Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Microsoft Releases New Anti-iPad Ad Highlighting Surface Accessories
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I agree. I'm in the Apple "ecosystem" with most of my media purchases and I still love my original gen iPad.
If I were in the MS/Xbox ecosystem, I would most likely have a Surface RT. My brother-in-law has one and it isn't bad. It does what he wants it to do and I don't see much of anything missing for my needs. Both supplement a desktop/laptop; neither replaces desktops/laptops imo.
I also liked the ad for its comical value.
*edit* - by "supplement desktops/laptops, I mean it in the sense of the things I do on my desktop (Aperture, video editing, typing more than 2 or 3 lines, etc). I understand that the RT is not strictly a tablet.
The Surface was never going to work. Many people said so at the launch. Even MS's own developers think it's a dog. When you have to explain what it is it's automatically a fail. Most people want simple to use. The iPad works because you just pick it up and go. The iTunes Store is head and shoulders above the competition.
If Apple made a cheaper mass market laptop or Google made an Android desktop rather than those limited Chromebooks, Microsoft would be toast.
But the RT is the reason they are in the can... The RT is failing. They already haved the number ordered, and they can't even sell that small number... They are in trouble. I assume there is a really big trench being prepared for the massive number of RT's and Pro's that are being gathered... Maybe they will be interned near the Zunes...
I agree with this. There wasn't anything in this ad that made me feel I should consider the Surface.
It's like watching the Titanic sinking.
And no one is responsible either... They just go through time screwing up one product after another.
Maybe this time will cost Ballmer his job?
Selling a computer (broadly speaking) on minor accessories is a losing proposition when it's not totally compatible with a dominant software ecosystem. I'm not spending hundreds of dollars for a keyboard and kickstand, I'm spending hundreds of dollars for a product that serves my needs - to wit, what apps/programs can I run on it?
Keyboard? both tablets have 'em available, iPad has a whole lot more - so many more options that doesn't bother making one.
Stand? same idea. So the Surface has one built-in...and word is it's cheesy, and methinks it will be broken not long after my kids (good ones at that) get done with it (at 3 & 5, they'll just do something not knowing it will break nor understand the consequences).
USB? meaningful to a non-trivial number of customers, but not a benefit to the rest. It doesn't have a DVD or 5.25" floppy drive either.
So...what can the Surface do?
Keyboard? both tablets have 'em available, iPad has a whole lot more - so many more options that
doesn't bother making one. Stand? same idea. So the Surface has one built-in...and word is it's cheesy, and methinks it will be broken not long after my kids (good ones at that) get done with it (at 3 & 5, they'll just do something not knowing it will break nor understand the consequences).
USB? meaningful to a non-trivial number of customers, but not a benefit to the rest. It doesn't have a DVD or 5.25" floppy drive either.
So...what can the Surface do?
Further proof that Microsft just doesn't get it. And don't be fooled, they REALLY think their tablet is way better than the iPad. They REALLY don't understand why their products are failling so amusingly.
Remember the Zune?
The day that google comes out with Android or Chrome desktop OS, whatever they will call it, with a free set of office apps is the day Microsoft will close.
Remember the Zune?
The day that google comes out with Android or Chrome desktop OS, whatever they will call it, with a free set of office apps is the day Microsoft will close.
Uh...if your iPad has a stand it must be a cheap knockoff. No iPad has a stand built in
apple makes a stand for the ipad in the same way that MS makes a keyboard for the surface. neither one comes with it.
THey won't go away over the RT and Pro, but I would wonder what kind of conversations are going between Google and Microsoft...
Kind of funny. I admit I love my iPad mini, but miss my expandable storage from my Android Tablet (Acer A500). I just had to uninstall several games and remove all my music to get SWKOTOR to install.
Commercials might not be working, but...they are kinda true. What is actually false about the commercial (technically speaking) ?
Commercials might not be working, but...they are kinda true. What is actually false about the commercial (technically speaking) ?
WIN 8 is just as much a problem as the RT. 8.1 is still an unknown. Our IT won't go near WIN8. We have no plans to move off WIN7 Enterprise any time in the next year. It's too bad in some ways. I actually like WIN8 Mobile. It's simply to much of a risk for many currently.
Take a look at the stock quote. Ouch. The week chart looks like you could make a free-fall jump, the curve is so steep.
The funniest thing about all these ads is that they are based on showing a feature the iPad has but the Surface RT lacks.... the ability to talk to you.
The iPad just needs to say "yeah, well I can TALK." And then walk away.
I had an employee at a kiosk show me the RT. It made sense, but I really didn't see anything it did that the iPad couldn't do that I'd miss. Oh, and he kept saying (because this was 'pre-Pro' time) that I should wait for the Pro when it came out and I'd really want to get one of those. Now, thinking back on it, I'm glad I didn't pre-order a Pro. I considered it, but figured with all of the bad press from the RT, I could just imagine how bad the 'Pro' would turn out to be.
As far as I know the kickstand is included. But I can't confirm, as I have never seen a surface out there..
The conversation here is so much different than the fights over android phone vs iPhone. It's the same iOS and the reception is loads different between iPhone and iPad. Without adding in my own opinions, I'm just curious to why?
So the Surface is like one of those £20 LCD photo frames? Oh, wait it's got a USB port where I can transfer the photos from my PC where I previously transferred them from my camera. Ugh, people still do all that rigmarole? Oh no, its okay, it's just a netbook. That explains the price.
Edit: Just to make my actual point - everything Microsoft points out as their advantage (other than the price) is exactly the sort of legacy hindrance that Apple deliberately left behind. Microsoft are too stupid to see it. The iPad is just one object with no moving parts, you hold it and use it in your hand, not hunched over its tiny screen and keyboard at a desk and not by fiddling about with crappy bits of plastic sticking out of every edge.
Edit: Just to make my actual point - everything Microsoft points out as their advantage (other than the price) is exactly the sort of legacy hindrance that Apple deliberately left behind. Microsoft are too stupid to see it. The iPad is just one object with no moving parts, you hold it and use it in your hand, not hunched over its tiny screen and keyboard at a desk and not by fiddling about with crappy bits of plastic sticking out of every edge.
Last edited:
You make a great point -- the kickstand is built right into the standard cover. And doesn't the small type on the screen indicate that the "real keyboard" is an optional accessory? The iPad also offers a "real keyboard" -- lots of 'em, in fact, that consumers can choose based on a range of criteria.
That you "Must have a USB Port" to be a Tablet.
It does not say that in the commercial. It says "I'm sorry I don't have a usb port" which is accurate.