Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
68,264
39,066



Apple is partnering with various building companies to integrate its HomeKit platform directly into homes from the get-go, with the hopes that such ingrained smart home features will convince prospective buyers into sticking with the Apple ecosystem for the long haul. The news comes in a report by Bloomberg, which looked specifically at a four-bedroom stucco house in Alameda, California as one of Apple's many HomeKit-enabled properties coming to the market.

David Kaiserman, president of the technology division at construction company Lennar Corporation, walked Bloomberg through the potential advantages of buying a smart home from the start, mainly centering around the sometimes frustrating installation of devices like smart blinds and locks. In the home in Alameda, Siri responded to "Good Morning" light requests, while Apple's new Home app played music from connected speakers, and even ran a bath. All told, $30,000 worth of connected technology was integrated into the house.

smart-home-apple-800x532.jpg
The model smart home in Alameda, California


Apple's vice president of product marketing, Greg Joswiak, said that the company's goal with these so-called "test beds" of internet-connected smart homes is to eventually introduce complete home automation into a mainstream market, which could otherwise be tricky if users have to go out and buy dozens of separately-sold products. As such, Joswiak concluded that "the best place to start is at the beginning."
The gamble is that pricey wireless home devices will be an easier sell when bundled into the home itself. Builders market granite countertops and brushed-nickel fixtures at thousands of models homes across the U.S. Why not video doorbells?

"We want to bring home automation to the mainstream," said Greg Joswiak, Apple's vice president of product marketing. "The best place to start is at the beginning, when a house is just being created."
Purchasing a house with smart devices already installed doesn't appear to come at a discount, however. The $30,000 worth of products inside the Alameda home included devices like Lutron's automated shading system, which starts at $349, and the Schlage Connect Touchscreen Deadbolt, which retails for $199. As Bloomberg pointed out, "a regular deadbolt fetches $32 at Home Depot -- and there's always hiding a key under the flower pot."

Apple is said to be working with other builders besides Lennar, including Brookfield Residential Properties Inc., but neither company said when the smart homes would actually go up for sale. Kaiserman mentioned that he hopes working with Apple in the smart home market will produce a "halo effect," in any neighborhood that the homes sell in, convincing potential buyers that the new home has a "cool" factor that other properties nearby lack.

smart-home-apple-2-800x523.jpg

All the same, some people watching the rise in connected home devices believe "the hype may be getting ahead of the reality," with examples given centering around products like a wireless onesie for a baby that can turn on lights and play soothing music when the child stirs. Likewise, IDC analyst Jonathan Gaw cited "useless" products like the recently announced smartphone-controlled candle LuDela, which "only hurts the message. It tells people that we have gone too far. There's too much crap out there, it's only diluting stuff that's really cool."

For people interested in smart home tech, it's predicted that a total of $24 billion will be spent on home automation in 2016. While it may take a while for its popularity to catch on, research firm Strategy Analytics believes that number will jump to over $40 billion by 2020, potentially with the help of companies like Apple leading the way into whole-home integration of the technology.

Check out the full Bloomberg report here.

Article Link: Apple Working With Home Builders to Bolster HomeKit Adoption
 
In it's current status, HomeKit is pathetic compared to the competition. If anything Apple seems like it's pulling a Google here with introducing something and then losing interest.
Can you tell me what the competition is? Not being snarky, I am genuinely curious as I'm about to start automating my new home soon...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 24601 and bpcookson
I'm pretty techie so I don't mind troubleshooting a house like this.

My parents if they bought a home like this accidentally, it sounds like a nightmare. I can see it now, "Adam, we can't turn the ceiling fan off. I put my passcode in the iPad too many times and now all of the lights are yellow and the fans are running at full speed"

sigh, I'll be right over, Dad.
 
As long as the functionality is standardized and not Apple specific I see this as a good thing.
However, if it is something you have to rip out to upgrade in a few years, no thanks.
 
In it's current status, HomeKit is pathetic compared to the competition. If anything Apple seems like it's pulling a Google here with introducing something and then losing interest.
HomeKit has received improvements every year, no?

It's now native in iOS 10. I can flip up into Control Center on my iPhone/iPad and control favorite devices without leaving whatever app I'm in. You can now use an iPad to be a controller (instead of AppleTV being the only choice). I can control stuff natively from my Apple Watch, too. Super easy way to raise the garage door when I'm coming back from a bike ride.

It's far from being complete IMO, but with regular updates coming from Apple, I don't see how you can say they're losing interest in it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: doelcm82
Biggest issue with Home Kit is that it has no backwards compatibility. Doesn't work with my WeMo, myQ, Nest stuff I already own. You can it on Apple or those companies, either way it doesn't work. I don't plan on purchasing all new gear for HomeKit. At least my WeMo and Nest stuff works with Amazon Echo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wlossw and ohio.emt
Biggest issue with Home Kit is that it has no backwards compatibility. Doesn't work with my WeMo, myQ, Nest stuff I already own. You can it on Apple or those companies, either way it doesn't work. I don't plan on purchasing all new gear for HomeKit. At least my WeMo and Nest stuff works with Amazon Echo.
It's not as easy as buying an Amazon Echo to be a bridge to your MyQ and WeMo stuff, but I run the open source Homebridge software on a $30 Raspberry Pi to bridge my WeMo and MyQ devices to HomeKit and it's been working great.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Happy-Mac
HomeKit has improved every year. It's native in iOS 10. I can flip up into my Control Center and control favorite devices without leaving whatever app I'm in, or use Apple's Home app. With iOS 10, you can now use an iPad to be a controller (instead of just an AppleTV).

It's far from being complete IMO, but with regular updates coming from Apple, I don't see how you can say they're losing interest in it?

My fear?
Apple Keynote 2020: "For all of your current HomeKit users, in order to work with the latest version on your iDevices, you will need to upgrade your hardware. We realize this may cause some issues, however you must to do this in order to utilize the latest .... and use it on with iOS 14."

Home seller: "this house comes with HomeKit built in!"
Son of Potential Home buyer: "Dad... this is the old version. Doesn't work with the new stuff. You'd have to upgrade..."
Potential Home buyer: " Looks good. Let us think about this and we'll get back to you ..."
Later...
Potential Home buyer: "Thanks son!!! We dodged that bullet..."
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty techie so I don't mind troubleshooting a house like this.

My parents if they bought a home like this accidentally, it sounds like a nightmare. I can see it now, "Adam, we can't turn the ceiling fan off. I put my passcode in the iPad too many times and now all of the lights are yellow and the fans are running at full speed"

sigh, I'll be right over, Dad.

A while ago, I set up TightVNC on my grandparent's computer, gave myself remote access to their router, and using DuckDNS to manage their changing IP address from the ISP.

All of this is free, and it has saved me sooooo much time and headache. No more trouble-shooting over the phone.

"My yahoo won't open." "Hang on." *click click click* "Ok, it should work now."
 
It's not as easy as buying an Amazon Echo to be a bridge to your MyQ and WeMo stuff, but I run the open source Homebridge software on a $30 Raspberry Pi to bridge my WeMo and MyQ devices to HomeKit and it's been working great.

I've tried Homebridge on my Mac and a Linux box it was a major PITA. App kept crashing every couple of days or so. Also not a elegant solution. If someone comes out with a standalone product/hub I'd think about it.
 
My fear?
Apple Keynote 2020: "For all of your current HomeKit users, in order to work with the latest version on your iDevices, you will need to upgrade your hardware. We realize this may cause some issues, however you must to do in order to utilize the latest .... and use it on with iOS 14."
I'm sure that'll be the case, in one regard. A few years from now, I'm sure you won't be able to run the latest iOS on an AppleTV or iPad (which acts as a controller/automator when you're not at home).

But I don't see it ever being the case where folks are going to have to rip out the wired switches/outlets in their walls, or replace a ceiling fan or thermostat.
 
I think Apple needs to do something with reaching out to home-automation companies. The HomeKit price difference is a big barrier for the ecosystem. The cheapest way to get a switch is to buy a ZigBee switch for around $50 assuming that you have a hub like the NanoLeaf, but the same product from Z-Wave is $20. Simply adding HomeKit to a Z-wave hub would expand the ecosystem drastically and bring down the price.
 
I'm sure that'll be the case, in one regard. A few years from now, I'm sure you won't be able to run the latest iOS on an AppleTV or iPad (which acts as a controller/automator when you're not at home).

But I don't see it ever being the case where folks are going to have to rip out the wired switches/outlets in their walls, or replace a ceiling fan or thermostat.

As long as the controls are external or modular add-ons. If they are integrated ... :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: 69Mustang
Homekit is a mess right now. I was so excited for Apple's Home app in iOS10 as well, but that is just as bad. I think I've opened it twice. Siri is the only usable interface for home automation at the moment.

What we need is a standard. A 15th competing standard.
 
Biggest issue with Home Kit is that it has no backwards compatibility. Doesn't work with my WeMo, myQ, Nest stuff I already own. You can it on Apple or those companies, either way it doesn't work. I don't plan on purchasing all new gear for HomeKit. At least my WeMo and Nest stuff works with Amazon Echo.

My HA system is based on Indigo which runs on a Mac (for me a MacMini), and supports Z-Wave and Insteon protocols. There is an Indigo plugin that supports HomeKit. Though I don't use it now, I may in the future.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.