iMac G5: Rev. A vs. Rev. B

[gregorydanger]

Just a question.

A while back I got my hands on a rev. A iMac G5 and ended up getting rid of it because the fan just would not shut off. I know that sounds completely stupid but trust me, it WAS ridiculous. I was running the OS in "Reduced" processor mode (as opposed to "Automatic") and all I'd be running was Safari and the fan would just start going crazy. I can't stress the keyword "loud" enough.

Anyways.

Other than that I loved the machine. If it hadn't been so loud I would've held onto it. I've heard that this problem has been fixed in the most recent release of the iMac (Rev. B) but I just want to know if this is true before I went out and bought one. I doubt that I'd get a straight answer talking to a "genius" at an Apple store so I figured I'd just ask here.

If anyone has some insight I'd be very glad to hear it. Thanks!

 

[shadowmoses]

The Rev B's in general are supposed to be far quieter although some are still apparently quite loud...

Also your Rev A was robably one of the un-lucky one's which was very loud as not all rev A's were loud....

If you want a quiet iMac G5 the Rev B's should be fine and if it is loud im sure apple will swap it over under warranty..

ShadOW

 

[eXan]

I agree with Shadow, you've got a deffective version of iMac. But their generally quite

 

[Vanilla]

I bought a revision B iMac G5 17" and returned it the next day, because of an incredibly annoying buzzing sound coming from the bottom left hand side, facing the screen, which kicked in whenever I actually did anything on the machine. I replaced it for a 20" version and the difference is like night and day. Quiet, fast, beautiful screen etc.
Vanilla

 

[Dreadnought]

Sounds to me more sensors that are off! Just like the rev A of the dual 2.0 powermac...

 

[gregorydanger]

I appreciate all of your responses.

Generally, I find it a little disheartening that Apple would release a system that you basically have to buy to find out if it'll run properly. I understand the issues regarding the G5 processor, particularly in the iMac, but you'd think that they'd take a few extra steps to prevent machines that don't run up to par from getting out there.

Regardless, I think I'm going to pick up another one (base 17" model) and hope all goes well. If I have problems I'll just return it. Again, thanks for the tips!

 

[Shai-Nadir]

From what I have heard and personally experienced, the Rev. B models are hit and miss when it comes to the noise level. While some state that their imacs are whisper quiet, my Rev. B 20" imac had a "whirring noise" that would get louder as the computer got hotter. It became so annoying that I ended up selling it. It was a nice machine but was too loud for my taste.