Is the MBA a Good Replacement for the 12" PB?

Discussion in 'MacBook Air' started by iDAG, Jan 16, 2008.

?

What Do You Think?

  1. Yes, the MacBook Air is the perfect replacement for the 12 inch PowerBook G4

    38.5%
  2. No, the MacBook Air is not the perfect replacement for the 12 inch PowerBook G4

    49.6%
  3. I am not sure yet...

    12.0%
  1. macrumors 65816

    iDAG

    #1
    Now that there is a new Apple Ultra Portable, will 12 inch PowerBook users upgrade to the MacBook Air?

    EDIT: Please explain why you do or don't think it is a good replacement.
     
  2. macrumors member

    notengolegs

    #2
    Sure, considering that the latest 12" Aluminum PowerBook sold for $1,699 when it came out.
     
  3. macrumors regular

    #3
    It's a no from me. I'd like to upgrade my 12" powerbook, but not to a MBA. Bottom line: The PB suits my needs, MBA doesn't.
     
  4. macrumors 65816

    iDAG

    #4
    What don't you like about it?
     
  5. macrumors 68020

    #5
    It's not ANY sort of replacement for the 12" PB, let alone a good one.

    A replacement for the 12"PB should be a 12" MBP. Proper, large HDD, Firewire, Optical Drive, Discreet graphics.

    The PB range (and the MBP range) are a productivity tool. The MBA is a lifestyle product.

    Doug
     
  6. macrumors G4

    #6
    For me it's the small storage capacity, the unexpandable memory, the lack of FireWire port and that you can't carry two batteries around and swap them when one is depleted. All things the PB12" has.
     
  7. macrumors newbie

    #7
    Its funny that this thread came up, because my 12" pb died a week ago and I was waiting on mwsf to see what to get. Honestly, I like the macbook air and I can see where it fits into the market, but its just not for me. I don't need a computer that THAT thin, the macbook would do fine. I was really holding out for a 13.3" macbook pro with standalone graphics and a >2.0ghz c2d. Oh well, I guess al 12" pb lovers were holding out for a reincarnated verson, and while I don't think the macbook air is a bad computer, I wouldn't choose it to replace my pb.
     
  8. macrumors 6502a

    #8
    I think it is. Similar screen size, same idea when both were launched.

    a MB or a MBA are good replacements for a 12" PB
     
  9. macrumors 68000

    taylorwilsdon

    #9
    Hell to the no. Its a good replacement to the clamshell. Form over substance is a big no no.
     
  10. macrumors member

    Polish97

    #10
    People are being greedy...

    Everyone wants what they had and more...

    ...but do you use all that you have?

    The key to this ultramobile is the accessories. If you buy the $1800 config, expect to by:

    - $20 USB Hub (for the mouse you like, 3G connection, etc)
    - $30 ethernet dongle - For speedy intercation with the network at job.
    - $250 80GB iPod Classic - For the 45GB of music and videos you have.

    It's missing firewire, optical drive, and what 5lbs.

    Give specifics to it's short comings to you, and why. There maybe better and cheaper solutions to your problems the MBA might solve.
     
  11. macrumors regular

    #11
    It's not that I don't like it. I just don't think it'll suit my day-to-day use as well as my PB still does.

    The PB is my secondary computer, but I still need a dvd drive/burner, I need firewire and ideally 2 usb ports. Otherwise the MBA sounds fine (and would be easier to lug around on my push bike).
     
  12. macrumors 68030

    iMpathetic

    #12
    I'd say to stick with the PB as long as you possibly can. My old language arts teacher had an 867MHz that had a broken hinge, five dents, and one RAM slot broken but still refused to get a new computer. Now that's devotion.

    I think that the 4:3 ratio actually makes a computer feel tidier and smaller, IMHO. If that's gonna be your second computer, you'll do fine with it.
     
  13. macrumors 6502a

    Ryox

    #13
    The MBA is not for me. Personally I need a bit more from my note books.
    As a replacement, in my opinion its good, but not good enough. I love the light thin design but not so drawn to it because of the lack of power
     
  14. macrumors 68040

    CrackedButter

    #14
    The MB is the best replacement for the 12" PB, I had a 12" PB and upgraded from it to a MB.
     
  15. macrumors regular

    #15
    I love a beat up powerbook - it adds character... Mine has a nice upward bend on the front/bottom left from when I dropped it from shoulder height. Bet the MBA couldn't take that :p
     
  16. macrumors 6502

    #16
    I say yes, but only for people who don't want it for productivity. If all you need it for is music, the occasional ripped movie, internet(browsing/email), and maybe even some photoshop it is fine. As long as you don't do video editing(firewire is killer here for connecting to cameras and storage) or need constant access to a disc, it would be perfect. But no doubt it is limited compared to an MB or MBP for productivity purposes. I myself may get one for my wife(not any time soon though, she won't allow herself to get a new laptop until her current windows one which is less than a year old dies.. plus I want to get a Mac Pro) who never does anything strenuous or disc based with her laptop.
     
  17. macrumors 603

    HLdan

    #17
    Actually it was $1799, same as the Air.
     
  18. macrumors 603

    HLdan

    #18
    Well, I voted that the Air is the perfect replacement of the 12" Powerbook, here's why:

    When the 12" Powerbook came out it fit the needs of what was going on or was about to happen in the industry of computing. It was a small form factor for the business class.
    It had an option for a Superdrive and burning DVD's was relatively new at the time. It was a pro model in the sense of the aluminum because it was the first full aluminum notebook along with the 17" and it had an option for wireless since wireless was still relatively new.

    The Air is the perfect replacement because it fits the needs of what's going on or about to happen in the industry of computing. It's fully wireless, it's sooo wireless that it will even read the optical drive of another computer to install software wirelessly.

    It fits the business class very well in terms of size and speed. It's still aluminum. It has an option for a Superdrive, it finally has the backlit keyboard (missing on the 12" PB), it has extensive trackpad touch capabilities and it runs two of the best OS's natively which makes it even better for anyone, it has more ram than the 12" Powerbook could even max out at.
     
  19. macrumors member

    #19
    Mine has the bend on the front right corner:rolleyes: I definitely do not think it is a good replacement for my 12 incher. Requisites for this title would have to be dedicated graphics, superdrive and latest processor. Basically, I want a MBP 13 inch ~$1500. That's the sweet spot.
     
  20. macrumors 68030

    #20
    iDAG - if you've been here the last 2 days, you should know that your question/poll is moot. That the contingent here would vote down the MBA no matter what you compared it to - be it a pencil, rock, or soda can.
     
  21. macrumors 6502

    #21
    I am still hoping for one day for a fully functional 12-13 Pro notebook that would be speced along the lines of the specs that djellison mentioned already.
     
  22. macrumors 604

    thejadedmonkey

    #22
    If the MBA had firewire, a 2nd USB port, and ethernet, it would be the PERFECT replacement for the MacBook.

    It's lacking almost every port imaginable, however, so it won't work for anyone who just wants a desktop replacement.

    If it won't work as a desktop replacement, it'll never work for the pro crowd..

    So, that leaves us with the consumerist who's no more advanced then your average tween. My dad, for one, would see it, think it looks wicked cool, never ever know what firewire is.. and get it.

    Actually, most people probably would. Heck, I would, if I could afford it.

    and then he'd have to get another mac when he finds out he can't use his camcorder with it...

    _______________________
    In this day and age, a desktop replacement isn't something with a 5000000ghz CPU and 24657567MB's of RAM, it's simply a computer that can function as your main computer.​
     
  23. macrumors 68040

    tdhurst

    #23
    Opinions

    I am a proud owner of a 1.5ghz, 12" powerbook and the MBA is most decidedly NOT a worthy replacement for me.

    I use my powerbook as my main (okay, only) machine and replacing it with a macbook air severely reduces the functionality I would have. Part of the reason I've always like Apple laptops is that you get full featured machines in a portable form.

    HOWEVER, if I was also an iMac or Mac Pro (or powermac G5) owner, the MBA would most assuredly be my next purchase, as I would have my desktop to rely on.

    That being said, the MacBook Air is not a bad machine, it's just a niche machine. It's great at what it does (satisfy a hefty chunk of most computer users' needs in a lightweight, easily transportable case), but nothing more.

    Very cool, but I'll be looking more at the MacBooks when it's time to replace my baby.
     
  24. macrumors 68040

    tdhurst

    #24
    Perfectly said here.

    I think the Macbook Air is the laptop version of the iPod touch. Has some of the cool, high end features, but sacrifices others.

    Looks awesome though.
     
  25. macrumors 68000

    bc008

    #25
    i would say no.
    take that same money and buy a blackbook for a lot less
     

Share This Page