Well this is interesting. Even though the nice folks at Quirky confirmed the cancelation of my Quirky Cloak order several weeks ago, one showed up in my mail today any way. The case I received is the black one. Initial reaction: what a disappointment. -VERY heavy. 1 pound, 7 ounces on our postage scale, compared to 7 ounces for the Apple iPad case. <<edit: that was a typo- weight is 1 pound 4 ounces>> - Dirt magnet. If you think the Apple case collects dirt, this one appears to be even worse. Right out of the box the cover was covered with little white dust specks that do not come off, or at least don't come off easily. The rubberized cover is very tacky (in feel) which is why it seems to attract dust so easily. Unlike the Apple case, the dust/dirt don't seem to wipe off easily either. These two factors alone make the case a deal breaker for me. Your mileage may vary.