I don't think you need to spend anywhere close to $200 to get a good scotch. If you're going to spend that much money on a malt, make sure you can tell the difference in quality. I've had expensive malts that to me aren't as good as the one I picked up for $50. To the OP, the ones you've picked out shouldn't cost anywhere near $200... And tastes differ, but I wouldn't go for Highland Park.
None of those cost $200. The closest was the Macallan at $145.
I'm going away for a while, and want something very special for when I get back, and I'll spend close to $200 to get it.