ummm I dont understand how a few of the previous posts can say Apple TV has no place or they cant understand the product.
Simple ... I record all my TV on my Mac in my office at home BUT like 99% of most households when I site down to TV after getting home from work I dont want to stuff about with keyboards and mouse or watch it on my mac.
Whats not to get ????
I dont get why people dont get it
In other words, if you are one of the few people out there who uses a Computer as a PVR (like I do), or store a lot of other video files on your Mac (ditto)...
But you DON'T have that media-center computer hooked up to... you know... a media center.
So
TV is a $300 way of doing what a good HDMI cable would do for you, oh and you have to give up surround sound to do it, since the
TV outputs stereo only. Yay.
A much better solution:
Buy a computer (the Mac mini is as good a choice as any), hook it up to an HDTV system (or a really big computer monitor if the room is small enough), use bluetooth keyboard & mouse from your comfy recliner.
Now you don't need an
TV, nor do you need office furniture, nor do you need a separate TV/Monitor. You just saved a fortune.
"But I want my computer in the office and the TV in the living room"
No problem. Use a MacBook. When you want to watch TV, carry it into the living room and plug it in to your TV set. When you would rather use it as a computer in the den, unplug it from the TV and carry it back to your desk. Done.
Yes, if you MUST keep your iMac (or whatever) in another room and you MUST be able to watch files from THAT computer on your TV set and you DON'T have any media files incompatible with (or poorly performing on) the QuickTime engine and you DO have an HDTV and you DON'T mind that many of the available content is not in high-def and you DON'T mind that your media will not be in true surround... Then congratulations, you are one of the six or seven people in the world for whom the
TV is the best possible solution.
For everybody else, the
TV is a poor substitute for just plugging a mini into your TV set, and before you start going off about the price of a mini vs. $300... keep in mind that those who own wide-screen TV's are people who are willing to pay more for the better media solution. Hooking up a computer directly is BY FAR the better solution, to the point that somebody with a $5000 TV set at $2000 sound system will not sneeze at paying an extra $400 to do it right.