Apple TV 4 Reviews: Siri is Helpful and There's Loads of Potential

[MacRumors]

With the launch of the new fourth-generation Apple TV just a couple days away on Friday, October 30, the first batch of reviews for the new set-top box have arrived online. Most sites have come away with positive impressions of the new Apple TV, noting that Siri is extraordinary helpful and the inclusion of tvOS and apps give the device a lot of potential for the future.

BuzzFeed says that the biggest new feature on the Apple TV, the new Siri Remote, is a "drastic" improvement over the remote included with previous Apple TV remotes. The touchpad is "surprisingly accurate and easy" to use for pinpointing certain moments during a film or TV show. The universal search via Siri, however, will have longtime Apple TV users "resenting Apple for not enabling it sooner." Siri, according to BuzzFeed, is both useful and clever.

"Rewind 30 seconds," "Show me Anchorman," and "Who directed this?" all work well. And thanks to "What did he say?" -- which skips back to replay a character's comment with closed captioning, I finally know what Benicio Del Toro's character was mumbling in The Usual Suspects. ("I said he'll flip you. ...Flip you. Flip ya for real." Kind of a letdown. Don't even get me started on Lost in Translation.) Also: For a few glorious moments last night I was able to taunt my wife by repeatedly what-did-he-saying a favorite moment in Blue Velvet.

While The Verge also enjoyed Siri on the Apple TV, saying that the execution is "among the best in the game," they noted that there are several limitations in place. Siri only works with a handful of apps at the moment, including Netflix, iTunes, Hulu, HBO and Showtime. However, The Verge does mention that a Siri search API is on the way.

On apps, The Verge says that most tvOS apps are currently just very large iPhone apps. There are few apps that take advantage of TV, though they do note that apps like the QVC app show the potential of the new Apple TV and tvOS.

The QVC app is the only app that really and truly blends television with interactivity: it shows you a live feed of QVC, and it overlays the familiar information box on the left side of the screen with a buy button. So you're watching the regular QVC TV channel, and you can just click to buy, or swipe down to see more photos of the item and related items while the video keeps playing.

Mashable notes that setting up the Apple TV is extremely simple and easy if the user has an iPhone with iOS 9.1 installed.

Simply plug the Apple TV into HDMI and power and then use the Bluetooth connection from your iPhone or iPad to share information such as iCloud and iTunes Account preferences and your WiFi password.

However, Yahoo Tech says that while Siri and the new setup process make things simpler, users will still have plenty of text entry to do on the new device. Users still have to enter their user information in certain apps that require authentication, like Hulu or HBO Go. Unfortunately, Yahoo Tech's David Pogue says that the new on-screen keyboard is far more difficult and "excruciating" to use than the previous on-screen keyboard.

Finally, BuzzFeed mentions that the new Apple TV accessory, the Remote Loop, which is intended to keep the new remote from flying out of the hands of new Apple TV users who want to play games, is better used in another way.

But frankly, the loop is better used as a means of locating and rescuing the diminutive remote after it's gone missing between couch cushions. I've used it for this purpose at least three times so far, and given the loop's utility for this sort of thing, it's puzzling that Apple doesn't view it as a crucial part of the remote, instead selling it as a silly $13 accessory.

The new fourth-generation Apple TV is available for pre-order now and will be available in Apple Stores this Friday. It's available for $149 for a 32 GB version and $199 for a 64 GB version.

Other reviews: CNET, USA Today, Re/code, The Wall Street Journal.

Article Link: Apple TV 4 Reviews: Siri is Helpful and There's Loads of Potential

 

[Crosscreek]

I'll stick with my Roku for now.

 

[mellomike]

I've been playing with the dev kit for some time now and I'm loving the Apple TV.

 

[Jeremy1026]

Dev units still don't have an App Store. Here's hoping that these units are fully functioning and not intentionally crippled by Apple.

 

[nepalisherpa]

I'm surprised that Buzzfeed didn't write the review in bullet points: "10 features of the new Apple TV"

 

[aaronvan]

I'll buy it when it has a karaoke app.

 

[mrfrosty]

Any idea when Friday starts in Apple land ? I fly out of JFK at 9am on Friday but for sure I can be at Apple on 5th at around 00:01 on Friday morning.......

 

[RockSpider]

"and given the loop’s utility for this sort of thing, it’s puzzling that Apple doesn’t view it as a crucial part of the remote, instead selling it as a silly $13"
They can't know Apple too well, just another money grab.

 

[haruhiko]

I'm surprised that Buzzfeed didn't write the review in bullet points: "Top 10 features of the new Apple TV"

And each page only has half of a feature so that you have to press Next page 20 times to show even more ads

 

[ghost187]

It's an Apple Wii with free/$0.99 games for $149. This doesn't have to be "magical" to succeed or sell. Also, this is not the last Apple TV they will ever release, but it certainly is a substantial update and a step in the right direction.

 

[Bako-MacAddict]

Can't wait to pick mine up this Friday morning

 

[haruhiko]

"and given the loop’s utility for this sort of thing, it’s puzzling that Apple doesn’t view it as a crucial part of the remote, instead selling it as a silly $13"
They can't know Apple too well, just another money grab.

Is the Lightning connection strong enough to hold the loop in place when the force is strong enough to throw the remote towards your TV?

 

[RockSpider]

Is the Lightning connection strong enough to hold the loop in place when your force is strong enough to throw the remote towards your TV?

At $269 for me, it'll be a long time before I can answer that question, I'll wait this one out.

 

[cdavis11]

The omission of optical audio out is a deal breaker. I just don't want to upgrade my A/V stack to support this right now.

Really too bad, I would've been totally on board for day 1.

That said, if Elgato ever gets around to putting an Eye TV app on it I may be forced to drop some money on a new HDMI capable receiver.

 

[iJayden]

Siri is Helpful*

*In selected countries

 

[haruhiko]

Siri is Helpful*

*In selected countries

In 8 selected countries only, most of them speak the same language

 

[2010mini]

The delivery of my new Apple TV can't get here fast enough.

IMHO the "future" Apple will show us will come when they have their own live TV package. Then they will be able put their unique touch on TV

 

[Shookster]

Dev units still don't have an App Store. Here's hoping that these units are fully functioning and not intentionally crippled by Apple.

Never fear, an Apple employee confirmed there will be another update to enable it. No word on whether that will be pushed out on Friday or if we'll have to wait for it.

https://forums.developer.apple.com/thread/18615

 

[appledefenceforce]

" instead selling it as a silly $13 accessory."

Jeez Apple, gouging much?

 

[blackcrayon]

The omission of optical audio out is a deal breaker. I just don't want to upgrade my A/V stack to support this right now.

Really too bad, I would've been totally on board for day 1.

That said, if Elgato ever gets around to putting an Eye TV app on it I may be forced to drop some money on a new HDMI capable receiver.

Can't you just get a $25 adapter to tide you over?

 

[sziehr]

Can't you just get a $25 adapter to tide you over?

please link us to this adapter we all need.

 

[lunaoso]

please link us to this adapter we all need.

I assume he was referring to something like this: Panlong Hdmi to Hdmi and Optical Spdif + RCA L / R Audio Converter Hdmi Audio Extractor Splitter De-embedder (Hdmi In, Hdmi + Digital / Analog Audio Out) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00ISQ8VB8/ref=cm_sw_r_awd_zAymwb0J4WZWX

 

[adamneer]

I guess I'll have to find out for myself whether or not Siri will respond appropriately to the phrase "that's what she said".

 

[mcdj]

Ugh. No native Siri support for 3rd party apps like Plex out of the box. Way to announce the deal killer after you have my money.

 

[Jeremy1026]

Ugh. No native Siri support for 3rd party apps like Plex out of the box. Way to announce the deal killer after you have my money.

This was talked about fairly often once the SDK got into the hands of developers.