ATV, I get closed captioning. I have downloaded other movies from itunes, and none of them have closed captioning on the ATV. Nothing else has closed captioning except this one movie. Is this a setting on the ATV somewhere? Could it be a setting on my TV? I am totally lost on how to get rid of the annoying closed captioning.