Ok i need help writing a decent song rating criteria, so i can allow anyone to rate my songs without arguing what rating a song deserves. i have written this so far, but i know it needs to be added to. opinions will be appreciated. Thanks Bobak 5 Stars (Excellent): Exceptional in at least two different categories, such as: lyrics, rhythm vocals, instrumental skill. parodies (or non-sense) songs cannot be awarded 5 stars. neither can songs that make any reference to modern technology. (with exceptions of course) 4 stars (Good): Exceptional in at least one category. must be continuously good throughout the song. 3 Stars (Mediocre): Any song that is decent, but not exceptional in any category. One weak point allowed. Such as : Bad timing, poor vocals, etc... Songs that are just bass cannot be awarded more than 3 stars (with exceptions). 2 Stars (Poor): Shows Minor Skills in any category. Non-impressive. 1 Star (Awful): Shows no skill what so ever, or unbearable to listen to.