Hi I have a 5th generation iPod and I have the extended warranty on it, so if it is broken I want to get it fixed now while I can. When I bought it I bought a rubber sleeve the same day so I never really payed attention. But now that I have it out of the sleeve I see the middle button is slightly depressed lower that the outer track piece. It does not feel right when I press on it. It works, but I thought the button was flush with the track wheel? I thought it should have a definate 'click' to it when pressed, but it kind of rocks and feels wobbly. But the rubber sleeve I suspect masked that feel so I never noticed. It is flush on my nano, but not sure about this one and I have not found anyone I know who has one for me to compare to. Anyone one who has one of these and is your middle button flush with the outside track? Thanks for your help.