I used to love speck, but lately I've had trouble with them cracking in a spider web like shatter, all without even hitting it against anything. I'd go with incase. Also, the speck bottom stays on by clipping on to the rear corners. Sometimes they will unclip, which can cause it to slip out of your hand if you pic it up with one hand. The incase bottom clips on to the rear vent pocket, all the way across. I also recommend the incase canvas coated sleeve.