Look, I am still absolutely amazed that so many people insist that they will gladly shell out 300 dollars for a glorified wireless hub with TV out. Still, I wonder why the ipod dock never got its chance at fulfilling the need in the living room.
Apple would only have needed to do the following:
1. Build a better interface for ipod + tv-out.
Just do front-row on the ipod...it cant be that hard...shoot, they're doing games arent they?
2. Component out...component out!...COMPONENT OUT?!?!?!?
This makes no sense. The itunes store is not selling HDTV content, yet the iTV has component out. something which the vast majority of televisions out there do not have. Most TVs out there...probably between 60-80% have s-video. S-video does a great job at around 480p, which is essentially what itunes is peddling. Coupled with the same interface that the front-row app uses your media from itunes can easily be synced down to your device, and then you can easily plug in your trusty ol ipod right next to your tv.
This, to me, makes perfect sense.
At the very least, they could have made another iteration of the airport express and uses s-video there.
I gotta rant: that entire presentation was bizarre by Apple standards...why introduce a product that isnt coming out for another 6-8 months? Why create a product like this that only about 10% of the market could even use. Why create a product that isnt even capable of doing everything its cracked up to do since the media isnt ready or available?!
Heck this all just stinks of reactionary engineering. Everyone has their hands in some sort of HD thing. Sony and Blu-ray are positioned for the living room, even Microsoft has their foot in the door and a$$ in the couches of america with over 1 million xbox 360s ready to deliver HD content into your home (oh, and tie in the Zune for a complete picture)...And this is all Apple can come up with?!
This thing is weak, expensive and poorly designed...
Apple would only have needed to do the following:
1. Build a better interface for ipod + tv-out.
Just do front-row on the ipod...it cant be that hard...shoot, they're doing games arent they?
2. Component out...component out!...COMPONENT OUT?!?!?!?
This makes no sense. The itunes store is not selling HDTV content, yet the iTV has component out. something which the vast majority of televisions out there do not have. Most TVs out there...probably between 60-80% have s-video. S-video does a great job at around 480p, which is essentially what itunes is peddling. Coupled with the same interface that the front-row app uses your media from itunes can easily be synced down to your device, and then you can easily plug in your trusty ol ipod right next to your tv.
This, to me, makes perfect sense.
At the very least, they could have made another iteration of the airport express and uses s-video there.
I gotta rant: that entire presentation was bizarre by Apple standards...why introduce a product that isnt coming out for another 6-8 months? Why create a product like this that only about 10% of the market could even use. Why create a product that isnt even capable of doing everything its cracked up to do since the media isnt ready or available?!
Heck this all just stinks of reactionary engineering. Everyone has their hands in some sort of HD thing. Sony and Blu-ray are positioned for the living room, even Microsoft has their foot in the door and a$$ in the couches of america with over 1 million xbox 360s ready to deliver HD content into your home (oh, and tie in the Zune for a complete picture)...And this is all Apple can come up with?!
This thing is weak, expensive and poorly designed...