I can't figure out a case to get for the iphone 4s, its a tossup between the defender or the commuter with the active holster. I understand the commuter has no apple logo protection, that being said, I have a back screen protector along with the front, and if I used clear packing tape to cover the inside and outside of the RUBBER part where the hole is, this would block the dirt and dust from going on. Or the defender and id take out the front screen protector that is built in. What do you all think? I can't decide, I don't want to bulk but I want a holster and protection.