Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

YoNadz

macrumors regular
Original poster
Jun 12, 2009
147
8
St. Louis, MO
So, we just purchased a 27" iMac 5K. I've had been trying to digitize our entire DVD library to iTune with Handbrake so we are able to watch movies on our Apple TV. Recently my DVD rips are all pixelated and jumbled. Anyone know what I'm doing wrong? The rips turn out fine on our ancient Windows laptop, but I really want to do this on our new mac...
 
Its usually best to rip an image of the disc contents before transcoding with Handbrake. I havent tried ripping directly from the disc as it usually takes signifigantly longer, so I use MakeMKV to rip the movie into an MKV file first and then transcode from that file. To my recollection, pixellated images usually occur when ripping directly from disc, this is because ofthe Macrovision copy protection which is supposed to be alleviated if you have a copy of the 64bit VLC installed to decrypt it (Handbrake with automatically detect it).

Anyway, rip with MakeMKV first into a file, and then transcode that using the AppleTV preset.

Oh, and a tip. MakeMKV isn't free, but you can use it as a trial before it disables itself after a new version is released. So to get around it, I run the app in a Windows virtual machine I created and duplicated the VM's image. Meaning I have a clean Windows 8 VM running in Parallels, of which I've duplicated as a backup copy on my HD.
  • Then in Parallels I install MakeMKV on one clean image, use the app until it expires (then you won't be able to use it anymore).
  • Delete the Windows image (because you can't reset the trial)
  • Duplicate the previous clean duplicated image
  • Rename it to match the original image
  • Install MakeMKV again.
  • Keep going where you left off
  • Process takes about 5 minutes and you're back up and running.
 
Last edited:
I just downloaded and installed VLC. Hopefully that alone will fix the problem. Trying to encode with Handbrake again now.
 
MakeMKV (free)>Handbrake (free; using ATV preset)>Done

Don't make this hard. It's not.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.